The True Crime Tapes

The Long Island Serial Killings, also known as the Gilgo Beach Murders or the Craigslist Ripper case, is an unsolved serial murder investigation centered around the discovery of numerous human remains on Long Island, New York. The case has been ongoing since 2010 and remains unsolved as of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021.

The initial discovery took place on December 11, 2010, when police were searching for a missing woman named Shannan Gilbert, a sex worker who had gone to meet a client in Oak Beach, Suffolk County. During the search, police found the remains of four women in the vicinity of Gilgo Beach. These victims were later identified as Megan Waterman, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Melissa Barthelemy, and Amber Lynn Costello, all of whom were also involved in sex work

.As the investigation progressed, additional remains were discovered in the same area. In March and April 2011, six more sets of remains were found, along with the remains of an unidentified toddler, who came to be known as "Baby Doe" or "Jane Doe #6." The additional victims were identified as Jessica Taylor, Valerie Mack, Jane Doe #6 (the toddler), and an Asian male dressed in women's clothing.The police discovered that many of the victims had connections to the sex trade and had advertised their services on websites like Craigslist.


This led investigators to suspect that a serial killer, dubbed the "Long Island Serial Killer" or "Craigslist Ripper," was specifically targeting sex workers in the area.The case gained significant media attention and sparked a large-scale investigation involving local, state, and federal law enforcement agencies. The search for additional evidence continued over the years, including the use of cadaver dogs, aerial searches, and the excavation of specific areas.

Despite these efforts, no further bodies were found.The investigation faced various challenges and controversies. Shannan Gilbert's disappearance and death were initially treated as unrelated to the serial killings. However, her death was later attributed to accidental drowning. The mishandling of the case and the delayed response to her initial 911 call raised questions about the police's handling of the investigation.

Then on July 13th, 2023 an arrest in the case was finally made. The man arrested? Rex Heuermann.

In this episode, we hear from Dave Schaller, the man who gave the police the tip about who Heuermann was over a decade ago and even gave them a description of the vehicle the alleged serial killer was driving.





to contact me:

[email protected]



source:

He came face to face with an alleged serial killer. 12 years later, his tip helped crack the case | AP News

Rex Heuremann, the suspect in the Gilgo Beach murders, not only carried out the act of murdering Melissa Barthelemy, allegedly, but he also had the audacity to call her family, from her phone, and brag about the action to her little sister. Her little sister, who was 15 at the time, is now talking about what she went through and the ordeal she faced knowing that her sisters murderer was not only still out there, but also watching her and taunting her as well.


In this episode, we hear from Melissa's sister about the phone calls and the impact that those phone calls have had on her throughout her life.




to contact me:

[email protected]


source:

Gilgo Beach victim's sister says suspect with a Long Island accent called her to say he raped her | Daily Mail Online

Defending a client in a murder case where the evidence, including DNA, overwhelmingly points to their guilt is highly challenging. However, a skilled lawyer might employ several strategies to provide the best possible defense.   So, what sort of strategy might be used by Rex Heuermann and his team at trial? 

1. Challenging the Evidence:
   • Chain of Custody: The lawyer might question whether the evidence was properly handled from the crime scene to the courtroom, suggesting possible contamination or tampering.
   • Forensic Procedures: They could scrutinize the methods used to collect and analyze the DNA evidence, aiming to find procedural errors that could undermine the reliability of the results.
2. Alternative Theories:
   • Third-Party Culpability: The defense might suggest that someone else had access to the crime scene and could have left the DNA, presenting alternative suspects.
   • Consent or Innocent Transfer: If applicable, the lawyer might argue that the client's DNA was present due to consensual contact or innocent transfer, rather than through criminal activity.
3. Questioning Witness Credibility:
   • Inconsistencies: The lawyer could highlight inconsistencies in witness testimonies or point out any reasons witnesses might have to lie or misremember events.
   • Bias and Motive: They might argue that witnesses are biased or have motives to falsely implicate the defendant.
4. Psychological Defense:
   • Mental Health: The lawyer could argue that the client was suffering from a mental disorder at the time of the crime, which impaired their ability to understand their actions or differentiate between right and wrong.
   • Diminished Capacity: They might claim that the client’s mental state, though not exonerating them completely, should mitigate their culpability.
5. Procedural Defenses:
   • Violation of Rights: The defense could argue that the client's constitutional rights were violated during the investigation, such as through unlawful search and seizure, leading to the suppression of critical evidence.
   • Coerced Confession: If there is a confession, the lawyer might contend it was obtained through coercion, making it inadmissible.
6. Plea Bargaining:
   • Reduced Charges: If the evidence is overwhelmingly against the client, the lawyer might negotiate a plea deal for lesser charges or a reduced sentence, arguing for mitigating factors like the client’s lack of prior criminal history or remorse.
7. Humanizing the Client:
   • Character Witnesses: The defense might bring in witnesses to attest to the client's good character, arguing that the crime is out of character and presenting them in a sympathetic light.
   • Background and Circumstances: They could present evidence about the client’s background, upbringing, and circumstances that might have led to their involvement in the crime, seeking to evoke empathy from the jury.

