Please enjoy this re-release of a 2022 premium episode!

Anthony Garcia seemed to have made it. He had overcome a severe learning disability to earn a medical degree from the University of Utah. Afterwards, he was admitted into the Pathology program at Creighton University. However, he washed out of that program and the two that followed. Garcia seemed to have weathered these setbacks, but then four murders were committed five years apart. And all four of the victims had ties to Creighton University’s Pathology Program. Were the murders somehow connected? It was difficult to believe that someone could have held a deadly grudge for so long.

Join us at the quiet end for The Grudge. As we dissect this fascinating case, we’ll tell you about Anthony Garcia’s childhood, his difficulties in medical school and residencies, and the unhinged life Garcia was living when these murders were committed.

Sources

Anthony Garcia’s Attorneys Want Him Evaluated for Mental Illness Before Death Penalty Hearing, World-Herald, Todd Cooper, 3/13/2027

Haunting, Dateline, S25 E24 Pathological: The Murderous Rage of Dr. Anthony Garcia by Henry J. Cordes and Todd Cooper

Resident Evil, 48 Hours, S30 E27

Trial Day 16-In Anthony Garcia Trial, Defense and Prosecution go at it One Last Time Before Handing Case to Jury, World Herald, Christopher Burbach

She was a vibrant young woman with a close-knit family and a promising life ahead. Then Claudia Lawrence vanished without a trace. No signs of struggle, no clear suspects—just a multitude of unanswered questions.

Join us for Vanished on Heworth Road. Today we dive deep into the mystery that has haunted York for over a decade. Despite extensive investigations, searches, and media coverage, no trace of Claudia has ever been found. The case remains unsolved, and it continues to raise questions about trust, secrets, and the people closest to her.

Sources

Answers for Claudia Podcast, Wondery

Claudia Lawrence: Timeline of her disappearance and suspected murder, The Press, Dan Bean, 12/22/2020. Retreived 6/12/2025.

Gone: The Disappearance of Claudia Lawrence and Her Father’s Desperate Search for the Truth, Neil Root, 3/14/2013.

No Leads from Claudia Lawrence searches in York, BBC News, 3/26/2010. Retreived 6/20/2025.

What Happened to Claudia? Alex Moss, 3/15/2019. Retreived 7/15/2025.

On a quiet morning in rural Michigan, a beloved television personality was gunned down in her own driveway. At first, it seemed like a stalker’s obsession had finally turned deadly. But as investigators dug deeper, the truth was much more sinister. The man she trusted most—the man she had vowed to love forever—was hiding his true character behind a mask of lies. Diane Newton King—mother, wife, and rising tv news personality—never made it to the inside of her home that day. Her children never had another moment with their mother.

Join us for Behind the Veil: Diane Newton King. Behind the wedding vows, the smiles, and the years of building and sustaining a family, there lurked a dark truth which threatened to destroy everything. This is not just a story about murder—it’s a story about trust shattered, love twisted, and the frightening question: How well do we really know the person we share our life with?

Sources

The Diane King Case, Suburban Secrets, S2, E2

Eye of the Beholder by Lowell Cauffiel

Killer Relationship, Oxygen Network, S3, E12

Mi v Bradford King, Court TV, https://www.courttv.com/?s=bradford+King, retreived 11/02/2025

News at 11, Forensic Files, S9, E5

Subscribe for ad-free, early, and bonus episodes

Record a voicemail for a future show

Contact Us

Shop TCB Merch

Michelle Herndon seemed to have it all. She was nearing completion of her degree and had a bright future ahead of her. She was engaged to a wonderful man. She had a lot of plans for her future. The only negatives for Michelle were her migraine headaches, which were excruciating.

Join us at the quiet end for Murder by Injection, a discussion about the tragic death of Michelle Herndon.

On a cool October morning in Richmond, Virginia, gunshots shattered the silence of the quiet suburban street where Fred Jablin lived with his two children. Fred, a respected professor and devoted father, had just stepped outside to grab his morning newspaper—something he did every day. But this day would be his last. Oblivious to the danger, he was ambushed in his own front yard as his children slept upstairs.

Join us for Murder in the Suburbs. As investigators searched for suspects and motivations for Fred’s murder, the name Piper Rountree came up again and again. Piper was Fred’s ex-wife. Their bitter divorce and custody battle had ended years earlier, but her resentment and hatred endured. Did Piper, a mother of three and former attorney, travel across state lines to execute her ex-husband. Today, we unravel this story of love turned lethal—the murder of Fred Jablin.

Sources

Die, My Love by Katherine Casey

Piper Ann Rountree v. Commonwealth of Virginia, Court of Appeals, 7/24/2007.

Piper Rountree gets life: She will be eligible for release after she turns 60, Richmond Times-Dispatch, 5/7/2005.

Subscribe for ad-free, early, and bonus episodes

Record a voicemail for a future show

Contact Us

Shop TCB Merch

On a quiet spring day in 1999, in the small town of Mena, Arkansas, 12-year-old Andi Brewer vanished. What began as a stay at her grandfather’s house cruelly turned into a nightmare that shook a community, devastated a family, and changed the way many people saw children’s safety and security forever.

Join us today for The Day Andi Disappeared. This is the story of a precious girl whose life was stolen far too soon and of her mother, who somehow turned her unimaginable grief into a force for justice. In today’s episode, we will go through the timeline of Andi’s disappearance, the chilling confession of her abductor, and the heartbreak and resilience she left behind for those who knew her.

