In part 1 of this deeply saddening series, we show how Sylvia Likens and her sister came into the home of deranged mother Gertrude Baniszewski, and an introduction to the torture and horrors that awaited them inside. We are entering into a living nightmare that will forever change you.

After the previous doozy of an episode, it's time for something a little more simple: one of those wholesome stories of boy meets girl, boy marries girl, and boy murders girl. David Stewart was convicted of his wife Debbie's 1984 murder in Decatur, AL. From expensive home remodeling projects to questionably installed fish ponds, we look at how financial woes may have led to the birth of a murderer... or perhaps, how the devil was already in him at the start. Roll tide.

Just imagine The Avengers theme song playing for this one, because we ain’t messing with the Disney beast. We explore the tragic past of Jason Vukovich who, after his own experiences as a victim, became an avenging angel and brought vigilante justice to registered pedophiles in Alaska. How can a man's actions be wrong, yet at the same time oh so right?

That sweet-looking old woman couldn’t possibly hurt you, right? Right…? Meet habitual liar and convicted serial killer Dorothea Puente, who preyed upon the elderly and disabled tenants of her boarding house for those sweet, sweet social security checks.

Everybody has heard of the Bermuda Triangle.. but have you ever heard of its obtuse cousin? This vast region between Anchorage, Juneau, and Barrow (now called Utqiagvik) is known for missing airplanes and up to tens of thousands of disappearances. The only things more wild than the incredible amount of vanishings are the theories which attempt to explain them. Don your tinfoil hats, because we discuss theories of murder, aliens, energy vortexes, cryptids, and of course the unforgiving wilderness itself. Journey with us to this mysterious location within The Last Frontier!

What could possibly be more American than our prison system? It's time to receive a history lesson on the world's very first penitentiary, where the goal was for prisoners to receive their penance (spoiler alert: hence the name!). From escapes to famous residents, from dubious practices to paranormal soup, we explore how this now preserved ruin came to be, and why it is considered one of the most haunted buildings in America.

As an added bonus, featured throughout this episode are select audio recordings taken during Jenn and Jimmy's twilight tour of Eastern State Penitentiary in May 2022! Do they contain sounds of the living... or artifacts of the dead? Tune in to judge it for yourself!

It doesn't get any easier to swallow. With little justice against the perpetrators, and up to dozens of bodies lost in the unknown, this unsatisfying conclusion to David Parker Ray's story will be sure to cause some heartache.

You may have heard of toys in the attic, but how about toys in the torture trailer? Here in part 1 we introduce David Parker Ray, a real-life Jigsaw with less morality and even more sadism. Live or die… the choice is not yours.

We finish out our series on Ed Gein, the Butcher of Plainfield, WI. You will learn all about the potential grave robbing, his house of horrors and flesh artisanry, and actual confession transcripts which have inspired (for better or worse) countless songs, games, and movies. Don your finest skin, and enter at your own peril.