Wicked Deeds

We posted a couple days ago on social media about how both Jon and I are a bit under the weather right now, so we’ve got to delay this weeks scheduled episode covering Melissa Brannen’s Case until next Tuesday, March 28th, 2023. But today, we’re re-releasing an episode that is near and dear to our hearts. It’s a case we covered over a year ago, back when our format for this podcast was very different than it is today.

This is a story that’s continued to stick with us, in part due to our interview with Gerri, Theresa Corley’s sister, which provided us so much insight into not only Theresa’s case, but all the work Gerri continues to put in, trying to get justice for her sister nearly 45 years later. If you could please do us a huge favor and share this episode on your socials, that would be amazing. We want Theresa’s story to reach as many ears as possible. And please take a minute to follow the Facebook page that Gerri runs, which is dedicated to Theresa’s case; it’s called Justice for Theresa Corley Bellingham MA 1978. Gerri posts on there pretty regularly with updates.

In this episode, we will be covering the 1978 murder of Theresa Corley. While researching, we had the amazing opportunity to speak with Gerri, Theresa's sister, at length regarding her case. Theresa was 19 years old when she was found strangled to death along a Massachussetts highway. As we worked our way through the case, we learned of those most likely responsible, but also became aware of deep ties throughout the small town of Bellingham, that link many of the suspects together. As important as all of the cases we cover are, this one has become particularly meaningful to us, and we hope you take the time to listen.

Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.

Today, we’ll be discussing the case of a ten year old girl who was riding her bike around her neighborhood as she often did, but never came home. After several days of searching, her body was found and the hunt for her killer ensued. A suspect was named after a very short time but the details of the case just never seemed to match up to that suspect being involved. It’s been 33 years now and justice has yet to be served.

If you have any information regarding Rosie Gordon's case, please contact the Fairfax County Police Department at 703-246-7511 or you can provide an anonymous tip by calling the Fairfax County Crime Solvers at 1-866-411-8477.

Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.

Today, we’re going to be continuing our discussion regarding the disappearance of Craig Frear. We’ll be diving into the odd behaviors and red flags he’d been displaying prior to going missing, as well as the State Police’s investigation and all of the theories that surround this case.

If you have any information regarding what happened to Craig Frear or know where he might be, please contact the New York State Police at 518-630-1700 or the New York State Police Anonymous Tipline at 1-800-448-3847.


Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.

Today, we’ll be discussing the peculiar details surrounding the case of a high school junior gone missing. As we work through the particulars, we’ll have to discern whether someone with seemingly everything going for them, chose to run away, or if something more wicked may have taken place.

If you have any information regarding what happened to Craig Frear, or know where he might be, please contact the New York State Police at 518-630-1700 or the New York State Police Anonymous Tipline at 1-800-448-3847.

Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.

We told you we were taking this week off, and we are… but seeing as how we’ve gotten a lot of new listeners recently, and most of you probably haven’t had time to make your way through our back log, we’re going to try something new on our off weeks. Today we’re reuploading our episode covering Sheree Magaro's case.

Tomorrow, February 22, 2023, marks 36 years since her disappearance and presumed murder. For those of you that have already listened to this one, if you wouldn’t mind taking a minute to share the episode on your socials or drop a line to a friend, we’d really appreciate your help in getting Sheree’s case out there.

If you have any information regarding what happened to Sheree Magaro, please contact the Maryland State Police at 410-290-0050.

Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.

Today, we’ll be discussing the case of a seventeen year old girl who took a shortcut home one rainy night and was found murdered the following day. Over the years there hadn’t been much coverage of her case until those who’d suffered similar tragedies in the area, stepped in to assist. But even with that added assistance, and advancements in DNA technology, this case remains unsolved nearly 39 years later.

If you know anything about what happened to Patty Ann Gonyea, please contact the Worcester Police Detective Unit at 508-799-8651.

Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.

Today, we’re going to be doing something a little different… something in a similar vein to our Halloween special. We’re going to have a relatively off the cuff conversation about the Netflix documentary, “The Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker.” We’re looking to test out some varied content which we hope will keep things fresh for you, while also giving you more of our authentic selves. Don’t worry though, our coverage of unsolved cases won’t be going anywhere, that will always be our main form of content.

Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.

Today, we’ll be discussing the case of a mother of two who went missing under very suspicious circumstances. Sadly, for years, most of the information surrounding her disappearance never made headlines, until a bombshell was revealed five years after she vanished… but the details of what came out are probably not what you’d expect.

If you have any information regarding where Sandy Baker is or know where her remains are located, please contact the Pennsylvania State Police at 724-662-4200 or 724-662-6162.

Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.

Today we’ll be continuing our conversation around the William Sproat and Mary Petry murder investigation, and discussing, in more detail, what type of person authorities believed could have committed these murders. Now, in order to paint the picture detailing what investigators were working with at the time, we’ll also be going over some of the other crimes that had been taking place in the area around that time period. If you haven’t listened to part one yet, we suggest you check that out first so you’re all caught up.

If you have any informatio regarding who killed William Sproat and Mary Petry, please contact the Columbus Police Cold Case Unit at 614-645-4036.


Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.

Today, we’ll be discussing the case of two college-aged sweethearts, who, during a weekend they spent together at one of their respective schools, were brutally murdered. The details of the case are horrific, and trying to pin down who could have committed these heinous acts will have your head spinning.

If you have any informatio regarding who killed William Sproat and Mary Petry, please contact the Columbus Police Cold Case Unit at 614-645-4036.


Help support the show on Patreon

Follow us on on Instagram at wickeddeedspod

Like our Facebook Page, Wicked Deeds

Follow us on Twitter at WickedDeeds

Visit our website for a list of photos related to this case and our source material.