In this episode of Thinking Out Loud, Nathan and Cameron react to Jordan Peterson’s appearance in the viral Jubilee debate—and things get theologically intense. They unpack where Peterson’s thinking aligns with Christian truth and where it dangerously veers off course. From disordered loves and worship to the meaning of belief, Nathan and Cameron bring biblical clarity and philosophical depth to the table. Along the way, they reference thinkers like Augustine, Ayaan Hirsi Ali, T.S. Eliot, David Foster Wallace, and Tom Holland, making this a must-listen for Christians who care about faith, reason, and the big questions of culture.

Topics Covered:

• Is Jordan Peterson a Christian—or just Christian-adjacent?

• What is worship, really? Augustine vs. Peterson

• Disordered loves and cultural idolatry

• Why “aim upward” isn’t the gospel

• Peterson’s definition of belief—where it fails

• Are atheists borrowing Christian morality? (feat. Tom Holland)

• David Foster Wallace, Paul Tillich, and the quest for meaning

• Why science can’t give you morality

In this episode, Nathan and Cameroon dive deep into the rising tide of AI in theological education, especially its implications for seminaries, spiritual formation, and the future of pastoral training. Drawing from Cameron Schaefer’s provocative article on Mere Orthodoxy, they discuss how AI may soon outpace traditional online seminary models and why Christian institutions must shift from being sources of information to curators of formation. Join as they explore the irreplaceable value of embodied ministry, human mentorship, and habitual wisdom in the digital age. Is AI a tool, a threat, or a catalyst for rethinking how we form Christian leaders? Listen for robust theological dialogue, real-world applications, and a hopeful vision for a hybrid future. 📚💻🧠🔍

Topics Covered:

AI in higher education & seminaries

The limits of digital discipleship

Spiritual formation vs. information download

Hybrid models of theological training

Pastoral presence in an AI world

The value of embodied wisdom and habits

📧 Interested in the Backyard Seminary cohort?

Email: [email protected]

DONATE LINK: https://toltogether.com/donate

BOOK A SPEAKER: https://toltogether.com/book-a-speaker

JOIN TOL CONNECT: https://toltogether.com/tol-connect

TOL Connect is an online forum where TOL listeners can continue the conversation begun on the podcast.

In this episode of Thinking Out Loud, Nathan and Cameron explore the recent DC embassy shooting through a Christian theological lens. Why do people scapegoat others? What drives individuals to violent action in the name of causes they don’t directly represent? Drawing on René Girard’s scapegoat theory, biblical concepts of atonement, and the moral confusion of modern culture, they analyze how this tragedy reveals the deep brokenness in human nature and our desperate attempts at meaning-making. With thoughtful insight and pastoral clarity, Nathan and Cameron reflect on individualism, ideological identity, and the limits of symbolic action. This conversation is essential for Christians seeking a thoughtful and faithful response to complex cultural events.DONATE LINK: https://toltogether.com/donate BOOK A SPEAKER: https://toltogether.com/book-a-speakerJOIN TOL CONNECT: https://toltogether.com/tol-connect TOL Connect is an online forum where TOL listeners can continue the conversation begun on the podcast.🔎 Topics Covered:– DC embassy shooting analysis– René Girard and scapegoat theory– Biblical atonement and collective guilt– Virtue signaling vs. real sacrifice– Individualism and ideology– Human responsibility and sin⏱️ Timestamps:00:00 – Intro: DC Embassy Shooting Overview01:19 – Scapegoating and Misplaced Guilt02:42 – Collective Blame and Individual Responsibility07:54 – Identity, Solidarity, and Symbolic Action14:23 – A Story of Hyper-Individualism16:49 – Community, Culture, and Perception17:28 – Desperate Acts of Self-Expression21:13 – The Dark Side of Virtue Signaling24:35 – The Tragic Capacity of Human Destruction25:31 – Theology of Sacrifice and Scapegoats26:55 – Biblical Justice vs. Endless Retribution#ThinkingOutLoud #NathanAndCameron #ChristianWorldview #TheologyAndCulture #ScapegoatTheory #RenéGirard #ChristianPodcast #CurrentEvents #BiblicalJustice #FaithAndCulture #ChristianCommentary #Atonement #SymbolicViolence

