Inner Life, Talks and Thoughts

0:00 / 19:22 What did Socrates teach? Or why you only understand Plato if he is decolonised


Listen Later

What Socrates taught is, of course, the wrong question. For, if there is one thing that Plato is quite clear about, it is that Socrates taught nothing. Something else is going on when you encounter this figure. So what is it?

In this talk I look first at common errors concerning Plato, such as that he pitched body against soul or thought poets were best banned. Other mistakes include treating his philosophy as a training in eudaimonia and reading his dialogues as stages in his philosophical development - the early ones being close to the historical Socrates, the middle ones being the mature Plato, the late ones being the disillusioned Plato. Similarly, Socrates did not seek definitions.

The irony, given the sensitivity to this charge often from philosophers who misread Plato, is that this is a colonial reading of Plato. Scholars like Julia Annas have shown that reading Plato changed during the period of the British empire, when texts like Plato’s Republic came to be treated as a manifesto for young minds in public schools being preparing to rule the world. 

Before that, Plato Plato was understood not to have a message but instead a path. Roughly speaking, the aporetic dialogues - the ones that end in radical uncertainty - offer a preparation in the form of an undoing. Then, next, into that space, the visionary dialogues speak. I'm indebted to the scholar Sara Ahbel-Rappe for so clearly stating that Socrates stands for a mode of being, thereby imparting a taste for it, stirring a love of it. 

Socrates can't give that presence, because it is already within you. This awareness actually already belongs to us, and we sense a distant yearning for it because of feeling separate from it, through ignorance or forgetting. The way back is to clear the space that makes us more ready to know it once more.

This is the meaning of the message Socrates received from the Delphic oracle: knowing yourself means knowing yourself, at base, to know nothing because all your theories or assumptions or certainties will turn out to be limited or straightforwardly wrong. Take that on board and then, regarding yourself as poor, come to know the richness of life, which is not eudaimonistic but rather theotic: a participation by contemplation, or theoria, in God.

That divine end, stressing the inadequacy of an isolated sense of our humanity, must be the fundamental reason why Plato is so widely dissed. He ready does offend, though in Socrates saw why that disquiet is so wonderfully worth undergoing.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Inner Life, Talks and ThoughtsBy Mark Vernon

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

12 ratings


More shows like Inner Life, Talks and Thoughts

View all
Start the Week by BBC Radio 4

Start the Week

162 Listeners

Philosophy Bites by Edmonds and Warburton

Philosophy Bites

1,532 Listeners

Nomad Podcast by Nomad

Nomad Podcast

424 Listeners

Ultraculture With Jason Louv by Jason Louv

Ultraculture With Jason Louv

385 Listeners

The Sacred by Theos

The Sacred

86 Listeners

Weird Studies by SpectreVision Radio

Weird Studies

586 Listeners

This Jungian Life Podcast by Joseph Lee, Deborah Stewart, Lisa Marchiano

This Jungian Life Podcast

1,563 Listeners

The Symbolic World by Jonathan Pageau

The Symbolic World

823 Listeners

Hermitix by Hermitix

Hermitix

342 Listeners

Rupert Spira Podcast by Rupert Spira

Rupert Spira Podcast

243 Listeners

Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal by Theories of Everything

Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal

470 Listeners

Decoding the Gurus by Christopher Kavanagh and Matthew Browne

Decoding the Gurus

944 Listeners

UnHerd with Freddie Sayers by UnHerd

UnHerd with Freddie Sayers

225 Listeners

Sounds of SAND by Science and Nonduality

Sounds of SAND

110 Listeners

History of Philosophy Audio Archive by William Engels

History of Philosophy Audio Archive

45 Listeners