For a special throwback episode, Bari and Dylan do a deep dive into RHONY’s iconic Scary Island trip. But first, they critique the costumes from this week’s RHONJ Halloween party, including Teresa as a cotton candy unicorn. From there, it’s all about candy queen Kelly Bensimon, whose behavior still makes no sense 10 years later. They revisit the debate about whether Bethenny is a cook or a chef, and discuss Jill’s ill-advised decision to surprise the ladies in St. John.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices