Watch It or Read It

This week, the ladies are turning the page on Jenny Han’s The Summer I Turned Pretty (book one) and things get pretty emotional. Amanda didn’t want to read this one… but surprise! She ended up loving the sweet, nostalgic chaos of Cousins Beach. Meanwhile, Dayelle is calling it the Gen Z Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret—a coming-of-age tale packed with sun-soaked angst, first loves, and an unfairly addictive love triangle. They’re breaking down book one vs season one of the Prime Video adaptation. What they loved and maybe didn't love....BUT it all comes down to the ultimate summer showdown: Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah? Oh, and did we mention? Pomegranate margaritas will be involved.

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

This week on Watch it or Read it, Amanda and Dayelle take a dive (or maybe a fall?) into Fallen, the YA paranormal romance that promised epic angel drama… and delivered something else entirely. They read the book, endured the epically bad movie, and checked out the newer TV adaptation so you don’t have to (but maybe you should?). Amanda did not hold back, she's got thoughts. Big ones. Meanwhile, Dayelle may or may not have watched the movie more times than she’s willing to admit and still has a soft spot for this gloriously messy movie. From tortured angels to confusing timelines to fanfiction-level dialogue, they dish hard on everything Fallen. So… should you watch it or read it, or let this one stay in 2009 where it belongs?

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

This was an unexpected one. The ladies had the rare opportunity to see a screener of On Swift Horses before it hit theaters AND were so moved, they immediately picked up the novel. What they found was a quietly powerful story about hidden desires, queerness, aching isolation, and the pursuit of freedom. They break down the breathtaking adaptation—moody, magnetic, and charged with longing and how it both mirrors and deepens Shannon Pufahl’s stunning prose. And if you stick around to the end, you’ll get to hear from Shannon herself. Yep—they got to interview her, and she was absolutely incredible. Thoughtful, generous, and just as brilliant as her writing. You don’t want to miss this one.

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

Season Four is here! AND we’re starting with a swoon worthy BANG! Amanda and Dayelle are heading through the stones to 18th Century Scotland with the one and only Outlander, written by Diana Gabaldon. Let’s be real...this episode is 50% book talk, 50% Jamie Fraser thirst. The chemistry between Claire and Jamie? Off the charts. The adaptation? Practically perfect. The kilts? Always welcome. Whether you’re Team Book, Team Show, or just Team "Let’s Gush About Jamie," this is the episode to kick off your next obsession. AND of course should you Watch it or Read it? OR BOTH.

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

Amanda and Dayelle are diving into Long Bright River by Liz Moore. This one took us on a ride we weren’t expecting. A gripping mix of crime thriller, family drama, and emotional depth, this book had us hooked from page one. And just when we thought we had our opinions locked in, the new screen adaptation dropped on Peacock, shaking things up even more. Did it do the novel justice? Were the characters as compelling on screen as they were on the page? And most importantly should you watch it or read it?

Oh, and we were supposed to interview Liz Moore herself… but let’s just say, plans took an unexpected turn. We’ll spill all the details in the episode!

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

This week, Amanda and Dayelle are heading back to Forks, Washington, where the rain never stops, vampires sparkle, and werewolves have the best hair game in town. That’s right—they’re diving into The Twilight Saga: New Moon by Stephenie Meyer!

From Bella’s heartbreak and Edward’s dramatic exit to Jacob’s luscious locks. Amanda and Dayelle will compare the book to its movie adaptation, explore what worked (and what didn’t), and, of course, tackle the ultimate question: Should you watch it or read it?

So grab your Team Edward or Team Jacob merch, settle in with a cozy drink, and join Amanda and Dayelle as they revisit the world of New Moon!

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

This week Amanda and Dayelle are throwing it back to their awkward tween years as they revisit Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret by Judy Blume.

From "Grow with Me" bras to figuring out who you are, they’re spilling all the tea on Margaret’s relatable journey through girlhood. Plus, they’ll dish on how the recent movie adaptation stacks up against the beloved book—what made them laugh, what made them cry and of course they’ll settle the big question: Should you Watch it or Read it?

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

This week, Amanda and Dayelle are diving into the world of wine-soaked journals, awkward encounters, and every Pride & Prejudice easter egg. If you guessed Bridget Jones's Diary by Helen Fielding, you're spot on!

Join them as they break down the beloved book and its iconic movie adaptation. From Bridget’s judgy inner monologue to the unforgettable love triangle with Mark Darcy and Daniel Cleaver, Amanda and Dayelle chat about everything they loved—and what didn’t quite hit. And of course, they’ll tackle the age-old question: Should you watch it or read it?

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

This week Amanda and Dayelle dive into what they are currently reading, what's on their TBR's and a whole lot of book gossip! Including a quick mention of a certain author, her book to movie adaptation thats been getting a lot of attention. Some Onyx Storm recapping (no spoilers don't worry) AND catch up on all things book related.

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.