
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


⚠️ Content advisory: This episode discusses the murders of a mother and two children, and later a survivor's thoughts of suicide. If you or someone you know is struggling, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, U.S.).
On March 1, 2008, in Alba, Texas, Penny Caffey and her sons, Matthew, 13, and Tyler, 8, were killed and their home was then set on fire. Terry Caffey was shot multiple times and crawled hundreds of yards to a neighbor's house for help. Within hours, investigators believed his 16-year-old daughter, Erin, was involved.
This episode looks at what Terry and Penny could see in the weeks before, what the phone records and evidence show about that night, the four different stories Erin has told, and why Terry still believes his daughter didn't plan it. We also cover Erin's 2026 habeas case, which is currently pending as of this episode.
📚 [SOURCES]
Court & official records
• Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, Ex parte Erin Michelle Caffey, WR-97,754-01/-02/-03 — remand order and dissenting opinion (Aug. 20, 2026); notices (Aug. 20 and Sept. 25, 2026)
• Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Inmate Search (inmate.tdcj.texas.gov), accessed Oct. 2026
• Recorded hospital interview with Erin Caffey, March 1, 2008
• Recorded interview with Terry Caffey, March 3, 2008
• Pamela Colloff, "Flesh and Blood," Texas Monthly, June 2009
• Associated Press reporting, March 2008 and January 2009 (via NBC News, Fox News, SFGate and KETR)
• Herald-Banner, March 3, 2008
• KLTV coverage, March 2008 – January 2009
• ABC News, June 2012
Interviews & accounts
• Terry Caffey & James H. Pence, Terror by Night (Tyndale, 2009)
• Terry Caffey, testimony at West Baptist Church, 2013
• Dr. Phil, two-part episode, 2014
• Killer Women with Piers Morgan, ITV, May 2016
• Tyler Morning Telegraph video feature
Where accounts conflict, the episode says so. Opinion is labeled as opinion.
🖼️ Some images in this episode are AI-generated illustrations. Photos of the people involved, the trailer and inside the courtroom are real.
🔔 YouTube: @TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎵 TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@truecrimefm_official
📸 Instagram: https://instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: https://facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
🎧 Podcast: https://truecrime.fm
🛒 Merch: https://tcfm.store
#TrueCrime #ErinCaffey #TexasTrueCrime
In November 2000, a groundskeeper at a veterans' home in Chelsea, Massachusetts, made a disturbing discovery. Police had a murder victim, but they had no idea who she was.
And here's where this case gets interesting...investigators did find the man responsible, eventually. He confessed, pleaded guilty, and went to prison.
The problem is, they still don't know WHO he had killed.
In the meantime, a family in Pennsylvania had been searching for a missing teenage girl since November 2000. Her name was Tiffany Bradley.
For 26 years, these two cases remained disconnected.
So how did investigators finally figure out that the woman they'd been calling Chelsea Jane Doe was Tiffany? And why did it take so long?
That's what we're getting into in this episode of TrueCrime FM.
🧡 HUMAN TRAFFICKING SUPPORT
If you or someone you know may be experiencing human trafficking, contact the National Human Trafficking Hotline:
Call: 1-888-373-7888
Text: 233733
If someone is in immediate danger, call 911.
🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO
🔔 YouTube: https://youtube.com/@TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎵 TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@truecrimefm_official
📸 Instagram: https://instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: https://facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
🎧 Podcast: https://truecrime.fm
🛒 Merch: https://tcfm.store
SOURCES & REFERENCES
Historical reporting (2000–2005)
The Boston Globe — November 14, 2000, p. 39. Reporting on the discovery at Chelsea Soldiers' Home.
The Boston Globe — November 16, 2000, p. 40. Investigation and victim identification efforts.
The Boston Globe — December 22, 2000, p. 47. Public appeal to identify Chelsea Jane Doe.
The Boston Globe — September 1, 2001, p. 21. Eugene McCollom's arrest and the investigation.
The Daily Item — September 1, 2001, pp. 1, 13. Arrest, surveillance evidence, and police findings.
