Thick Thighs & Murder Vibes 's Podcast

Send us Fan Mail

Imagine meeting someone, having a little fun, and then watching your entire life turn into a psychological nightmare.

When Cari Farver seemingly vanished in November 2012, the people around her began receiving disturbing messages. Threats, harassment, jealousy, and an obsession that refused to die.

But here's the thing, besties... sometimes the person you think is terrorizing you isn't the person behind the screen.

And sometimes the truth is so batshit insane that even Hollywood couldn't make this shit up.

For this special Halloween episode of Thick Thighs & Murder Vibes, we're diving into a twisted story of obsession, deception, digital stalking, and a mystery that will have you questioning EVERYTHING.

So grab your Halloween candy, roll something spooky, double-check those deadbolts, and get comfortable.

Because this nightmare doesn't need ghosts, demons, or a masked killer.

The real monster is already here. 

 New episode. Same vibes. Halloween edition.

Sponsored by The Loaded Tea Shop! Get caffeinated with code TTMV4200 for 10% off orders of $20 or more.

https://www.theloadedteashop.com/TTMV4200

Send us Fan Mail

Besties, this week we're taking a trip to Fox Hollow Farm, where the sprawling estate, indoor swimming pool, and seemingly picture-perfect family life were hiding something far more sinister.

Behind closed doors, Herb Baumeister was living a double life, and what investigators would eventually uncover on his Indiana property would leave more questions than answers.

And because this case is WAY too unhinged to tackle alone, I'm joined by a very special guest, the fabulous Nikita Romanoff! 💋

We're talking secrets, suspicious disappearances, disturbing discoveries, and the horrifying truth behind one of Indiana's most notorious suspected serial killers.

So grab your favorite drink, get comfortable, and prepare yourself, besties. Because this farmhouse has a whole lot more than skeletons in its closets.

Welcome to Fox Hollow Farm. 🖤

🎙️ Thick Thighs & Murder Vibes

🔞 Listener discretion advised.

Send us Fan Mail

In November 2016, a young mother vanishes while out for a jog in Northern California, leaving behind her husband, two children, and a community desperate for answers.

What follows is a nationwide search, shocking developments, and a story that would leave investigators—and eventually the entire country—with more questions than answers.

But besties, as the pieces of this bizarre puzzle start coming together, things take a turn that will have you questioning EVERYTHING.

This week on Thick Thighs & Murder Vibes, we're diving into the absolutely unbelievable story of Sherri Papini.

We've got suspicious circumstances, questionable decisions, and enough red flags to decorate an entire fucking carnival.

The AUDACITY is truly unmatched.

Grab your snacks, roll whatever you need to roll, and get comfortable. Because this one is a RIDE.

🎙️ New episode. Same vibes.

Send us Fan Mail

In 1995, 18-year-old Christa Pike was enrolled in Job Corps in Knoxville, Tennessee—a program meant to help young people build a future.

Instead, she ended up on death row.

What started as jealousy and teenage drama escalated into the brutal murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, a crime so disturbing that Christa would become the youngest woman sentenced to death in Tennessee at the time.

But decades later, the case still raises questions that go far beyond what happened that night.

This week, we’re getting into Christa Pike’s troubled history, the murder of Colleen Slemmer, the investigation and trial that sent Christa to death row, and the controversy surrounding her execution—including the recent attempt that didn’t go according to plan.

Because you can believe someone deserves to be held accountable for what they did and still question what happens when the government decides to take a life.

So pull up a chair, roll whatever you need to roll, and buckle the fuck up, besties.

This is Job Corps to Death Row: The Christa Pike Case.

Send us Fan Mail

What happens when the person you should be safest with becomes the person you never saw coming?

In 2007, thirteen-year-old Paris Bennett was intelligent, articulate, and seemingly devoted to his family. But behind that carefully composed exterior was something his mother, Charity Lee, could never have imagined.

One night would leave four-year-old Ella Bennett dead, a family shattered, and investigators facing an almost impossible question: How does a thirteen-year-old become a killer?

