Architect Stanford White was shot three times at close range by millionaire Harry Kendall Thaw during a performance of Broadway comedy ‘Mamzelle Champagne’ on 25th June, 1906. At first, the stunned audience thought it was part of the show.

Thaw claimed White had “ruined” his wife, showgirl Evelyn Nesbit - often called America’s first ‘It Girl’ - who at just 16 had been lured into White’s orbit and ‘seduced’ by White - though a reading of Nesbit’s diary makes it sound a lot more like rape. 

But sadistic playboy Thaw was no knight in shining armour himself. His legal defense introduced the bizarre concept of dementia Americana—a supposed burst of "patriotic insanity" any red-blooded man might feel upon learning his wife had been wronged. Astonishingly, it worked. 

In this episode, Arion, Rebecca and Olly consider (yet another) ‘trial of the century’; reveal what happened to Nesbit once the dust had settled; and explain what Thaw used to with his $100 bills…

CONTENT WARNING: sexual sadism, abuse, coercive control, description of murder.

Further Reading:

• ‘The History of New York Scandals - Harry Thaw Shoots Architect Stanford White’ (New York Magazine, 2012): https://nymag.com/news/features/scandals/stanford-white-2012-4/

• ‘THAW MURDERS STANFORD WHITE; Shoots Him on the Madison Square Garden Roof’ (The New York Times, 1906): https://www.nytimes.com/1906/06/26/archives/thaw-murders-stanford-white-shoots-him-on-the-madison-square-garden.html

• ‘The Girl in the Red Velvet Swing: Trailer’ (20th Century Fox, 1955): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ARhXJas59YQ

Love the show? Support us! 

Join  🌴CLUB RETROSPECTORS🌴to DITCH THE ADS and get an additional full-length episode each SUNDAY… 

… Plus, get weekly bonus bits, and unlock over 100 bits of extra content. 

Join now with a free trial on Apple Podcasts or Patreon and support our show ❤️

The Retrospectors are Olly Mann, Rebecca Messina & Arion McNicoll, with Matt Hill.

Theme Music: Pass The Peas. Announcer: Bob Ravelli. Graphic Design: Terry Saunders. Edit Producer: Ollie Peart

Copyright: Rethink Audio / Olly Mann 2025.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices