WTF Is That Podcast

💀 A Stay That Got… Uncomfortable 💀

This week on WTF Is That Podcast, we packed our bags, grabbed our EMF readers, and checked into the Groveland Hotel—because we were invited to stay overnight and investigate one of California’s most haunted hotspots. Very chill. Extremely normal behavior.

From Gold Rush–era tragedy to whispered hallways and lights that absolutely did not need to turn on by themselves, this place has STORIES. And maybe a personal issue with us being there.

👻 A historic hotel with a body count and bad vibes

🕯️ Guest rooms that refuse to stay quiet

🧳 Personal experiences we genuinely cannot explain (and yes, we tried)

⚠️ Quick heads-up: the audio isn’t perfect this week. The Groveland is pushing 200 years old, with thick walls, creaky floors, and acoustics from a time before microphones were a thing. We did our best—but the ghosts and the architecture were not sound engineers.

If you think haunted hotels are just creaky floors and overactive imaginations… this episode would like a word.

🎧 Go hit play now! And be honest—would you spend the night here? 👇

🔗 Listen here: https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast

Hosts: Jessica Mosely & Jenny Garcia

Producer: Jessica Mosely

💀 The Trial That Shook the Nation 💀

This week on WTF Is That Podcast, we’re diving into the Caylee Anthony case—one of the most infamous true crime stories of all time. From Caylee’s mysterious disappearance to Casey Anthony’s shocking trial and acquittal, this case had the world watching in disbelief.

🕵️‍♀️ A missing child with a bizarre timeline

🛑 The 911 call that started it all

⚖️ A courtroom battle that left the nation outraged

If you haven’t listened yet… why not?! This is true crime at its wildest, and you do NOT want to miss it.

🎧 Go hit play now! And tell us—do you think the jury got it right? 👇

🔗 Listen here: https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast

Hosts: Jessica Mosely & Jenny Garcia

Producer: Jessica Mosely

💀 The Wildest Post-Mortem Journey EVER 💀

This week on WTF Is That Podcast, we’re talking about Elmer McCurdy—the outlaw who was way more famous dead than alive. Seriously, this man went from failed train robber to carnival attraction, and his body was passed around for DECADES like some kind of creepy keepsake. 😳

🔪 A crime career that flopped HARD

🎭 A mummified corpse that became a sideshow act

🤯 The unreal way he was finally discovered

If you haven’t listened yet… why not?! This is prime WTF history, and you do not want to miss it.

🎧 Go hit play now, and tell us—what’s the wildest post-mortem story you’ve ever heard? 👇

🔗 Listen here: https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast

Hosts: Jessica Mosely & Jenny Garcia

Producer: Jessica Mosely

🎉 Surprise! We’ve got something special for you. 🎉

This week on WTF Is That Podcast, we’re bringing you an exclusive sneak peek of our brand-new show: So That’s How That Happened—where we spill the juiciest, most scandalous history tea. ☕🔥

Forget the dry history lessons—this is history with drama, gossip, and all the messy details they didn’t teach you in school.

💬 What you’ll hear in this preview:

👑 Power-hungry rulers, wild betrayals, and iconic feuds

💋 Scandals that rocked entire empires

😱 History’s biggest “WTF” moments that actually happened

The first two episodes of So That’s How That Happened drop TOMORROW, but we’re giving you an exclusive first listen. If you love a good drama-filled deep dive, you’re not gonna want to miss this!

🎧 Make sure to follow & subscribe so you don’t miss a single scandal. And let us know—what historical drama do you want us to cover next? 👇

🔗 Get all the links to our shows here: Linktree

Hosts: Jessica Mosely & Jenny Garcia

Producer: Jessica Mosely

This week, we’re covering the shocking case of Rodney Alcala, the charming yet deadly predator known as The Dating Game Killer. 🎭🔪

📺 In 1978, Alcala appeared on The Dating Game—a smiling, charismatic bachelor hiding a truly horrifying secret. Behind the camera? A trail of brutal crimes spanning decades.

Join us as we uncover:

🔥 How Alcala fooled everyone—including a national TV audience

🕵️‍♀️ The disturbing patterns behind his crimes

📸 The chilling photo collection that still haunts investigators

🚨 The bizarre moment his game show appearance helped expose him

With a body count that could be even higher than we know, this case is a terrifying look at how killers can hide in plain sight.

🎙️ Listen now wherever you get your podcasts, and head over to our Linktree to support the show and access exclusive content.

Hosts: Jessica Mosely & Jenny Garcia

Producer: Jessica Mosely

Episode 40: Brenda Ann Spencer – The Garfield Killer and the Tragic School Shooting

This week, we’re diving into the chilling story of Brenda Ann Spencer, the infamous “I hate Mondays” killer.