In this episode of Thinking Out Loud, Nathan & Cameron dive into a nuanced theological discussion on Ross Douthat’s latest book Believe, exploring the provocative idea that religion—even in its broadest form—can serve as a legitimate and vital stepping stone toward Christianity. They examine Douthat’s arguments through the lens of current cultural disinterest in organized faith, C.S. Lewis’s concept of “mere Christianity,” and spiritual seekers like Simone Weil and David Foster Wallace. Is structured religion still the best place to begin a sincere search for truth in the modern age? Join them as they wrestle with these questions, challenge each other, and consider whether religion is a crutch, a catalyst, or a compass in a post-Christian world. Perfect for Christians craving thoughtful, biblically grounded commentary on contemporary spiritual issues.

DONATE LINK: https://toltogether.com/donate 

BOOK A SPEAKER: https://toltogether.com/book-a-speaker

JOIN TOL CONNECT: https://toltogether.com/tol-connect 

TOL Connect is an online forum where TOL listeners can continue the conversation begun on the podcast.

In this episode of Thinking Out Loud, we dive deep into a disturbing and tragic event—the bombing of a fertility clinic in Palm Springs by a self-proclaimed "pro-mortalist." While grieving the loss of life, we also explore the unsettling philosophical underpinnings of this act, including anti-natalism, pro-mortalism, and the idolization of consent as the highest moral authority. For Christians seeking thoughtful, theologically grounded discussions on current events, this conversation unpacks how modern moral frameworks—rooted in radical autonomy, subjective consent, and distorted views of love and freedom—can lead to logical yet dangerous conclusions. We contrast these ideologies with a biblical worldview, challenging the cultural narrative that human beings are the ultimate moral arbiters. Join us as we confront the implications of being born "without consent" and what it reveals about our cultural moment.DONATE LINK: ⁠https://toltogether.com/donate ⁠BOOK A SPEAKER: ⁠https://toltogether.com/book-a-speaker⁠JOIN TOL CONNECT: ⁠https://toltogether.com/tol-connect ⁠

TOL Connect is an online forum where TOL listeners can continue the conversation begun on the podcast.

In this episode of Thinking Out Loud, we dive deep into the crisis of attention in the digital age and its profound implications for Christian witness, spiritual formation, and intellectual integrity. Are we losing our ability to think deeply, listen well, and discern truth amidst the noise? Join us as we explore how Sabbath, solitude, intentionality, and community can help reclaim a Christ-centered focus in a world of distraction. With references to Dallas Willard, Joseph Pieper, and the Screwtape Letters, this conversation equips Christians, apologists, and thoughtful believers to pursue meaningful theology, cultural analysis, and spiritual disciplines that resist the algorithm and restore the mind. Perfect for Christians seeking more than hot takes—subscribe for rich theological dialogue on faith, culture, and formation.

DONATE LINK: https://toltogether.com/donate 

BOOK A SPEAKER: https://toltogether.com/book-a-speaker

JOIN TOL CONNECT: https://toltogether.com/tol-connect 

TOL Connect is an online forum where TOL listeners can continue the conversation begun on the podcast.

In this episode of Thinking Out Loud, we dive into the morally complex decision by the U.S. to reduce medical aid to Zambia due to systemic government corruption—and ask how Christians should think through such dilemmas. With a focus on ethical reasoning, moral calculus, and Christian theology, Nathan and Cameron explore the spiritual and practical tensions involved in foreign aid, workplace complicity, and the moral responsibilities of believers living in a broken system. What does Scripture say about giving, accountability, and justice? How do we balance compassion with stewardship? Join us for a deep, faith-informed conversation on global corruption, moral math, and Christian responses to injustice in an age of political compromise. If you care about Christian ethics, global missions, and theology applied to real-world events, this episode is for you.

