What we lose in the Shadows (A father and daughter True Crime Podcast)

Send us Fan Mail

We dig into the 1945 Sauter house fire in Fayetteville, West Virginia and the five children who disappeared without a clear forensic answer. With Dr. Robert Rice’s fire and homicide experience, we map what likely happened, what was mishandled, and what modern DNA testing could still prove. 
• the Christmas Eve timeline including the phone call and roof impact 
• missing ladder, stalled coal trucks, and delayed emergency response 
• conflicting reports about bones, tissue, and what was truly recovered 
• why house fires rarely erase all remains without trace 
• how a proper excavation and fine sifting could still find fragments 
• reasons the faulty wiring conclusion feels unsupported 
• computer fire modeling and what it suggests about fire growth 
• arson possibilities including warnings, possible accelerants, and motive rumors 
• scene contamination, alleged evidence planting, and the cost of poor procedure 
• lost files, denied records requests, and why transparency matters 

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music 

Send us Fan Mail

A Tesla sits parked for too long in the Hollywood Hills, collecting parking tickets as neighbors grow concerned. Then, a strange smell changes everything. When police pop the trunk, they discover human remains so decomposed it takes weeks to identify victim: 14-year-old Celeste Rivas Hernandez, who had been reported missing months earlier. We take a closer look at who she was and where the evidence leads.

..

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music 

Send us Fan Mail

A breakup in a remote place can be cruel. On a mountain trail, it can become something much worse. We talk about the chilling phenomenon known as “alpine divorce” and why some people choose a hike, a forest, or a cliffside viewpoint to end a relationship where escape, witnesses, and cell service are limited. It’s not just awkward, it can be dangerous, and the psychology behind it often points to avoidance, poor communication, and a lack of empathy.

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music 

Send us Fan Mail

A school is supposed to be where kids get safer, not where adults get access. Today we’re unpacking a case that’s exploding online for all the worst reasons: an Arizona student allegedly groomed by a teacher who used gifts, money, special treatment, and constant texting to blur boundaries that should never move. We talk through the reporting around Haley Beck, the claims of thousands of messages, and why “almost 18” is not a moral loophole when the adult is the authority figure who controls grades, trust, and consequences.

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music 

Send us Fan Mail

A family’s move turns into tragedy on a summer hike when a stranger in black attacks, and two parents fight to protect their daughters. We trace the evidence that led to a barbershop arrest, examine red flags, and reflect on safety, community, and courage.

Devil's Den 'killer' Andrew James McGann was 'pretty cold' teacher
James Andrew McGann arrested for Devil's Den State Park double murder | Fox News

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music 

Send us Fan Mail

A routine traffic stop reveals the unthinkable horror hiding in plain sight. When Baltimore County police pulled over Nicole Johnson for minor traffic violations in July 2021, they never expected to discover the decomposing bodies of two children hidden in suitcases in her trunk. The horrifying revelation that Johnson had been driving around with the remains of her seven-year-old niece and five-year-old nephew for nearly a year stunned even the most experienced officers.

Woman Sentenced After Police Find Bodies of Niece, Nephew Decaying in Trunk

Aunt pleads guilty in deaths of 2 children from Dayton found in car trunk near Baltimore

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music 

Send us Fan Mail

The year was 1978 when Cheryl Bradshaw made what could have been a fatal mistake on national television. As the bachelorette on "The Dating Game," she chose bachelor number one – Rodney Alcala, a charming photographer with a winning smile. What she didn't know was that she had just selected a vicious serial killer in the midst of a murderous spree.

Trust your instincts when something feels wrong – it might just save your life. Subscribe and follow us on Instagram @whatweloseintheshadows to suggest cases and share your thoughts on this chilling story.

https://people.com/crime/how-a-serial-killer-and-rapist-ended-up-on-the-dating-game-and-was-chosen-by-the-girl/

https://nypost.com/2024/10/21/entertainment/how-serial-killer-rodney-alcala-ended-up-on-the-dating-game/

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music 

Send us Fan Mail

A two-decade mystery finally unravels as science catches up with a killer who had been hiding in plain sight all along. The murder of Leslie Preer in her Chevy Chase home shocked the community in 2001, but despite clear DNA evidence found beneath her fingernails and blood scattered throughout the crime scene, investigators hit a dead end with no matching profiles in their databases. Until now. 

Maryland man Eugene Gligor pleads guilty to killing ex-girlfriend's mother

Daughter's chilling realization after mom's 'killer' was finally revealed 23 years later

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music 

Send us Fan Mail

What happens when someone simply vanishes without explanation? The mysterious disappearance of 28-year-old Gretchen Fleming has left her family, friends, and an entire West Virginia community searching for answers for over two years.

The puzzle pieces of that fateful night remain scattered. We know she was last seen leaving a local establishment called My Way Lounge around 3 AM with Preston Pierce, a man who went by an alias and, most disturbingly, was a former law enforcement officer with 12 years of experience. While Pierce acknowledges Gretchen was in his car that night, he denies she came to his home - yet his inconsistent statements have made him a central person of interest in this perplexing case.

This story raises troubling questions about how someone can simply disappear in today's connected world. Was this foul play? Could trafficking be involved? Or is there another explanation for Gretchen's disappearance? If you have information, no matter how small, that might help solve this case, please contact the Parkersburg Police Department or submit an anonymous tip through West Virginia Crime Stoppers. Every detail matters in bringing Gretchen home.

Parkersburg Police chief: Gretchen Fleming case ‘not even close’ to cold | News, Sports, Jobs - News and Sentinel

FBI searches ex-officer's previous home who is person of interest in woman's disappearance

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music 

Send us Fan Mail

A legendary actor and his wife die alone in their mansion with no one to help them. The heartbreaking final days of Gene Hackman and Betsy Arakawa reveal a tragedy that unfolded in slow motion behind the gates of their Santa Fe estate.

When authorities discovered their bodies on February 26th, they pieced together a timeline that would chill anyone with aging loved ones. Betsy, a talented classical pianist 30 years younger than her husband, contracted the extremely rare Hantavirus and died around February 12th. What happened next is even more devastating – Hackman, suffering from advanced Alzheimer's and heart disease at 95, wandered their home alone for nearly a week, unable to comprehend what had happened or call for help.

Their story forces us to confront uncomfortable truths about aging and isolation. Despite Hackman's illustrious career spanning 40 years and 77 films, including Oscar-winning performances in "The French Connection" and "Unforgiven," fame and fortune couldn't protect them from tragedy. The couple had withdrawn from public life after Hackman's retirement in 2004, with Betsy becoming increasingly protective of her vulnerable husband, especially during the pandemic.

This episode explores how their deaths were initially shrouded in mystery, with speculation about carbon monoxide poisoning or foul play, before autopsies revealed the truth. We also unpack the complex aftermath regarding Hackman's $80 million estate, which he left entirely to Betsy while excluding his three children from his previous marriage.

Beyond the headlines, we remember the loving relationship between these two talented individuals who were frequently spotted holding hands, even after 34 years of marriage. Their tragic end reminds us that sometimes what we do to protect those we love most can have unintended consequences.

Follow us on Instagram @whatweloseintheshadows and join us next Tuesday for another compelling story from the shadows.

Gene Hackman was likely dead for 9 days before he and his wife were found, sheriff says | CNN

Santa Fe authorities update timeline on the last days of Gene Hackman and his wife | CNN

Gene Hackman's children not named in actor's $80m will

Contact us at: [email protected]



Background music by Michael Shuller Music