🏫💔Brenda’s deadly actions in 1979 shocked the nation, but what led this 16-year-old girl to commit such an unimaginable crime? Was it the influence of her troubled upbringing, or was there something more to her cold and calculated actions?

Join us as we explore:

🔪 The details of the 1979 San Diego school shooting

🧩 Brenda's chilling "I hate Mondays" confession

👀 The theories behind what drove a teenage girl to commit such violence

💬 The aftermath of the tragedy and its impact on school security

This episode gets deep into one of the most haunting and puzzling school shootings in history, with a killer who was as emotionless as her notorious catchphrase.

🎙️ Listen now wherever you get your podcasts, and head over to our Linktree at https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast to support the show and access exclusive content.

Hosts: Jessica Mosely and Jenny Garcia Producer: Jessica Mosely

Episode 39: The Villisca Axe Murders – Creepy Crimes and Small-Town Chills

This week, we’re taking you back to 1912 for one of America’s most infamous unsolved mysteries—the Villisca Axe Murders. Think quiet Midwestern town meets a nightmare straight out of a horror movie. 🔪😱

💀 A family of eight brutally murdered in their sleep.

🕵️‍♂️ A list of shady suspects longer than your favorite true crime binge.

🏚️ And yes, it’s now a hotspot for ghost hunters who probably enjoy sleeping with one eye open.

Join us as we uncover:

🔎 The twisted timeline of the crime and its bizarre aftermath

👀 The preacher suspect whose alibi was weaker than your Wi-Fi during a storm

🧟‍♀️ Why the Villisca house is still scaring people over 100 years later

Pack your flashlight, maybe some sage, and get ready to dive into this creepy true crime tale.

🎙️ Listen now wherever you get your podcasts, and don’t forget to check out our Linktree at https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast for ways to support the show and access exclusive content.

Hosts: Jessica Mosely and Jenny Garcia

Producer: Jessica Mosely

Episode 38: The Stanley Hotel – Spooks, Creeps, and the Sweetest Ghost Pup

This week, we're checking into the iconic Stanley Hotel, the haunted hotspot that inspired The Shining!

🏨 From spectral children giggling in the halls to ghostly piano serenades, this historic hotel is crawling with paranormal activity. But don’t worry—it’s not all scares. There’s also a ghost dog who might just melt your heart. 🐾👻

Join us as we uncover:

🔎 The haunted history of the Stanley Hotel

🎹 The mysterious sounds of Room 217 and the piano room

🐶 The story of Cassie, the hotel’s adorable ghostly canine

🕵️‍♀️ Why the Stanley remains a paranormal investigator’s dream destination

Pack your bags and bring your bravery—you’ll want to hear all about this spooky yet surprisingly sweet location.

🎙️ Listen now everywhere you get your podcasts, and don’t forget to check out our Linktree at https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast for ways to support the show and access exclusive content.

Hosts: Jessica Mosely and Jenny Garcia

Producer: Jessica Mosely

Episode 37: The Warrens – Paranormal Pioneers or Controversial Con Artists?

In this episode, we dive into the chilling world of Ed and Lorraine Warren, the infamous paranormal investigators behind some of history's most terrifying hauntings. From the Amityville Horror to the Annabelle doll, the Warrens' cases have become the stuff of legends—and blockbuster movies. But were they uncovering the supernatural or spinning tales for fame?

Join us as we explore:

👻 The origins of the Warrens’ paranormal investigations

🔮 Their most famous (and infamous) cases

🕵️‍♀️ The controversies surrounding their work

🎥 How Hollywood turned their stories into horror classics

Whether you’re a believer or a skeptic, this episode will have you questioning what’s lurking in the shadows.

💬 Have thoughts on Ed and Lorraine Warren? Share your opinions on our social media!

🎙️ Listen now everywhere you get your podcasts, and don’t forget to check out our Linktree at https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast for ways to support the show and access exclusive content.

Hosts: Jessica Mosely and Jenny Garcia

Producer: Jessica Mosely

Episode 37: Robert the Doll - Season Two Premiere

We’re baaaaack! Season Two of WTF is That Pod kicks off with a bang (or maybe a creepy giggle) as we tackle the infamous and highly cursed Robert the Doll.

This episode dives into the eerie history of the Key West legend who has been terrifying locals and visitors alike for over a century. We uncover the doll’s origins, from its mysterious arrival in the Otto household to the unsettling events that followed. Is Robert just an innocent plaything, or is he the vessel for something far more sinister?

And don’t worry—this episode is full of our usual banter and spooky fun. Plus, we made sure to be very polite to Robert… just in case.

We’re so excited to be back for another season of unraveling the weird, wild, and WTF stories that keep you coming back for more!

🎙️ Listen now everywhere you get your podcasts, and don’t forget to check out our Linktree at https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast for ways to support the show and access exclusive content.

Hosts: Jessica Mosely and Jenny Garcia

Producer: Jessica Mosely