The Story Isn’t Over: History from the Margins

The Story Isn’t Over: History from the Margins

By Ramblings of a SikhHistory
Download on the App Store

The Story Isn’t Over: History from the Margins episodes

  • Jallianwala Bagh | Amandeep Madra

    Today I have the pleasure to talk to Amandeep Singh Madra, the co-author of ‘Eyewitness at Amritsar’.


    ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★
    ★ Buy this podcast a coffee ★

    If you want to know more about our guest then I recommend you visit  episode 15. Coming back to today’s episode, we will be focusing on  Jallianwala Bagh.

    Now those of you listening have probably seen the recent ‘renovations’,  in my opinion, it’s an absolute indecorous f*ckery of stupidity and  disrespect of history. However, the ‘renovations’ and disrespect itself  won’t be the topic today - instead we’ll be focusing on the Jallianwala  Bagh massacre and the events both preceding and proceeding it.

    As always here’s a time stamped breakdown of the conversation:

    00:00 - Introduction

    01:13 - Where does Jallianwala Bagh get its name from?
    03:03 - What was the purpose of Jallianwala Bagh?
    06:01 - Visiting Jallianwala Bagh
    06:25 - End of WWI, socio-economic influences on Panjab
    13:32 - Rowlatt Acts
    15:01 - Who are Colonel Reginald Edward Harry Dyer and Sir Michael O’Dwyer?
    25:22 - Kitchelew, Sataypal & April 10th, 1919
    35:23 - Marcella Sherwood
    40:54 - The plan to bomb Amritsar
    46:09 - Which regiments were involved in the massacre & did any of the soldiers refuse to shoot?
    51:35 - Finding out who belonged to these regiments  
    54:05 - Who do we know about the crowd that was there that day?
    01:01:45 - The myth of the well
    01:04:48 - How far are the soldiers from the crowd when they shoot?
    01:15:31 - Bhagat Singh, Udham Singh and General Dyer’s siropa
    01:25:29 - How is the British Raj about to mobilise a vast volunteer force for WW2 considering the events of Jallianwala Bagh?
    01:32:09 - What happens to Dyer?


    1 hr 37 min
  • Sikhs in Britain | Peter Bance

    In this episode I get the chance to talk to Peter Bance author of 'Sikhs in Britain: 150 years of photographs' about Sikh migration, immigration and settlement in Britain over the last 150 years.

    ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

    ★ Buy this podcast a coffee ★

    As always here's a time stamped breakdown of the conversation:

    00:00 - Introduction

    01:18 - Why did decide to research this topic?
    03:04 - When is the first instance of Sikh migration from India?
    07:15 - How does caste and class influence migration and did this change?
    11:57 - What was the relationship between early Sikh peddlars and the Jewish community?
    15:00 - What is the legislation change that impacts 'chain-migration'?
    16:18 - Is this the only instance of legislation impacting Sikh immigration, or does it occur in other places?
    17:28 - What was it about Britain that attracted the first Sikh settlers?
    24:18 - How did Sikh migration and the establishment of Gurdwaras work?
    27:58 - Are the current concerntrations of the British Sikh population reflective of early Sikh settlement?
    31:57 - During your research what were some of the common experiences that early Sikh migrants faced?
    36:11 - How did the peddlar trade continue to be a career choice for Sikh immigrants throughout the 20th century?
    45:33 - What's the difference between the two editions of your 'Sikhs in Britain' book?
    47:22 - What about World War I influences Sikh immigration to England?
    51:18 - What role did Britain play in the Indian nationalist movement?
    56:07 - Udham Singh in Coventry?
    01:00:01 - Accounts of Udham Singh
    01:02:55 - Udham Singh, Communism and the IWA.
    01:05:12 - Final comments

    1 hr 8 min
  • Punjab-Sikh Representation in Bollywood | Jasmine Rai

    In this podcast I get to talk to Jasmine Rai, a recent graduate from the  University of Birmingham, about her dissertation entitled - “An  exploration of the representations of Punjabi-Sikhs within Bollywood  cinema and how this affects perceptions of their community”. 

    ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

    ★ Buy this podcast a coffee ★

    As always here's a time stamped breakdown of the conversation:

    00:00 - Introduction
    01:45 - Family, education and culture
    04:52 - PPE & Punjab
    05:54 - Research & fieldwork
    12:46 - Stereotype of Punjabi-Sikh identity in Bollywood films
    15:20 - Representation and responsibility
    22:53 - Did you come across any movies that bucked the trend?
    26:34 - Power to make a change
    27:55 - Caricatures & the Punjabi film industry
    28:54 - The diaspora and changing the narrative
    29:26 - Majority-Minority framework
    31:55 - 'Bollywood has culturally appropriated Punjabi culture'
    37:09 - Deep rooted change and the politics of India

    46 min
  • Standardising Sri Dasam Granth | Kamalroop Singh

    In this episode I get to talk to Dr. Kamalroop Singh once again and this time we discuss the Sodhak Committee, 'apocrypha' Bani and a lot more. 

    ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

    ★ Buy this podcast a coffee ★

    As always here is a time stamped breakdown of the conversation:


    00:00 - Introduction
    04:53 - When did the Sodhak Committee take place, who was involved and how did they decide what should and should not be included?
    14:33 - The processes of the Sodhak Committee
    29:32 - Which recension is used most today?
    35:46 - Events leading up to the Sodhak Committee
    45:27 - Debating 'apocrypha'
    47:36 - A list of some 'apocrypha' bani
    49:26 - The literary Court of Guru Gobind Singh Ji & languages
    58:51 - Gobind Geeta & Hanuman Natak
    1:05:45 - Ugurdanti, Sansar Sukhmana, Indra Kavach and more

    1 hr 25 min
  • The Sikh Royal Family | Peter Bance

    In this episiode I get to talk to Bhupinder Singh Bance, also known as  Peter Bance is a sikh historian, author, art collector and Maharaja  Duleep Singh archivist.   In fact, His collection has been exhibited worldwide including at the  Victoria & Albert Museum, The British Museum, and the Bard Graduate  Centre in New York.

    He has written for the Times and The Oxford National Biography & is the author of four books - The Duleep Singhs: Photograph Album of Queen Victoria's Maharajah (2004)  Sikhs in Britain: 150 Years of Photography (2007) Khalsa Jatha British Isles Centenary 1908-2008 (2008) Sovereign, Squire and Rebel: Maharajah Duleep Singh & the Heirs of a  Lost Kingdom (2009) Sikhs in Britain: 150 Years of Photography (2012),

    He has also appeared in many BBC programmes such as The Story Of The  Turban (2012), Inside Out (2004), Desi DNA (2005), Britain's Maharajah  (2013), Sophia: Suffragette Princess (2015) and The Stolen Maharajah:  Britain's Indian Royal (2018)

    ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★
    ★ Buy this podcast a coffee ★

    As always here is a breakdown of the conversation:

    00:00 - Introduction
    03:25 - A doctor in India but a door-to-door seller in England
    04:23 - Why was peddling the go to occupation for early Sikh settlers in England?
    05:09 - Why did your family come to the UK?
    06:38 - Ancestry - Shaheedi Misl and Baba Deep Singh Ji
    08:13 - How did you go from a marketing degree to being a historian of Sikh history?
    14:21 - What type of items did you come across in your initial research?
    14:35 - What was it about the Maharaja that attracted you so much?
    16:38 - Anecdote of Prince Frederick Duleep Singh
    17:37 - The view of the Sikh Royal Family in East Anglia  
    19:36 - Princess Catherine Hilda Duleep Singh - The Punjabi Schindler
    20:59 - How was Catherine practically able to do this and also evade being caught?
    25:43 - Sister Suffragettes
    28:04 - Anita Anand and the suffragette story
    28:19 - How did the descendants of M. Ranjit Singh identify and view themselves?
    33:00 - The Pension that was never paid
    34:00 - A Russian Promise - 20k soldiers to march into Punjab via Afghanistan
    37:11 - The personal notebook of Maharaja Duleep Singh
    38:17 - The daughters of M. Duleep Singh
    39:30 - Guns of M. Duleep Singh - The Rolls Royce of Guns
    42:16 - How many wives and children did M. Duleep Singh have?
    44:14 - Museums and Repatriation
    48:21- A painting of a Prince
    52:48 - The Ramgharia Bakery
    55:25 - Monte Carlo
    01:01:32 - Rani Jinda Gravestone & Catacombs
    01:06:57 - Princess Pauline
    01:15:13 - Are you aware of the Sikh Royal Family visitng their items in a museum?  
    01:16:42 - £1.7million Statue
    01:25:32 - Illegitimate heirs to the throne
    01:28:48 - How many illegitimate heirs?
    01:30:18 - Sid Hammond
    01:31:53 - End of the legitimate heirs of M. Ranjit Singh
    01:34:32 - Interesting finds & advice in entering the field of Sikh history

