Catholic Answers Live

#10859 Open Forum - Jimmy Akin


Listen Later

Questions Covered:
02:45 – I recently heard an answer you gave about giving false information to an automated machine and whether that was lying. You then made an offhanded point about it being ok to say false things to animals because you aren’t damaging their belief system. But Pavlovian conditioning trains an animal to connect 2 otherwise unrelated stimuli (in the original experiment the sound of a bell and being fed) and at some point, the idea is to give the one stimulus without the other. Can this be said to be forming a false belief in the animal and therefore essentially damaging their belief system. Is this kind of conditioning wrong? Is the conditioning itself wrong for establishing a false belief (that stimulus A and stimulus B are connected) OR would the subsequent use of stimulus A while intentionally withholding stimulus B be wrong? Does “damaging a belief system” require linguistic communication (either spoken or written word)? Does the apparent cognitive ability of the subject make a difference (say a mouse vs a dog)? Would it matter if the subject was human and would developmental stage matter (a baby, a toddler, an older child)? If it is lying, is it grave matter? Again, does the subject’s species or level of cognitive (or physical) development matter? 
11:54 – Why is the Didache not in the Bible? 
15:16 – Why isn’t 1 Clement in the Bible? It was in the Codex Alexandrinus and listed as canon in the Apostolic Constitutions. There’s also a theory (which I find a bit thin) that Clement wrote Hebrews. 
22:12 – What of discussing what are essentially the sins of youth in a humorous way? While one is telling tales of youth, not consciously thinking of the things as sin while recounting. Is this recounting a sinful in itself? It is, after all, making light of sin. 
32:07 – If time travel gets invented, and I travel to the day before my baptism, do I need to get baptized again? 
34:26 – Why doesn’t the Mass contain all of the Bible, even when adding together both daily and weekend cycles? Why are entire books left out (like Judith)? 
36:43 – Does the Eucharist in the Orthodox Church contain the Real Presence? And do we genuflect to show our belief and respect to Our Lord? 
39:25 – Is God bound by the priest’s prayers for transubstantiation? 
40: 14 – Why did the early church sometimes refer to the pope as a successor of Paul? 
42:41 – What would have happened to Mary if John had not taken her into his home when Jesus died?Or, if in that time period, where a widow had only one child and that child was crucified, would the widow’s family and village have taken care of her? Or would she have been basically exiled because her child was crucified? It’s something that has come to mind when meditating on the Crucifixion & I would love to know. 
44:43 – Did the writer of Genesis (in your opinion) mean for the creation account to be taken literally (as in creationism) or symbolically? and the reasons for it 
48:42 – Is Baptism of Desire, and Baptism of Blood more than a theological supposition (like Limbo)? 
51:12 – Which argument for God’s existence do you find most compelling? 
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Catholic Answers LiveBy Catholic Answers

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

2,139 ratings


More shows like Catholic Answers Live

View all
Catholic Stuff You Should Know by J. 10 Initiative

Catholic Stuff You Should Know

3,825 Listeners

Bishop Barron’s Sunday Sermons - Catholic Preaching and Homilies by Bishop Robert Barron

Bishop Barron’s Sunday Sermons - Catholic Preaching and Homilies

5,028 Listeners

The Word on Fire Show - Catholic Faith and Culture by Bishop Robert Barron

The Word on Fire Show - Catholic Faith and Culture

5,771 Listeners

The Thomistic Institute by The Thomistic Institute

The Thomistic Institute

805 Listeners

Catholic Answers Focus by Catholic Answers

Catholic Answers Focus

1,428 Listeners

Pints With Aquinas by Matt Fradd

Pints With Aquinas

6,798 Listeners

The Fr. Mike Schmitz Catholic Podcast by Ascension

The Fr. Mike Schmitz Catholic Podcast

7,750 Listeners

The Jeff Cavins Show (Your Catholic Bible Study Podcast) by Ascension

The Jeff Cavins Show (Your Catholic Bible Study Podcast)

2,204 Listeners

The Counsel of Trent by Catholic Answers

The Counsel of Trent

2,620 Listeners

Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World by Jimmy Akin

Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World

2,943 Listeners

The Catholic Talk Show by Ryan Scheel & Ryan DellaCrosse

The Catholic Talk Show

1,517 Listeners

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn by Scott Hahn

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn

43 Listeners

American Catholic History by Noelle & Tom Crowe

American Catholic History

914 Listeners

Godsplaining by Dominican Friars Province of St. Joseph

Godsplaining

1,281 Listeners

Catholic Saints by Augustine Institute

Catholic Saints

1,224 Listeners

Catholic Bible Study by Augustine Institute

Catholic Bible Study

792 Listeners