The Boston Globe — January 20, 2004, p. 18. Developments in the Jane Doe investigation.
The Patriot Ledger — March 9, 2004, p. 16. John Leyden murder investigation.
The Daily Item — April 24, 2004, p. 5. Reporting on other investigated cases.
Telegram & Gazette / Associated Press — February 24, 2005, p. 2. McCollom's guilty plea and sentencing.
The Daily Item — February 25, 2005, pp. 1, 5. Sentencing and the unidentified victim.
Tiffany Bradley's identification (2026)
The Boston Globe — June 4, 2026, pp. B1, B4. Identification of Chelsea Jane Doe as Tiffany Bradley, the family's search, and investigative genetic genealogy.
FBI Boston / Suffolk County District Attorney — June 2026 identification announcement and press conference, referenced in the case research.
#TiffanyBradley #ChelseaJaneDoe #TrueCrimeFM
🛒 Merch: https://tcfm.store
In 2023, police showed up at the door of Steven White. They had pics of him robbing someone's home the night before. He didn't deny it but then told them that the woman who lived there was a murderer.
That'll get your attention.
The woman who lived there was Marsha Allen and her husband, Harold "Peanut" Allen, had died at home five days before Christmas in 2022 after being sick for weeks and with more than one trip to the ER.
HIs death was attributed to heart problems but no one tested his blood for poison until this burgler gave police a tip and the whole mother / daughter plan fell apart.
🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO:
🔔 YouTube: https://youtube.com/@TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎵 TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@truecrimefm_official
📸 Instagram: https://instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: https://facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
🎧 Podcast: https://truecrime.fm
🛒 Merch: https://tcfm.store
00:00 The Break In
02:27 Meet Harold "Peanut" Allen
05:32 Harold Gets Sick
06:43 Death Ruled Natural
08:13 The Break In
12:20 Marsha's Interview
17:15 The Text Messages
20:10 Root Beer Floats
23:29 Search Warrant for Marsha's Place
25:58 Marsha Found Dead
27:26 Ashley's Interrogation Begins
36:29 Charges and Money Motive
46:24 Sentencing and Aftermath
48:54 Ty’s Death Revisited
Probable cause affidavit, Lt. Adam Nicholson, Jackson County Sheriff's Department (Oct. 26, 2023)
Charging information and MyCase docket, Jackson Circuit Court, 36C01-2310-MR-000001
Bodycam and interrogation footage
Seymour Tribune (Oct. 28, 2023; Aug. 16, 2024; Aug. 23, 2025; Sept. 27, 2025)
Nexstar / WANE / Fox59 (Aug. 2024)
Law&Crime (Oct. 19 and Oct. 27, 2023)
106.1 The River (Sept. 24, 2025)
CBS News, 48 Hours, "The Root Beer Float Murder" (April 2026)
This episode discusses suicide. If you're struggling or worried about someone, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (US).
#TrueCrime #TrueCrimeFM #Indiana
Grab a coffee, or whatever your favorite true-crime drink might be, and let’s get into the details of the Liz Barraza Case.
Liz Barraza was just setting up a garage sale in Tomball, Texas when a truck pulled up. Minutes later, she would be laying in her driveway, unable to respond.
On this day, someone knew exactly when Liz's husband would leave for work, knew Liz would be there and knew she would be having a garage sale that day. The lead investigator calls the timing of this crime "impeccable."
00:00 Garage Sale Ambush
02:29 Who Was Liz
06:26 Timeline To The Shooting
08:51 What The Cameras Caught
22:10 Crime Scene Evidence
24:56 Hunting For A Motive
27:47 Oscar And Money Trouble
33:25 501st Leads And The Boots
37:55 Tracking The Frontier
39:43 Geofence And Dead Ends
42:32 Later Theories Amber And Gang
47:29 Open Case And Reward
🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO:
🔔 YouTube: @TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎧 Podcast: https://TrueCrime.fm
📸 Instagram: instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
Sources: Sgt. Ritchie Interviews @TrueCrimeUnsolvedShow
Several news sources including KPRC / Click2Houston, ABC13/KTRK, KHOU, NBC News Dateline, Fox 26 Houston, and the family website created for Liz at https://whokilledlizbarraza.com.