    1 hr 38 min
  • The Sikh Royal Family – Peter Bance - EP #20

    In this episiode I get to talk to Bhupinder Singh Bance, also known as  Peter Bance is a sikh historian, author, art collector and Maharaja  Duleep Singh archivist.   In fact, His collection has been exhibited worldwide including at the  Victoria & Albert Museum, The British Museum, and the Bard Graduate  Centre in New York.  

    He has written for the Times and The Oxford National Biography & is the author of four books - The Duleep Singhs: Photograph Album of Queen Victoria's Maharajah (2004)  Sikhs in Britain: 150 Years of Photography (2007) Khalsa Jatha British Isles Centenary 1908-2008 (2008) Sovereign, Squire and Rebel: Maharajah Duleep Singh & the Heirs of a  Lost Kingdom (2009) Sikhs in Britain: 150 Years of Photography (2012),  

    He has also appeared in many BBC programmes such as The Story Of The  Turban (2012), Inside Out (2004), Desi DNA (2005), Britain's Maharajah  (2013), Sophia: Suffragette Princess (2015) and The Stolen Maharajah:  Britain's Indian Royal (2018)  

    As always here is a breakdown of the conversation:  

    00:00 - Introduction

    03:25 - A doctor in India but a door-to-door seller in England
    04:23 - Why was peddling the go to occupation for early Sikh settlers in England?
    05:09 - Why did your family come to the UK?
    06:38 - Ancestry - Shaheedi Misl and Baba Deep Singh Ji
    08:13 - How did you go from a marketing degree to being a historian of Sikh history?
    14:21 - What type of items did you come across in your initial research?
    14:35 - What was it about the Maharaja that attracted you so much?
    16:38 - Anecdote of Prince Frederick Duleep Singh
    17:37 - The view of the Sikh Royal Family in East Anglia  
    19:36 - Princess Catherine Hilda Duleep Singh - The Punjabi Schindler
    20:59 - How was Catherine practically able to do this and also evade being caught?
    25:43 - Sister Suffragettes
    28:04 - Anita Anand and the suffragette story
    28:19 - How did the descendants of M. Ranjit Singh identify and view themselves?
    33:00 - The Pension that was never paid
    34:00 - A Russian Promise - 20k soldiers to march into Punjab via Afghanistan
    37:11 - The personal notebook of Maharaja Duleep Singh
    38:17 - The daughters of M. Duleep Singh
    39:30 - Guns of M. Duleep Singh - The Rolls Royce of Guns
    42:16 - How many wives and children did M. Duleep Singh have?
    44:14 - Museums and Repatriation
    48:21- A painting of a Prince
    52:48 - The Ramgharia Bakery
    55:25 - Monte Carlo
    01:01:32 - Rani Jinda Gravestone & Catacombs
    01:06:57 - Princess Pauline
    01:15:13 - Are you aware of the Sikh Royal Family visitng their items in a museum?  
    01:16:42 - £1.7million Statue
    01:25:32 - Illegitimate heirs to the throen
    01:28:48 - How many illegitimate heirs?
    01:30:18 - Sid Hammond
    01:31:53 - End of the legitimate heirs of M. Ranjit Singh
    01:34:32 - Interesting finds & advice in entering the field of Sikh history

    1 hr 38 min
  • British Asian Music | Panjabi Hit Squad

    In this episode I get to talk to Rav from Panjabi Hit Squad. We discuss Rav's background, upbringing, the history of Panjabi Hit Squad and so  much more. 

    ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★
    ★ Buy this podcast a coffee ★

    As usual, a breakdown of the conversation is below.  

    00:00 - Introduction - How are you? Have things gone back to normal in the entertainment industry?  
    02:00 - What is your family history and experience been?
    06:16 - How did you all meet and what is the history of Panjabi Hit Squad and where did the name come from?
    13:27 - What were the feature factors in the popularity of the British Asian music scene in the 90s/00s?
    17:39 - What have been the biggest changes over the last twenty years to the British Asian music scene and why isn’t it as popular?
    21:51 - Do you think we will see a group from the South Asian diaspora, similar to NSG?
    28:30 - Do you think the healthy competition in the early 2000s lent itself to pushing everyone?
    31:17 - What have your experiences of the music industry been like?
    39:32 - How was it working with Ms Scandalous, Alyssia and Rahat Fateh Ali Khan?  
    44:00 - Who has been the most interesting person you’ve worked with or  come across in the music industry? What was it like being signed by Def  Jam and working with people like Mariah Carey and Fat Man Scoop?
    51:12 - Have you ever thought about the impact of your music on popular culture?
    57:00 - Food heaven and food hell?

    1 hr 1 min
  • Historical Dissemination of Sri Dasam Granth Sahib | Gurinder Singh Mann

    In this episode I get to talk to Gurinder Singh Mann about the history and dissemination of Sri Dasam Granth, amongst a whole host of other topics.

    Gurinder Singh Mann, is a Sikh historian and has published three books

    1. The British and the Sikhs: Discovery, warfare and friendship c1700-1900. Military and social interaction in Imperial India (From Musket to Maxim 1815-1914)
    2. Sri Dasam Granth Sahib: Questions and Answers
    3. The Granth Of Guru Gobind Singh: Essays, Lectures, and Translations, which was published by Oxford University Press

    He is also the director of the Sikh Museum Initiative, a curator of the Anglo Sikh Virtual Museum and an advisor for the upcoming movie The Sikh Soldier.

    ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★
    ★ Buy this podcast a coffee ★

    As always here is a breakdown of the podcast:

    00:00 – Introduction
    01:24 – Upbringing and family background
    04:29 - How were you introduced to Sri Dasam Granth?
    08:07 - What were you planning on studying in respect to Sri Dasam Granth?
    12:12 - What were some of the conclusions of your MA study?
    17:17 - What was the reaction to your MA & what is your opinion of past Dasam?
    19:47 - Why do you think certain scholars are hesitant to attribute Dasam Granth?
    25:13 - What is your view of the work of Jaggi and Reinhart?
    41:41 - Introduction to the physical historical dissemination of Sri Dasam Granth?
    47:59 - What methods were used to physically construct a Dasam Granth manuscript?
    53:02 - Anything of particular interest come up in your research?
    55:15 – Kavis (poets) of Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib Ji.
    59:04 - Why 52?
    01:01:30 - What was the religious landscape like at the time of Guru Gobind Singh ji?
    01:06:49 - Where does the tradition of having Kavis come from?
    01:08:51 - Paonta Sahib Sri Dasam Granth manuscripts
    01:11:39 - The Bhai Daya Singh recension of Sri Dasam Granth Sahib
    01:15:26 - Any other Sri Dasam Granth manuscripts worth mentioning?
    01:17:27 - How did Sri Dasam Granth Sahib evolve historically?
    01:19:36 - How do the themes of Sri Dasam Granth and Sri Guru Granth Sahib relate?
    01:25:31 – What other ways was Sri Dasam Granth propagated?
    01:31:50 - What evidence is there to show the body armour once belonged to Guru Gobind Singh Ji?
    01:33:42 - How was Sri Dasam Granth propagated during the misl period and M. Ranjit Singh period?
    01:48:03 - Wilkins, Malcolm, Leyden, Anglo-Sikh Wars and the Singh Sabha movement
    01:54:30 - What is your opinion of the idea that the British purposefully removed Sri Dasam Granth sahib?
    01:55:53 - Did the changing relationship between Britain and the Punjab impact British accounts of the Sikhs?
    01:57:05 - Annexation and perception of Sri Dasam Granth sahib
    02:09:22 - The Sodhak Committee?
    02:14:32 – National armies, the Sikhs and Sovereignty
    02:26:55 – How did copies of Sri Dasam Granth end up in institutions across the world?
    02:23:20 - What is the most accurate translation of Sri Dasam Granth currently available?

