Bestselling author and Anglican priest, Tish Harrison Warren recently ignited a firestorm with a New York Times op-ed, arguing for a generous pluralism that would extend the same rights to Christians as those outside the church. In an article for World Magazine, Bethel McGrew offers a compelling alternative to this form of public Christian witness in the figure of Sean Sheehy, a retired Irish Catholic priest who boldly calls out homosexuality, transgenderism, and abortion as some of the main mortal sins of our age. Like Warren, he was raked over the coals, but his response was decidedly firmer and more robust: He remained steadfastly compassionate, while pushing against the lies of our culture. In this episode, we explore the changing dynamic of public Christian witness and consider how we move forward.