Grab a coffee, or whatever your favorite true-crime drink might be, and let’s get into the details of the Lindsay Clancy Trial.
📂 SUPPORT THE RESEARCH & UNLOCK MORE:
Join the Coffee Tier for Early Access or the Beer Tier for Exclusive Extras.
https://TrueCrime.fm/support
This episode is a little different than most. So many questions have been raised at Lindsay Clancy's trial and a lot of them about her ex-husband. So many rumors and speculation are flying around online, I thought I'd take a look at some of them.
And some really did make me step back and say ... wait a minute...
We'll learn about Lindsay and what happened in the months leading up to the crime, how her mental health deteriorated rapidly, we'll talk about what was digitally recorded while Patrick went to CVS and then to ThreeV to pick up takeout. We'll talk about what Patrick found, in what order, and so much more.
It's important to know that this episode talks about what was actually presented at trial from online speculation and my own observations.
⚠️ Content Warning: This episode discusses the deaths of children, suicide attempts, mental illness, and other disturbing subject matter.
This episode contains commentary and opinion. Allegations, theories, and questions discussed online are identified as such and should not be treated as established facts.
00:00 Lindsay
00:34 Case Summary
02:24 Arrest Timeline
05:32 Online Suspicion
08:56 Mental Health History
15:09 Intrusive Thoughts
18:02 Hospitals and Medication
25:42 Jan 24 Timeline
31:56 CVS Footage Questions
40:51 Stair Climb
47:43 ThreeV Timeline
49:12 The Shoes
53:47 Window Fall
55:03 911 Call Issues
58:47 The Discovery
01:01:59 First Responder Timeline
01:09:41 The Arrest
01:12:41 Webcam Theory
01:20:13 Crime Scene Evidence Left Behind
01:23:55 Toxicology and DNA
01:25:58 Rumors About Travel
01:30:50 The Medical System Failure
Videos & Transcripts
https://webflow.rev.com/search?query=Lindsay+Clancy
https://whdh.com/news/surreal-neighbors-residents-grapple-with-deaths-of-young-children-in-duxbury/
https://parade.com/news/lindsay-clancy-911-call
🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO:
🔔 YouTube: @TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎧 Podcast: https://TrueCrime.fm
📸 Instagram: instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
Visit The Home Security Superstore. Trusted by thousands including law enforcement. https://bit.ly/4glu1GT
This episode contains an affiliate link to The Home Security Superstore. If you use it, it helps support the show at no extra cost to you.
Grab a coffee, or whatever your favorite true-crime drink might be, and let’s get into the details.
📂 SUPPORT THE RESEARCH & UNLOCK MORE:
Join the Coffee Tier for Early Access or the Beer Tier for Exclusive Extras.
https://TrueCrime.fm/support
In 2004, a man in Colorado rented out the basement of his townhouse. Three weeks later, he was d3ad. His "tenant" has never been identified.
Al Kite was a well-liked 53-year-old man who was a kind man and a dedicated worker. He had purchased a townhouse and like most homeowners wanting to help their income, he rented out his basement.
The man who answered the ad called himself Robert Cooper but everything he put on the rental agreement was fake. Three weeks after first meeting Mr. Cooper, Al would be found in his basement in the most heinous way.
00:00 They have his DNA & still don't know who he is
03:28 Who Was Al Kite
05:58 Basement for Rent
09:47 Al is Discovered
14:08 Who is Robert Cooper?
17:52 Theories
20:24 The DNA Profile
23:10 Motive?