    2 hr 45 min
  • Bhai Nand Lal | Satnam Singh

    In this latest podcast episode I get to talk to Satnam Singh again.   

    ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★
    ★ Buy this podcast a coffee ★

    We discuss Bhai Nand Lal, his birth in Ghazni, Afghanistan, his  upbringing and education. We discuss Bhai Nand Lal's parents, their  passing and the different narratives regarding his life. We then explore  Bhai Nand Lal's tenure under Aurangzeb before joining the court of Guru  Gobind Singh Ji. We then dive into the plethora of works penned by Bhai  Nand Lal, along with the importance of Persian.

    1 hr 13 min
  • "How did South Asian Women Forge Solidarity and Create Spaces for their Community in Britain?" | Amal Malik

    In this episode I get to talk to Amal Malik, a recent history graduate from the University of Warwick. We discuss her dissertation regarding how South Asian women forged solidarity and created spaces for their Community in Britain.

    ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★
    ★ Buy this podcast a coffee ★

    As always here is a breakdown of the podcast:

    00:00 – Introduction
    02:38 – Family background
    06:59 – The Maldives, railways and Milan fashion week
    14:34 – Why was it important to acknowledge “the women of the Sari Squad, the Jagonari Centre, Bradford Women’s Centre and Club Kali”?
    17:03 – How did you go about your research?
    19:32 – Oral history and academia
    22:41 – Section 1: Hostile Territories
    26:27 – To what extent was the work of the Sari Squad making South Asian women be acceptable rather than creating a safe space?
    28:06 – Assimilation or integration?
    35:59 – Is the term “South Asian” adequate?
    41:01 – The Sari Squad and mixed martial arts
    42:47 – Section 2: Community Services – Jagnoari Centre & Bradford Women’s Centre
    44:38 – Section 3: Transgressive Sexualities – Club Kali and DJ Ritu
    50:02 – Why do you think South Asian history is thoroughly sanitised?
    53:41 – What was the lesson you took away from your dissertation?
    58:29 – Last thoughts

    1 hr 3 min

About The Story Isn’t Over: History from the Margins

From the publisher's feed

The Story Isn't Over is a podcast from Amar Singh, aka Ramblings of a Sikh. Historians, authors, artists, journalists, activists and culture-makers join wide-ranging conversations that unearth forgotten histories, challenge dominant narratives and rethink the stories we thought we knew. From empire and resistance to migration, faith, music and community memory.

More shows like The Story Isn’t Over: History from the Margins

The Joe Rogan Experience by Joe Rogan

The Joe Rogan Experience

227,576 Listeners

The Archers by BBC Radio 4

The Archers

1,083 Listeners

Economist Podcasts by The Economist

Economist Podcasts

4,116 Listeners

Intelligence Squared by Intelligence Squared

Intelligence Squared

769 Listeners

Heavyweight by Pushkin Industries

Heavyweight

17,660 Listeners

The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett by DOAC

The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett

8,428 Listeners

Anything Goes with James English by Anything Goes with James English

Anything Goes with James English

300 Listeners

Inside Briefing with the Institute for Government by Institute for Government

Inside Briefing with the Institute for Government

21 Listeners

Banged Up by Goalhanger Films

Banged Up

19 Listeners

Empire: World History by Goalhanger

Empire: World History

2,464 Listeners

Miss Me? by Persephonica

Miss Me?

240 Listeners

The Therapy Crouch by Tall or Nothing

The Therapy Crouch

256 Listeners

The Rest Is Politics: US by Goalhanger

The Rest Is Politics: US

2,242 Listeners