Happy Halloween from The Supernaturals Podcast! This year we wanted to make it very special. Not only does this episode conclude a very mystical and haunting season 2, but hosts Jake and Cal will be reading your chilling Halloween stories, all while they’re dressed in costumes. Sit back, relax, and celebrate Halloween with your favorite horror podcast. And once again, thank you for an incredible season here on The Supernaturals Podcast.

In this chilling episode of The Supernaturals, Jake and Cal discuss the Smiley Face Mystery, a theory that connects the drownings of college-aged men over the last twenty years. Were their cases really accidents? Well, the smiley faces painted next to the last place they were seen alive says differently.

In this week’s episode, The Supernaturals discuss ‘The Black Phone,’ a movie directed by Scott Derrickson (Sinister) and starring Ethan Hawke. Jake and Cal prepare for the second movie while also discussing the importance of watching your kids and taking extra precautions to keep them safe. This point is hammered home as Cal leads Jake through the horrors of the Jaycee Dugard Case.

In this episode, The Supernaturals discuss a native Algonquin legend. The people believed in a terrifying creature known as the Wendigo, a haunting creature that just wants to eat. But what it craves, will surely turn your stomach. Jake and Cal look to uncover the truth to these mythical creatures and see if they once walked among us… or if they still do.

In their 50th episode special, The Supernaturals pack up their bags and head to Salem, Massachusetts, where they examine a dark period in American history. While witchcraft wasn’t necessarily the cause of this haunting period, it did spawn an interest in the subject. Jake and Cal then discuss witchcraft and whether it exists or not.

In this unsolved mysteries episode, The Supernaturals discuss what has been dubbed as ‘America’s Dyatlov Pass Incident.’ The story follows five young men with mental disabilities who vanished on the night of February 24, 1978. Jake and Cal discuss the facts as they try to uncover the truth of what happened to the young men.

In this special episode, The Supernaturals asked you to send them your terrifying encounters. From stalkings to close calls, Jake and Cal read your submissions of haunting events that you experienced. Sit back, relax, and prepare to be frightened.

Stemming from West Virginia folklore, there was a creature that was first sighted in 1966 in Point Pleasant. Its massive size, giant wings, and glowing red eyes have been described by many. But soon after a disaster on a bridge in Point Pleasant, the mythical creature has become a sort of ‘bad omen.’ The Supernaturals examine the history, discuss theories, and try to uncover the truth that is… The Mothman.

In this intriguing unsolved mysteries episode, The Supernaturals discuss the weird events that occurred at a National Park in Canada. Full of untouched wilderness, stories spread of miners and explorers who were found… without their heads. With little to no answers, this mystery has stumped researchers for years. Follow along as Jake and Cal try to uncover the secrets as they step into the valley of the headless men.

Part two: In the conclusion of ‘Cult Month,’ The Supernaturals examine the rise and fall of Peoples Temple. While the media began to criticize his abusive cult, Jim Jones decided to move the Temple to Guyana. And what happens there is so horrific, Jake and Cal can hardly believe it's real.