July 03, 2025

#128: How AI + Human Decision Making Beats AI Alone when Hiring with Scott Parish

29 minutes

Scott Parish is the founder and CEO of HireGuide. Before that, he helped build LinkedIn Jobs & ATS.

In this episode, Matt sits down with Scott to explore how AI is revolutionizing the hiring process. Scott introduces a game-changing concept: shifting focus from "quality of hire" to "quality of hiring decision" - and explains why this distinction could transform how organizations approach talent acquisition. From the staggering reality that 25% of managers regret their hiring decisions to how AI can capture 1000x more structured data than traditional methods, this conversation reveals practical strategies for making interviews faster, fairer, and twice as predictive. Scott also addresses the critical balance between leveraging AI's power while preserving the human connection that makes great hiring decisions possible.

From Our Sponsor

The Predictive Index (PI) is an award-winning talent optimization platform that aligns business strategy with people strategy for optimal business results. More than 60 years of proven science, software, and a curriculum of insightful management workshops make PI the solution for any company looking to design great teams and culture, make objective hiring decisions, foster engagement, and inspire greatness in their people anywhere in the world. More than 10,000 clients and 480+ partners use PI—including Nissan, Citizens Bank, Subway, Blue Cross Blue Shield, and Omni Hotels—across 90+ countries. Learn more at predictiveindex.com.

Key Takeaways

Shift Your Focus. Move from measuring "quality of hire" (which includes factors outside TA control like management and compensation) to "quality of hiring decision" (which focuses on process, content, and data quality that recruiters can actually control).

Human + AI Beats AI Alone. The most effective approach isn't replacing human decision-makers with AI, but using AI as a "copilot" - similar to how the best chess players with AI outperform AI alone.

AI Enables Hyper-Personalization. Modern AI can create truly customized interview content by incorporating company websites, job descriptions, and specific organizational values, moving beyond generic templates to genuinely tailored assessments.

Connect with Scott

Website: Hireguide.com
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/scottcparish/

...more

View all episodes

By Matt Poepsel, PhD

88 ratings