24:52 Still a Cold Case
🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO:
🔔 YouTube: @TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎧 Podcast: https://TrueCrime.fm
📸 Instagram: instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
SOURCES
Oxygen — The DNA of Murder with Paul Holes: https://www.oxygen.com/the-dna-of-murder-with-paul-holes/crime-news/paul-holes-investigates-colorado-murder-of-oakey-al
Denver Gazette — "Cold Case: Brutal killing of Colorado homeowner has ties to mysterious renter": https://www.denvergazette.com/outtherecolorado/cold-case-brutal-killing-of-colorado-homeowner-has-ties-to-mysterious-renter-f0e205a4-1c6d-489e-86e5-cc5243972a5c/
Colorado Bureau of Investigation — Cold Case Database: https://apps.colorado.gov/apps/coldcase/casedetail.html?id=193
Aurora Police Department
FOHVAMP (Families of Homicide Victims and Missing Persons)
Find A Grave: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/25163639/oakey_albert-kite
The News & Observer, obituary (via Legacy.com): https://www.legacy.com/obituaries/name/oakey-kite-obituary?pid=85831462
Unresolved (unresolved.me)
The Seattle Times — "Man reportedly linked to killing": https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/man-reportedly-linked-to-killing/
KIRO 7 News, Seattle
Parabon NanoLabs
INTERPOL — DNA Gateway
FBI — CODIS/NDIS
#truecrime #truecrimedocumentary #murdermystery #interrogation #truecrimecommunity #truecrimefm
Grab a coffee, or whatever your favorite true-crime drink might be, and let's get into the details of the Darlie Routier case.
📂 SUPPORT THE RESEARCH & UNLOCK MORE:
Join the Coffee Tier for Early Access or the Beer Tier for Exclusive Extras.
https://TrueCrime.fm/support
It's a little after 2:30 in the morning in Rowlett, Texas, when 26-year-old Darlie Routier calls 911. Her sons, six-year-old Devon and five-year-old Damon, have been stabbed. Darlie survives with a knife wound across her neck, and for the first officers on scene, she's the surviving victim of a home invasion. Twelve days later, she's arrested for capital murder.
So what changed? We're going back through the cut window screen, the knife on the utility room floor, the sock found 70 yards from the house, the silly string video that only showed half the story, and the attorney switch 11 weeks before trial that still doesn't sit right. I have questions. Some of this is suspicious. Some of it is just contamination and bad luck. This episode traces every claim back to trial transcripts, sworn affidavits, and named sources — no embellishment, just what's actually on the record.
⏱️ CHAPTERS:
00:00 The 911 Call
02:21 Who Were the Routiers?
05:59 Night Before the Attack
07:38 Darlie's Account
11:13 First Responders Arrive
14:00 Crime Scene Questions
19:52 The Screen, The Knives & The Footprints
25:50 The Sock
28:31 The Silly String Video
32:03 Darlie Is Arrested
34:07 Darlie's Attorney(s)
42:10 The Trial
43:11 The Transcript Scandal
47:19 DNA Testing Limbo
50:09 Closing Thoughts
🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO:
🔔 YouTube: @TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎧 Podcast: https://TrueCrime.fm
📸 Instagram: instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
#truecrime #truecrimedocumentary #murdermystery #interrogation #truecrimecommunity #truecrimefm
Grab a coffee, or whatever your favorite true-crime drink might be, and let’s get into the details of The Springfield Three - The Finale.
📂 SUPPORT THE RESEARCH & UNLOCK MORE:
Join the Coffee Tier for Early Access or the Beer Tier for Exclusive Extras.
https://TrueCrime.fm/support
In this episode, we go back through everything that's never been fully explained: the purses left behind, the picture frame in Suzie's bedroom that the police asked the public about, a 2002 statement that "no outside fingerprints" were ever found inside the house, and a cropped photo from the night before the women disappeared that appeared on a national television program.
And one person who was there that night that has never been publicly addressed.
If you have information about this case, contact the Springfield Police Department's non-emergency line: 417-864-1810.
🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO:
🔔 YouTube: @TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎧 Podcast: https://TrueCrime.fm
📸 Instagram: instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
#truecrime #truecrimedocumentary #murdermystery #interrogation #truecrimecommunity #truecrimefm
He Said He'd Talk When His Mother Died | The Springfield 3 Part 3
Grab a coffee, or whatever your favorite true-crime drink might be, and let’s get into the details of The Springfield Three. I’ve been digging into the details…let's learn about the suspects.