DONATE LINK: https://toltogether.com/donate 

BOOK A SPEAKER: https://toltogether.com/book-a-speaker

JOIN TOL CONNECT: https://toltogether.com/tol-connect 

TOL Connect is an online forum where TOL listeners can continue the conversation begun on the podcast.

In this thought-provoking conversation, Cameron and Nathan explore the crucial difference between defending Christianity and being a defensive Christian. Rooted in biblical wisdom and apologetic insight, they challenge believers to stand firm in their faith without fear or insecurity. From tackling common objections to Christianity, to addressing the cultural pressure to stay silent, this episode equips Christians to respond with clarity, humility, and strength. Whether you're engaging skeptics or wrestling with doubts, you'll discover how Christian apologetics isn't about proving God needs us—but about faithfully representing what we believe. Perfect for believers seeking to grow in intellectual discipleship, biblical confidence, and gospel witness.

DONATE LINK: https://toltogether.com/donate 

BOOK A SPEAKER: https://toltogether.com/book-a-speaker

JOIN TOL CONNECT: https://toltogether.com/tol-connect 

TOL Connect is an online forum where TOL listeners can continue the conversation begun on the podcast.

#ChristianApologetics #DefendingFaith #ChristianPodcast #FaithAndReason #SpiritualGrowth #ThinkingOutLoudPodcast #BiblicalWorldview

In this episode of Thinking Out Loud, Cameron and Nathan dive deep into the theological roots of Western love, exposing how today’s culture has redefined love using borrowed Christian language—without the God who gives it meaning. Drawing from philosophers like Simon May and theologians such as N.T. Wright, we challenge the four foundational assumptions about love in today’s world: that it is unconditional, disinterested, all-affirming, and enduring. These ideas, often taken for granted, echo divine attributes that humans simply can't sustain. As we attempt to live them out without God, we end up playing God ourselves—a move that leads not to freedom, but confusion and relational breakdown.Whether it’s the phrase “love is love” or the cultural obsession with affirmation, this discussion unpacks how our post-Christian society has built a fragile theology of love on sand—and what Scripture says we should build instead. This is a must-listen for any Christian thinker, pastor, or layperson wrestling with the cultural narratives of identity, romance, and meaning.

🔔 Subscribe for more deep Christian conversations on culture, theology, and truth.

👍 Like, comment, and share to help spread thoughtful faith-based content.

DONATE LINK: https://toltogether.com/donate

BOOK A SPEAKER: https://toltogether.com/book-a-speaker

JOIN TOL CONNECT: https://toltogether.com/tol-connect

TOL Connect is an online forum where TOL listeners can continue the conversation begun on the podcast.

📚 Referenced Authors & Ideas:

Simon May – Love: A New Understanding of an Ancient Emotion

N.T. Wright

Charles Taylor

In this episode of Thinking Out Loud, Cameron McAllister and Nathan Rittenhouse perform an intellectual autopsy of the New Atheist movement, reflecting on its cultural rise and current irrelevance. They unpack why arguments from figures like Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, and Sam Harris no longer resonate—especially in light of Christianity’s enduring philosophical and moral foundations. With references to current debates, including a dismantling of Lawrence Krauss’s secular claims, this episode provides Christians with a robust understanding of how to engage secular critiques with grace and intellectual rigor. Whether you're interested in apologetics, cultural commentary, or the intersection of theology and modern society, this conversation is for you.

DONATE LINK: https://toltogether.com/donate 

BOOK A SPEAKER: https://toltogether.com/book-a-speaker

JOIN TOL CONNECT: https://toltogether.com/tol-connect 

TOL Connect is an online forum where TOL listeners can continue the conversation begun on the podcast.

👉 Subscribe for more conversations on faith, philosophy, and culture.

🎧 Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts