Let’s begin with what prompted me to contact today’s guest - the opening paragraph from an article from April 30th in The Nation magazine.
In 1807, Heinrich von Kleist published a short story called "The Earthquake in Chile." Its heroes are a man sitting in prison and a woman in a convent, each confined for the crime of conceiving their child out of wedlock. All of a sudden, an earthquake hits, the buildings that house them collapse, and the couple rediscover each other in the wreckage. Seeking shelter in the woods, they meet people who know of their sin but welcome rather than judge them. In the flush of the emergency, all is transformed: “Instead of the usual trivial tea-table gossip about the ways of the world, everyone was now telling stories of extraordinary heroic deeds.” Exhilarated, the couple follows the masses to the only remaining cathedral, where to their horror, the preacher rages against their transgressions. At the climax of the sermon, the crowd identifies the pair and clubs them to death. The inverted world is gone as soon as it came.
Earthquakes, pandemics, and economic collapse can bring much misery and suffering. But might they also be opportunities to see the world with fresh eyes (or as Slobodian says elsewhere, to get an X-ray view of governing structures). Is it a chance to practice living in different ways, to stand against the way that reductive systems use us? Or will it happen again that those in power and those with great wealth will rush in and capitalize upon disaster. That is the playbook after all.
President Donald J. Trump and Secretary of Commerce Wilbur Ross. Thursday, July 11, 2019 in the Rose Garden.
The vultures are circling overhead as unemployment rises to levels last seen in The Great Depression and corporations declare bankruptcy. But while we’re seeing little government assistance to aid actual people, bankruptcy is actually a kind of safety net. “As financial challenges continue to escalate amid this crisis, bankruptcy is sure to offer a financial safe harbor from the economic storm,” according to the institute’s executive director, Amy Quackenboss.
Notable recent bankruptcies are Neiman Marcus, the luxury department store, the apparel company J. Crew, and Hertz. Here’s a little detail about the Hertz bankruptcy that illustrates how capitalism defends itself from “the people”: 16,000 employees were cut loose and former CEO Kathryn Marinello walked away with over 9 million dollars in total compensation comprised in part of $1.45m as salary, $5.5m in stock, and always my favorite, $1.4m as a bonus.
Bankruptcy, it turns out, and as Donald Trump typifies, is a best practice, and best supported by government. From that same Nation article Slobodian writes
A pioneer in vulture investing and now the commerce secretary, Wilbur Ross praised bankruptcy in 2003 as “the corporate form of Darwinism.” Howard Marks, director of investment fund Oaktree Capital Management, was even more graphic in a recent letter to shareholders quoted in The Wall Street Journal. “Capitalism without bankruptcy is like Catholicism without hell,” he wrote, suggesting that federal bailouts shouldn’t shield market actors from “a healthy fear of loss.” He failed to add that people like himself have learned how to monetize the flames.
This is a part of statecraft as conceived by neoliberal thinkers. Specifically how institutions are designed to sit between the rulers and the ruled - from law courts and insurance companies to investment law and the World Trade Organization. According to Slobodian this is how capitalism is defended from mass democracy.
GUEST
Quinn Slobodian is a historian of modern German and international history, and the intellectual history of neoliberalism. His most recent book is Globalists: The End of Empire and the Birth of Neoliberalism (Harvard University Press) and he’s the co-editor (w...