Sources

Ark. inmate cites mental illness in death penalty appeal, Corrections1, Andrew DeMillo

Man tries to attack 12-year-old daughter’s killer, rapist in courtroom, Oklahoma News 4, 12/29/2014, retrieved 10/14/2025. https://www.corrections1.com/capital-punishment/articles/ark-inmate-cites-mental-illness-in-death-penalty-appeal-tha6TJoOzfKebZvk/

ROBERTS v. STATE, Supreme Court of Arkansas. Karl D. ROBERTS, Appellant v. STATE of Arkansas, Appellee. Decided: January 30, 2020. https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ar-supreme-court/2044572.html

Stolen by Rebecca Petty

Read “Stolen” by Rebecca Petty

Subscribe for ad-free, early, and bonus episodes

Record a voicemail for a future show

Contact Us

Shop TCB Merch

Please enjoy this premium episode from way back in 2017!  To get more premium episodes, minus the ads, subscribe at tiegrabber.com/subscribe.

Sugar Land is a peaceful, upper-class suburb southwest of Houston, Texas. But one quiet evening in December 2003, the community was shattered when a family of four was ambushed by an armed intruder as they entered their home.

Tricia Whitaker and her son Kevin were murdered. Now, son and brother of the deceased, Bart Whitaker, is on death row, convicted of capital murder and sentenced to lethal injection for masterminding a plot to murder his parents and brother. His father has forgiven him and visits him often. But does Bart deserve his father’s forgiveness? Does he feel any remorse?

Join us at the quiet end for a discussion of the crime and the punishment of Bart Whitaker on this episode of True Crime Brewery— Bad Seed: The Whitaker Family Murders.

On a warm September afternoon in 1969, 8-year-old Susan Nason vanished from her quiet suburban neighborhood. For two decades, her case remained cold, until a shocking bit of news broke the silence: a former playmate claimed she had witnessed Susan’s murder… and that it was committed by her own father.

Join us for Memory of Murder. Susan Nason’s story is not just a story about a horrible murder; it’s a story of dysfunctional family relationships and repressed memories. Memories can fade and some say they can return with devastating clarity. Today we are unravelling a complicated case that challenges the boundaries of psychology, criminal justice, and the truth itself. Are repressed memories a defense mechanism to protect oneself from painful experiences, or, like one prominent psychologist has said, are they the worst catastrophe to befall the mental health field since the lobotomy?

Sources

A Childhood Memory Sent Her Father to Prison for Murder. Was it Real? Los Angeles Times, Christopher Goffard, 8/7/2024.

Buried: Can you forget a murder? Showtime Miniseries, 2021.

Hey, Daddy, remember when you killed Susie? Arizona Dailoy Wildcat, Jamie Kanter, 8/27/1997.

Once Upon a Time: A True Story of Memory, Murder, and the Law by Harry MacLean

Subscribe for ad-free, early, and bonus episodes

Record a voicemail for a future show

Contact Us

Shop TCB Merch

On a quiet dirt road in Brackney, Pennsylvania, two best friends went skeet shooting in the woods. One would walk away but the other would not. Martin “Marty” Dillon was a respected attorney, a father, and a husband. That day, after he was shot dead, the tragedy was ruled an accident. But the truth was darker. Marty’s best friend, Dr. Stephen Scher, told the authorities that Marty tripped while chasing a porcupine and his gun went off. And for two decades, they believed him.

Join us today for The Doctor, the Wife, & the Set-Up. Secrets don’t always stay buried forever, in fact, they seem to have a way of coming out eventually. This is especially true when a killer marries his victim’s widow and raises her children as his own. This is a twisted story of betrayal, obsession, and cold-blooded murder hidden in plain sight.

Sources

SCHER’S WIFE PLEADS GUILTY, GETS PROBATION, The Morning Call, 10/4/2021.

Secrets from the Grave, Maria Eftimiades.

Subscribe for ad-free, early, and bonus episodes

Record a voicemail for a future show

Contact Us

Shop TCB Merch

Please enjoy this re-release of a premium show from 2022!

For more of these episodes and to get rid of ads, you can subscribe at tiegrabber.com/subscribe

Late on the night of November 17, 1978, Speedway, Indiana teenager Brian Kring stopped by his workplace, the Burger Chef fast food restaurant, to visit with his friends and offer them help closing up for the night. But when he arrived, he found the restaurant empty. The four employees working that night, 20-year-old Jayne Friedt, 16-year-old Daniel Davis, 16-year-old Mark Flemmonds, and 17-year-old Ruth Shelton were all gone, but the door was unlocked and all of the lights were still on. Unable to reach the assistant manager, Jayne, by phone, Brian finally called the police.  But when the police arrived, they were surprisingly cavalier.  In their opinion, a group of irresponsible teens had taken the cash from the till and gone off for a night of fun.

Join us at the quiet end for our discussion of the 1978 Burger Chef Murders.  The next day, the police would realize that they had made a big mistake.  None of the employees arrived home and their parents were frantic, but the police had not bothered to treat the abandoned restaurant as a crime scene.  Two days later, four dead bodies were discovered about 20 miles south of the scene.  The young Burger Chef employees had been stabbed, shot, and bludgeoned to death. Now, forty-three years later, no one has been arrested for these murders.

Sources:

American Crime Journal, “Forrester Confession”

https://www.insider.com/burger-chef-murders-unsolved-speedway-indiana

Indianapolis Monthly, “Next in Line: The Burger Chef Murders”

The Burger Chef Murders in Indiana, by Julie Young