This week, we’re digging into the disturbing case of Paris Bennett—the events leading up to Ella’s murder, the chilling aftermath, the questions surrounding Paris’s motives, and the mother who has spent the years since trying to understand the unimaginable.

This case involves the death of a young child and other sensitive subject matter. Listener discretion is strongly advised.

Grab your snacks, lock your doors, and settle in, besties. This one is deeply unsettling.

New episodes every Wednesday. Listen wherever podcasts live.

Send us Fan Mail

New York City, 1976.

A killer is stalking the streets after dark, seemingly choosing his victims at random and leaving an entire city terrified of who might be next.

For more than a year, the attacks continued while police chased leads, the media received bizarre letters, and the man behind it all became known as the Son of Sam.

Then investigators finally caught David Berkowitz—and somehow, besties, the story got even weirder.

Because according to Berkowitz, there was a demon involved.

And a dog.

Yes. A dog.

This week on Thick Thighs & Murder Vibes, we're getting into the Son of Sam murders, the investigation that finally brought Berkowitz down, and one of the most infamous excuses in true-crime history.

Grab your snacks, lock your doors, and maybe give your dog a treat.

The dog was innocent. 🐾🖤

Send us Fan Mail

Easter weekend, 1980. A Catholic nun walks into a chapel to prepare for Easter Sunday—and never makes it home.

Sister Margaret Ann Pahl was just 71 years old when she was brutally murdered inside the chapel of Toledo’s Mercy Hospital. For decades, her death remained unsolved, leaving behind a case filled with unanswered questions, a shocking crime scene, and a killer who managed to stay free for far too long.

But after nearly four decades, investigators finally got the break they needed.

In this episode of Thick Thighs and Murder Vibes, we’re diving into the murder of Sister Margaret Ann Pahl, the investigation that refused to die, and the twist that finally brought her killer to justice.

So grab your snacks, settle in, and prepare for some Holy Hell—because this case is a reminder that sometimes justice takes its sweet-ass time… but it doesn't always forget. 

Send us Fan Mail

This week on Thick Thighs and Murder Vibes, we’re diving into the Bear Brook murders—a case that starts with a barrel, gets progressively more disturbing, and somehow manages to involve a Bob Evans along the way.

It’s one of those cases where every answer seems to create about twelve more questions. Who were these victims? Who was responsible? And how the hell did investigators finally put the pieces together?

This one may be short and sweet, besties, but the case itself is anything but.

Grab your snacks, settle in, and let’s talk barrels, bodies, and Bob Evans. 🖤🔪

Lock your doors, trust your gut, and let’s get into it.

Send us Fan Mail

This week, things are looking a little different around here because Terra has company. Shaq is stepping into the guest-host seat, and he’s bringing us one of the creepiest unsolved mysteries in true crime history: the Hinterkaifeck murders.

In 1922, a remote German farm became the center of a mystery that has haunted investigators for more than a century. Strange footprints. Unexplained noises. Someone—or something—lurking around the property. And then, a horrifying discovery that left an entire community searching for answers.

Who was watching the family before the crime? Why were there signs that someone may have remained on the farm afterward? And how the hell did the killer disappear without being caught?

Shaq is presenting the case, Terra is bringing the commentary, and together they're diving headfirst into one of history's most baffling unsolved mysteries.

Lock your doors, trust your gut, and grab your bestie… because this week, the vibes are VERY haunted. 

Send us Fan Mail

In 2009, a horrific crash on the Taconic State Parkway left eight people dead and raised a question that still sparks debate today: how did Diane Schuler end up driving the wrong way down the highway with children in her vehicle?

The investigation painted a disturbing picture, but Diane’s family has continued to dispute key parts of the official account—and more than 15 years later, people are still arguing over what really happened that morning.

In this episode of Thick Thighs and Murder Vibes, we’re breaking down the timeline, the evidence, the investigation, the unanswered questions, and the theories that have kept this case in the true-crime conversation for years.

Because sometimes the most disturbing cases aren't about a mystery killer.

Sometimes they're about trying to understand how one morning went so catastrophically wrong.

Put your bestie on speaker, buckle up, and let’s get into it.