When someone is attacked, especially in their home, the victim usually knows the person hurting them. And in the 2002 murder of a woman named Marlyne Johnson, the police charged her daughter-in-law, Sophia Johnson, with first degree murder. The whole ordeal tore two families apart because not only was Sophia charged with killing her mother-in-law, but the main witness against her was her own brother. Amory Sivertson dives back into the case in her new podcast, Beyond All Repair. She joins Crime Story now.  To listen to Crime Story early and ad-free, subscribe to <a href="https://apple.co/cbctruecrime" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">CBC True Crime Premium on Apple Podcasts</a>. Feedback for us? You can email us directly at crimestory@cbc.ca.

When someone is attacked, especially in their home, the victim usually knows the person hurting them. And in the 2002 murder of a woman named Marlyne Johnson, the police charged her daughter-in-law, Sophia Johnson, with first degree murder. The whole ordeal tore two families apart because not only was Sophia charged with killing her mother-in-law, but the main witness against her was her own brother. Amory Sivertson dives back into the case in her new podcast, Beyond All Repair. She joins Crime Story now. To listen to Crime Story early and ad-free, subscribe to CBC True Crime Premium on Apple Podcasts. Feedback for us? You can email us directly at crimestory@cbc.ca.

When someone is attacked, especially in their home, the victim usually knows the person hurting them. And in the 2002 murder of a woman named Marlyne Johnson, the police charged her daughter-in-law, Sophia Johnson, with first degree murder. The whole ordeal tore two families apart because not only was Sophia charged with killing her mother-in-law, but the main witness against her was her own brother. Amory Sivertson dives back into the case in her new podcast, Beyond All Repair. She joins Crime Story now.&nbsp; To listen to Crime Story early and ad-free, subscribe to <a href="https://apple.co/cbctruecrime" rel="noopener noreferrer">CBC True Crime Premium on Apple Podcasts</a>. Feedback for us? You can email us directly at crimestory@cbc.ca.

Two siblings, one murder. Who should police believe?

This is true crime with journalistic integrity — and a curious, conversational edge. Every other Monday, Crime Story dives into gripping cases of every kind: from white-collar scandals and high-profile trials to under-the-radar stories you’ve never heard before. At the heart of each episode is a deep, intimate interview with someone who knows the case inside and out — the journalists, documentarians, and storytellers who’ve reported on these crimes, chased leads for years, and lost sleep uncovering the truth. Their insights cut through the noise, revealing not just what happened, but why it matters. Hosted by award-winning journalist Kathleen Goldhar — a true crime devotee with more than 20 years of experience and a track record of critically-acclaimed podcasts — the show blends sharp reporting with an authentic love for the genre.

True Crime

This is true crime with journalistic integrity — and a curious, conversational edge. Every other Monday, Crime Story dives into gripping cases of every kind: from white-collar scandals and high-profile trials to under-the-radar stories you’ve never heard before. At the heart of each episode is a deep, intimate interview with someone who knows the case inside and out — the journalists, documentarians, and storytellers who’ve reported on these crimes, chased leads for years, and lost sleep uncovering the truth. Their insights cut through the noise, revealing not just what happened, but why it matters. Hosted by award-winning journalist Kathleen Goldhar — a true crime devotee with more than 20 years of experience and a track record of critically-acclaimed podcasts — the show blends sharp reporting with an authentic love for the genre.

Share Two siblings, one murder. Who should police believe?

Sign up to save your podcasts

Two siblings, one murder. Who should police believe?

Two siblings, one murder. Who should police believe?

More shows like Crime Story

Someone Knows Something

In The Dark

Missing & Murdered: Finding Cleo

Canadian True Crime

Allison after NXIVM from Uncover

Crime Beat

The Pit

Island Crime

True North True Crime

Deep Cover Presents: Snowball

The Binge Cases: Watching You

Escaping NXIVM

The Village

Evil By Design

A Death In Cryptoland

The Next Call with David Ridgen

The Binge Crimes: The Crimes of Margo Freshwater

White Hot Hate: Agent Pale Horse

Boys Like Me

Kuper Island

The Kill List

Pressure Cooker

Bone Valley

The Con: Kaitlyn's Baby

The Africas VS. America

The No Good, Terribly Kind, Wonderful Lives and Tragic Deaths of Barry and Honey Sherman

Bad Results

Aftermath: Hunt for the Anthrax Killer

Sea of Lies

Dirtbag Climber