📂 SUPPORT THE RESEARCH & UNLOCK MORE:
Join the Coffee Tier for Early Access or the Beer Tier for Exclusive Extras.
https://TrueCrime.fm/support
In 1992, three women vanished overnight from a home in Springfield, Missouri — and within days, police had a sketch that was published in a newspaper, tons of tips and a list of names that they were polygraphing.
Today, we cover the well-known suspects, Suzie's brother, a not-so-great ex boyfriend, three men connected to a mausoleum robbery and man sitting in a Texas prison who may just be playing games.
Not to mention a van. A van seen by several people, all who give a different description of the color.
00:00 Three Women Vanish — Case Recap
02:01 The Composite Sketch That Flooded the Hotline
04:44 Polygraphs and Public Pressure
06:35 Bartt Streeter — The Brother Under Scrutiny
13:07 Mike Kovacs — The Ex-Boyfriend with a Restraining Order
17:08 Chief Knowles and the Micromanaged Investigation
22:08 The Mausoleum Break-In and What It Means
29:40 Robert Craig Cox — The Most Notorious Name
37:35 The Mysterious Van — Three Witnesses, Three Descriptions
43:06 What We Know and What We Don't
46:14 Episode 4 Tease — The Photo, the Name, and the Ethics
🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO:
🔔 YouTube: @TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎧 Podcast: https://TrueCrime.fm
📸 Instagram: instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
#truecrime #truecrimedocumentary #murdermystery #interrogation #truecrimecommunity #truecrimefm
Grab a coffee, or whatever your favorite true-crime drink might be, and let’s get into the details of The Springfield 3 - Part 2. I’ve been digging into the details…let’s listen.
📂 SUPPORT THE RESEARCH & UNLOCK MORE:
Join the Coffee Tier for Early Access or the Beer Tier for Exclusive Extras.
https://TrueCrime.fm/support
They were supposed to go to Whitewater in the morning. Suzie and Stacy were supposed to call. When they didn't, Janelle called the house. No answer. She called again, and again, and again, nearly a dozen times. Still nothing.
Finally she drove over to check. The cars were there. There was also a broken porch light, an unlocked door, purses left behind, one with migraine medication that Stacy needed. But no one was around.
Episode 2 follows what happened the day the women were discovered missing. The obscene phone calls. The dog, Cinnamon and what the neighbors said about her.
This is the day the case began.
Part 1:
https://truecrime.fm/episode/-graduated-in-the-afternoon-vanished-by-morning-the-springfield-three-part-1/
00:00 Springfield Three: Unanswered Morning Calls
00:10 Recap and Timeline Gap
01:24 Janelle’s Calls Begin
02:28 First Visit Broken Porch Light
03:36 Inside the House Clues
05:34 Obscene Phone Calls
07:08 Searching Town and Assumptions
08:36 Janis Gets Involved
11:03 Second Check and Caller Returns
15:11 Janis Arrives at Delmar
20:15 Crowd Gathers Crime Scene Contaminated
22:38 Police Arrive and Initial Report
24:58 Timeline Conflicts and Walkthrough
29:31 Struggle Or Not
30:54 Purses And Clothing
33:42 Cinnamon Timeline Clues
36:41 Answering Machine Mystery
39:29 House Locked And Rumors
44:31 Hospitals Media And Nigel
52:29 Police Mobilize Search
54:44 Evidence Inside The House
59:39 Prowler Tips And Next
01:02:01 Wrap Up Next Episode
🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO:
🔔 YouTube: @TrueCrimeFM_Official
🎧 Podcast: https://TrueCrime.fm
📸 Instagram: instagram.com/TrueCrimefm
👥 Facebook: facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM
#truecrime #truecrimedocumentary #mystery #springfieldthree #truecrimecommunity #truecrimefm #unsolvedcases
Research sources: Springfield News-Leader, Kansas City Star, Laura Bauer's "Ten Years Later" investigative series, SPD Case #92-40169, and public records.
From the publisher's feed

10,574 Listeners