Simply Trade

Where Does Customs Belong? Org Structures That Make (or Break) Compliance


Listen Later

Hosts: Renee Chiuchiarelli & Julie Parks

Length: ~15 minutes
Format: Simply Trade Tips

Episode Summary

Welcome to Series 6 of Simply Trade Tips.

This series tackles a foundational — and often overlooked — issue in global trade:

Where does Customs actually sit inside your organization?

In this opening episode, Renee and Julie lay the groundwork by breaking down the three most common organizational structures and how each one impacts customs operations, compliance authority, budgeting, and risk management.

Because here’s the truth:

Customs rarely fails because people don’t care.

It fails because it’s structurally misaligned.

This episode sets the foundation for understanding how org structure dictates decision-making, funding, escalation paths, and ultimately — compliance outcomes.

Why Org Structure Matters for Customs

Customs sits in the middle of everything:

  • Procurement

  • Finance

  • Logistics

  • Legal

  • Tax

  • Sales & contracts

  • Export operations

    Yet it rarely “owns” all the decisions that affect it.

    That misalignment can create compliance gaps, conflicting priorities, and operational tension between speed and governance.

    Follow the money. Follow the reporting lines. That’s where risk lives.

    The Three Core Organizational Structures
    1️⃣ Centralized (Functional) Structure

    Definition:

    Departments operate in defined lanes (Supply Chain, Finance, Legal, Sales), each with its own leadership.

    Where Customs Usually Sits:

    • Under Supply Chain

    • Under Legal

    • Occasionally under a dedicated Trade Compliance function

      Upside:
      • Clear ownership

      • Defined reporting line

      • Often its own budget (if structured well)

        Downside:
        • Under Supply Chain → can become overly execution-focused (velocity & cost driven)

        • Under Legal → can become overly compliance-focused and disconnected from operations

        • If no independent budget → strategy becomes fragmented

          Key theme: Budget authority drives strategic control.

          2️⃣ Decentralized (Divisional) Structure

          Definition:

          Trade responsibilities are spread across business units, regions, or product lines.

          Each division may manage its own customs activity.

          Upside:
          • Faster decision-making

          • Direct access to business leaders

          • Local agility

            Downside:
            • Inconsistent processes across divisions

            • Requires corporate oversight or council to maintain standards

            • Heavy reliance on influence rather than authority

              This model works — but it requires strong coordination and governance discipline.

              3️⃣ Matrix (Hybrid) Structure

              Definition:

              Dual reporting lines — often operationally to Supply Chain, dotted line to Legal, Tax, or Finance.

              This is where many global organizations land.

              Reality of the Matrix:
              • Multiple “bosses”

              • Consensus-driven decisions

              • Speed vs. compliance tension

              • Performance reviews may not align with dotted-line accountability

                Success in a matrix requires:

                • Clear budget ownership

                • Clear escalation paths

                • Strong consensus-building skills

                • Mature leadership alignment

                  Without alignment, it becomes a tug-of-war between execution and governance.

                  Customs Operations vs. Customs Compliance

                  A critical distinction discussed in this episode:

                  Customs Operations:
                  • Entry filings

                  • ACE submissions

                  • Broker management

                  • Day-to-day problem solving

                    Customs Compliance:
                    • Classification governance

                    • Valuation methodology

                    • Origin policy

                    • Audit strategy

                    • Risk tolerance

                      Julie and Renee strongly advocate for structural separation of these roles — even in small teams.

                      Why?

                      Operations finds errors.

                      Compliance fixes root causes.
                      Both must cross-communicate consistently.

                      When they don’t align, friction, inefficiency, and risk increase.

                      Real-World Red Flags

                      Renee and Julie call out four common structural warning signs:

                      🚩 1. Customs buried too deep

                      Under logistics, contracts, or sales without escalation authority.

                      🚩 2. Broker “owns” compliance

                      Brokers file entries — they do not own your risk.

                      🚩 3. No executive sponsor

                      A sponsor is not a cheerleader — it’s a leader who clears roadblocks and escalates risk appropriately.

                      🚩 4. Customs is not the budget holder

                      If you don’t control funding, you don’t control strategy.

                      The Big Takeaway

                      There is no “perfect” structure.

                      Centralized, decentralized, and matrix models can all work.

                      But maturity shows up in:

                      • Clear decision rights

                      • Budget authority

                      • Executive sponsorship

                      • Alignment between operations and compliance

                        Structure doesn’t eliminate risk.

                        Misalignment creates it.

                        This Episode’s FIO (Figure It Out)

                        Take a hard look at your organization:

                        1. Which structure are you operating in — centralized, decentralized, or matrix?

                        2. What’s working well?

                        3. Where are the structural gaps?

                        4. Who holds the budget and escalation authority?

                          Because you can’t fix what you haven’t identified.

                          Future episodes in this series will focus on how to modernize or optimize each model — whether through small tweaks or major reorgs.

                          Join the Conversation

                          Where does Customs sit in your organization?

                          And more importantly — is it positioned for influence or just paperwork?

                          Let us know inside the Trade Geeks Community or connect with us on LinkedIn.

                          Credits

                          Hosts:

                          Renee Chiuchiarelli
                          Julie Parks

                          Producer:

                          Lalo Solorzano

                          🎧 Subscribe & Follow

                          New Simply Trade Tips episodes every Tuesday.

                          Presented by Global Training Center — providing education, consulting, and compliance resources for trade professionals worldwide.

                          Listen & subscribe:

                          • YouTube

                          • Spotify

                          • Apple Podcasts

                            ...more
                            View all episodesView all episodes
                            Download on the App Store

                            Simply TradeBy Global Training Center

                            • 4.6
                            • 4.6
                            • 4.6
                            • 4.6
                            • 4.6

                            4.6

                            22 ratings


                            More shows like Simply Trade

                            View all
                            Hidden Brain by Hidden Brain, Shankar Vedantam

                            Hidden Brain

                            43,687 Listeners

                            Motley Fool Money by The Motley Fool

                            Motley Fool Money

                            3,228 Listeners

                            WSJ What’s News by The Wall Street Journal

                            WSJ What’s News

                            4,420 Listeners

                            The Mindset Mentor by Rob Dial

                            The Mindset Mentor

                            13,600 Listeners

                            Global Trade This Week by CAP Logistics

                            Global Trade This Week

                            4 Listeners

                            The Daily by The New York Times

                            The Daily

                            113,121 Listeners

                            Up First from NPR by NPR

                            Up First from NPR

                            56,944 Listeners

                            The Trade Guys by CSIS  |  Center for Strategic and International Studies

                            The Trade Guys

                            152 Listeners

                            On Purpose with Jay Shetty by iHeartPodcasts

                            On Purpose with Jay Shetty

                            27,584 Listeners

                            Two Minutes in Trade by Sandler, Travis & Rosenberg, P.A.

                            Two Minutes in Trade

                            32 Listeners

                            Consider This from NPR by NPR

                            Consider This from NPR

                            6,462 Listeners

                            The Ezra Klein Show by New York Times Opinion

                            The Ezra Klein Show

                            16,525 Listeners

                            The Big Take by Bloomberg

                            The Big Take

                            155 Listeners

                            The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart by Comedy Central

                            The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart

                            11,013 Listeners

                            The Tucker Carlson Show by Tucker Carlson Network

                            The Tucker Carlson Show

                            16,982 Listeners