We sit down with Nick, founder and head baker of Inside Out Cookie, to unpack the double meaning behind the name, what makes these big filled cookies different from anything you grab at the grocery store, and why in-person events and festivals became a turning point.

Nick walks us through flavor development and the realities of small-batch baking at scale, including why Dubai Chocolate became the breakout best seller, and how he keeps costs and quality in check by making pistachio cream from scratch. We also get nerdy about ingredients and freshness: from locally milled flour to packaging choices that make freezing cookies actually work. 

Then the conversation goes deeper. Nick shares how he learned to bake while incarcerated in a federal minimum-security prison, how purpose and community changed his trajectory, and why he’s committed to hiring and supporting others who are rebuilding their lives. 

Plus, we round out the Pittsburgh food talk with a Strip District Vietnamese recommendation for banh mi and pho at Maiku, and a quick, bold curry idea from Priya and Glen of Anar Gourmet Foods featuring eggplant, optional beef, and tangy tamarind.

Subscribe for more Pittsburgh food stories, share this with a friend who loves cookies, and leave a review to help more listeners find the show. What part of Nick’s story stuck with you most?

Support the show