(commercial at 12:04)


to contact me:


[email protected]



source:

Defending the Devil: Serial Killer Lawyers Speak Out on Gilgo Beach Murders - Newsweek

The Maxwell transcripts, paired with her transfer to Camp Bryan, expose a process designed not to uncover truth but to bury it. Deputy Attorney General Todd “Baby Billy” Blanche oversaw the meeting, yet instead of demanding names or clarity, he allowed Maxwell to dodge and evade without consequence. What should have been a reckoning was instead theater—Maxwell performing silence, Blanche directing the script, and the DOJ rubber-stamping it as cooperation.

The reward for that silence was clear: Maxwell, a convicted child trafficker, was moved to a low-security “camp” usually reserved for nonviolent offenders. Survivors were left betrayed, the public misled, and the broader Epstein network protected. This wasn’t justice delivered but justice inverted, a cover-up executed under the guise of procedure, ensuring that accountability died the moment Maxwell kept her mouth shut.


to contact me:

[email protected]

The Maxwell transcripts, paired with her transfer to Camp Bryan, expose a process designed not to uncover truth but to bury it. Deputy Attorney General Todd “Baby Billy” Blanche oversaw the meeting, yet instead of demanding names or clarity, he allowed Maxwell to dodge and evade without consequence. What should have been a reckoning was instead theater—Maxwell performing silence, Blanche directing the script, and the DOJ rubber-stamping it as cooperation.

The reward for that silence was clear: Maxwell, a convicted child trafficker, was moved to a low-security “camp” usually reserved for nonviolent offenders. Survivors were left betrayed, the public misled, and the broader Epstein network protected. This wasn’t justice delivered but justice inverted, a cover-up executed under the guise of procedure, ensuring that accountability died the moment Maxwell kept her mouth shut.


to contact me:

[email protected]

Today’s episode centers on the powerful, gut-wrenching press conference held by survivors of Jeffrey Epstein’s sex trafficking network—women who stood before Congress not to ask, but to demand justice. Their testimony wasn’t just about personal trauma—it was a public reckoning. These survivors, some speaking publicly for the first time, delivered raw, unfiltered truth about decades of abuse, systemic failures, and institutional protection of the powerful. They called for the full, unredacted release of Epstein’s files and vowed to compile their own list of the men who raped them if the government continues to withhold names. Their voices were a clarion call—not just for justice, but for national accountability. This wasn’t about left or right. It was about the most powerful among us exploiting the most vulnerable and getting away with it.


to contact me:

[email protected]

Recent revelations have significantly undercut former Attorney General Pam Bondi’s explanation regarding the so-called “missing minute” from Jeffrey Epstein’s jail surveillance footage. The House Oversight Committee has released previously unseen surveillance video capturing the minute—from about 11:58:59 p.m. to midnight on August 10, 2019—that had been absent from earlier DOJ releases. The newly revealed clip, showing guards working near Epstein’s cell, undermines Bondi’s prior claim that the gap resulted from a routine, nightly system reset—a technical quirk that she stated led to that minute being “missing every night.” The footage instead suggests the gap emerged from how the files were stitched together at the midnight timestamp, not a recurring reset issue, effectively blowing Bondi’s narrative out of the water


to contact me:


[email protected]



source:

Epstein document dump blows huge hole in Pam Bondi's 'missing minute' theory as pressure mounts for Trump to disclose the truth - and MAGA rep says case 'a lot bigger than anyone anticipated' | Daily Mail Online

As the dust continues to settle around the arrest of Rex Heuermann, we are hearing from sex workers who sold their services to him and what we are hearing is right in line with the profile of the man that has emerged since he was arrested.


In this epsiode we hear from Sheriff Toulen about Rex Heuermann's life in jail and where things currently stand from his perspective.




to conctact me:

[email protected]


source:

Gilgo Beach 'serial killer' Rex Heuerman is meeting with 'clergyman' once a week while in jail, as top cop says he's been taken off suicide watch and is 'emotionless' | Daily Mail Online

Marina Lacerda, now 37, revealed that she was first approached by Epstein in 2002 when she was just 14, under the pretext of providing massage services, which led to years of sexual abuse in his New York residence. She recounted horrifying details of Epstein’s home operating like a "revolving door," hosting up to 5–10 women per day. After being contacted originally by investigators in 2008—only for Epstein to secure a secret non-prosecution agreement that prevented her from testifying before a grand jury—she was approached again over a decade later, and her testimony ultimately became pivotal in the 2019 sex-trafficking charges against him .

Lacerda passionately called for transparency by urging the Trump administration to release all files related to Epstein’s crimes—not only for the sake of the victims but also for the American public. She emphasized that access to her records would help her—and others—begin to heal, acting as a broader demand for public accountability and truth. Her plea aligns with a broader bipartisan congressional push, led by Representatives Ro Khanna and Thomas Massie, to force the Justice Department to disclose Epstein‑related documents, despite claims that no "client list" exists.


to contact me:

[email protected]



source:

'We need the Epstein files to be out': Central witness in Epstein case speaks publicly for 1st time - ABC News

The investigation into Rex Heuermann, alleged Long Island Serial Killer continues to grow not only in evidence but also in manpower. Police Chief Rodney Harrison announced that two more detectives were added to the task force and they are looking very, very closely at Rex Heuermann for his possible involvement in the deaths of Valerie Mack and Karen Vergata.


Heuermann has already been charged with 3 counts of murder, with one more count pending and a whole host of other charges due to his illegal ownership of firearms.

He has said that he is innocent and is expected back in court in November.




to contact me:

[email protected]


source:

Suffolk cops expand probe into other potential victims of suspected Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann (nypost.com)