I know you've probably heard of the mothman or seen the movies, but do you know where this legend comes from? Apparently this thing is real and it is not some adorable little fairy like Beth hopes. In this episode, Ash tells us the history of the mothman and makes us all question, could this be real? Are there more creatures out there like this? And most importantly, do moths have opposable thumbs?!? Join us to find out...or at least to have some fun and speculate wildly (;

For the first time ever, we technically know what happened. But we don't know why or how and that's why we're here folks. Join us this week as we tell you the story of the woman who solved her own murder...

If you like ghosts, possession, and us, this ones for you (; 

IT'S GAME TIME LISTENERS! This week we are so excited to have our very first trivia night of many. We are quizzing each other on the episodes we've told and we're taking shots for every answer we get wrong. Spoiler: we had A LOT of shots. We would love it if you play along with us and test how lost you are... Drink responsibly and stay safe, love you all (;

Welcome to the first episode to scare Beth! This one is a doozy friends. The Jamison family goes missing in Oklahoma and after 4 years, their bodies are found with NO evidence or clues as to how they died. The Jamisons behavior prior to their disappearance was anything but normal, they had 32,000 cash on them, and the wife/mother Sherilynn had a long and hateful letter to her husband with her. This one has us googling and talking way after we finished recording. If you haven't been lost yet, this one will do it...

Disclaimer guys: Ash isn't 100% sure what lighthouses are for, but it's fine we're doing the episode anyway. Three men go mysteriously missing on Flannan Isles while they're supposed to be manning the lighthouse. Did they get abducted by a ghost ship? Get taken by a giant bird? Leave to start a new life as a beautiful happy throuple? We're going with C, but listen and tell us your thoughts? Make sure to stay until the end for some bloopers and we would love it if you could leave us a review on Apple Podcasts. Love ya!

This episode has us cancelling old men left and right. The amazing and talented Natalie Wood dies after "falling" into dark water while trying to take a boat to shore. There's one problem though, Natalie was TERRIFIED of dark water. The whole story is sketchy and Christopher Walken is randomly here?? Neither of us can do a good Walken impression, don't get your hopes up. The story changes over the years and by 2018 (37 years after the crime) her husband is declared a person of interest. Did she go on the boat intentionally? Did someone push her? Why is Walken being so weird? We have no answers. Welcome to We'reLost in case you're new (; 

A young couple moves into their dream home at 657 blvd and are immediately greeted with letters from "the watcher". This might be the episode that scares us the most. The watcher is terrifying and creepy, but also an undeniably amazing writer (don't hate us). We love this story as much as we are scared of it. What's the watcher's motive? Why is he doing this to these people? And what the actual f is up with the phrase "young blood"?? Join us for very little answers, but a thrilling story from your two bffs (;

We'd like to start this bio by saying that Ash is definitely haunted and sleep paralysis isn't a thing...JK FRIENDS! Apparently it is?? Listen to us have a terrifying and confusing conversation about different sleep paralysis experiences and theories surrounding this crazy phenomenon. We still don't get it and one of us will probably have it tonight. Sweet dreams (; 

P.s. please reach out if you've experienced sleep paralysis and share your story with us via instagram or our email! 

Sleep Paralysis - https://www.livescience.com/21653-brain-chemicals-sleep-paralysis.html

First recorded paralysis - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18691361/

The Old Hag - https://theravenreport.com/2017/02/21/finding-lilith-the-most-powerful-hag-in-history/

Hat Man - https://www.sinistercoffeeandcreamery.com/blog/hatman

This week Beth tells us about the tragic death of Josh Maddux aka the boy in the chimney (not loving that nickname). This one’s a sad one friends, but we do our best to make you laugh through it. We’re lost as ever and we’re also pretty sure we could be detectives in another life? Join us and help us understand. Or just be mad with us. Either is acceptable (: 

It’s Dyatlov pass time people and NOTHING makes sense. This week Ash’s telling us about a famous Russian mystery. 9 people died while on a trek, tongues are missing, eyebrows are gone, and we do not accept the explanation. Join us, be mad with us, we hate this, but we loveeee you. 

Sources :

BBC Article - https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/extra/SoLiOdJyCK/mystery_of_dyatlov_pass

Dead Mountain: The Untold True Story of the Dyatlov Pass Incident by Donnie Eichar

Photos - https://dyatlovpass.com/trek-photos