Gary and Selena unpack their night at Hamilton and everything that followed, from struggling to understand the lyrics to questioning why certain cultural experiences are treated as untouchable. The conversation drifts into live theater expectations, nostalgia driven hype, and how something widely praised can still feel alienating in real time. From there Gary and Selena spiral into period logistics, awkward bodily realities, conspiracy theories, elite myths, celebrity obsession, and historical figures behaving badly. The episode moves freely between humor, confusion, irritation, and curiosity, capturing the feeling of sitting nearby while two people talk through what confused them, annoyed them, and stuck in their heads long after the night was over.

Gary and Selena unpack their night at Hamilton and everything that followed, from struggling to understand the lyrics to questioning why certain cultural experiences are treated as untouchable. The conversation drifts into live theater expectations, nostalgia driven hype, and how something widely praised can still feel alienating in real time.From there Gary and Selena spiral into period logistics, awkward bodily realities, conspiracy theories, elite myths, celebrity obsession, and historical figures behaving badly. The episode moves freely between humor, confusion, irritation, and curiosity, capturing the feeling of sitting nearby while two people talk through what confused them, annoyed them, and stuck in their heads long after the night was over.

Gary and Selena unpack their night at Hamilton and everything that followed, from struggling to understand the lyrics to questioning why certain cultural experiences are treated as untouchable. The conversation drifts into live theater expectations, nostalgia driven hype, and how something widely praised can still feel alienating in real time. From there Gary and Selena spiral into period logistics, awkward bodily realities, conspiracy theories, elite myths, celebrity obsession, and historical figures behaving badly. The episode moves freely between humor, confusion, irritation, and curiosity, capturing the feeling of sitting nearby while two people talk through what confused them, annoyed them, and stuck in their heads long after the night was over.

We Saw Hamilton.... Pt 1

Unfiltered conversations unfold between “Gary” and “Selena” as everyday observations slide into cultural commentary, media obsession, relationship dynamics, and moments that probably should have stayed private. Nothing is structured and very little is filtered. Topics drift from movies, celebrities, and internet culture into arguments, confessions, and reactions that feel slightly too honest. Some exchanges are funny, some are uncomfortable, and some cross into territory that is occasionally highly inappropriate.  “Gary” and “Selena” revisit disagreements, contradict themselves, escalate minor annoyances, and follow curiosity wherever it goes, without smoothing anything over. If you like sharp observations, messy honesty, and the feeling of being a fly on the wall during conversations you were never meant to hear, this is exactly that.

Comedy

Society & Culture

Personal Journals

Unfiltered conversations unfold between “Gary” and “Selena” as everyday observations slide into cultural commentary, media obsession, relationship dynamics, and moments that probably should have stayed private. Nothing is structured and very little is filtered.Topics drift from movies, celebrities, and internet culture into arguments, confessions, and reactions that feel slightly too honest. Some exchanges are funny, some are uncomfortable, and some cross into territory that is occasionally highly inappropriate. “Gary” and “Selena” revisit disagreements, contradict themselves, escalate minor annoyances, and follow curiosity wherever it goes, without smoothing anything over. If you like sharp observations, messy honesty, and the feeling of being a fly on the wall during conversations you were never meant to hear, this is exactly that.

Unfiltered conversations unfold between “Gary” and “Selena” as everyday observations slide into cultural commentary, media obsession, relationship dynamics, and moments that probably should have stayed private. Nothing is structured and very little is filtered. Topics drift from movies, celebrities, and internet culture into arguments, confessions, and reactions that feel slightly too honest. Some exchanges are funny, some are uncomfortable, and some cross into territory that is occasionally highly inappropriate.&nbsp; “Gary” and “Selena” revisit disagreements, contradict themselves, escalate minor annoyances, and follow curiosity wherever it goes, without smoothing anything over. If you like sharp observations, messy honesty, and the feeling of being a fly on the wall during conversations you were never meant to hear, this is exactly that.

Share We Saw Hamilton.... Pt 1

Sign up to save your podcasts

We Saw Hamilton.... Pt 1

We Saw Hamilton.... Pt 1

More shows like Terrible Person

The #JJRBTS (rehashed)

Johnjay & Rich On Demand

Mojo In The Morning

Kiss 95-7's War of the Roses

Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

Dave Ryan's War of the Roses

The War Of The Roses

Johnjay & Rich: After Words

Y100 Second Date Update

Marcus In The Morning Second Date Update

Sippin' TEAquila

Intern John & Your Morning Show's War Of The Roses

War of the Roses - To Catch a Cheater - The Jubal Show

Second Date Update

The Johnjay Van Es Podcast