The 42FM

Why VAR has absolutely no place in the GAA


Listen Later

‘The whole conversation is stupendously ridiculous’ says Sinead, who fears for football and hurling should video review be introduced.

Sinead tells Niall that any embrace of technology beyond HawkEye and goal-line sensors would lead to decisions which are no less contentious, while making the overall player and fan experience ‘way less fun’.

It’s a rocky road, says Sinead, and we need only look to soccer and rugby for clear evidence that the quest for the perfect decision is futile and counterproductive.

Niall is not sure if this ‘stone age or nowhere’ policy is too vibes based, and wonders whether Sinead would be as ready to accept that sport and life are inherently unfair in the very moment when her favourite team has paid the ultimate price for a wrong call.

It is, Sinead concedes, hard to recall such a situation given Kildare’s lack of brushes with success in recent seasons. But in the event of such glory she would give it up for greater principles: perfection should be strived for with greater training and support for referees, but ultimately we have to accept their best-intentioned human failings.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The 42FMBy The 42

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

6 ratings


More shows like The 42FM

View all
The Second Captains Podcast by Second Captains

The Second Captains Podcast

174 Listeners

The Last Word with Matt Cooper by Today FM

The Last Word with Matt Cooper

55 Listeners

RTÉ Rugby Podcast by RTÉ Sport

RTÉ Rugby Podcast

19 Listeners

Inside Politics with Hugh Linehan by The Irish Times

Inside Politics with Hugh Linehan

141 Listeners

Indo GAA by Irish Independent

Indo GAA

38 Listeners

The Left Wing by Irish Independent

The Left Wing

58 Listeners

The Counter Ruck by The Irish Times

The Counter Ruck

19 Listeners

The 42 Rugby Weekly by The 42 Rugby Weekly

The 42 Rugby Weekly

30 Listeners

In The News by The Irish Times

In The News

54 Listeners

The Football Pod by OTB Sports

The Football Pod

19 Listeners

The GAA Social by BBC Radio Ulster

The GAA Social

78 Listeners

The Indo Daily by Irish Independent

The Indo Daily

114 Listeners

Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning by Gold Hat Productions

Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning

68 Listeners

Path to Power by Matt Cooper

Path to Power

27 Listeners

Indo Sport by Irish Independent

Indo Sport

59 Listeners