Plain Talk

197: Can North Dakota break the Apple/Google app store monpoly?


Listen Later

In the late 19th century hundreds of small, short-line railroads were being bought up and consolidated into larger companies. Our nation's burgeoning economy was (and still is, in many ways) dependent on those railroad lines which, increasingly, were under the control of a shrinking number of people.

Those people began using their monopoly over the transportation of goods to price gouge and manipulate markets.

"If we will not endure a king as a political power we should not endure a king over the production, transportation, and sale of any of the necessaries of life," Republican Senator John Sherman said at the time.

Sherman would ultimately give his name to the Sherman Antitrust Act, which continues to the basis of American antitrust law to this day.

The point is that corporate hegemonies should be allowed to suppress free trade. Some argue that's exactly what's happening in the enormous and growing market of app development.

That market is dominated by two companies. Apple, the manufacturer of iPhones, and Google, which operates the Android operating system used on phones from pretty much every single non-Apple manufacturer.

Companies that sell digital services through these apps - think a subscription to a fitness app, or an in-app purchase in a game like Candy Crush - have to use Apple and Google's payment services and they have to pay a 30 percent fee for the privilege.

"This is exactly the same thing" as the railroad monopolies of the 19th century says Lacee Anderson, spokesperson for the Coalition for App Fairness, said on this episode of Plain Talk.

It is in this context that North Dakota's lawmakers take up Senate Bill 2333, which was introduced by Republican Senator Kyle Davison of Fargo.

Mark Buse, who is a vice president for dating service Match.com, says his company supports the legislation. "The issue is that all app developers should be treated the same."

Anderson suggested that Apple and Google have used their control of the app markets to drive out competitors for their own services. She also noted the recent controversies over the tech industry censoring political content as an argument in favor of breaking up these company's controls over apps.

No other state has this sort of law in place, though others are considering it. Why should North Dakota lead the charge? It could encourage app developers to locate here in order to avoid Apple and Google's fees.

Could Apple and Google cut North Dakotans off from their stores if this legislation passes? After all, our state is but a fraction of the markets those tech giants serve.

Anderson says that would be an extreme and unlikely outcome.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Plain TalkBy Forum Communications Co.

  • 3.8
  • 3.8
  • 3.8
  • 3.8
  • 3.8

3.8

81 ratings


More shows like Plain Talk

View all
Fantasy Focus Football by ESPN, Field Yates, Stephania Bell, Mike Clay, Daniel Dopp

Fantasy Focus Football

13,562 Listeners

Purple Daily - A Minnesota Vikings Podcast by SKOR North | Hubbard Radio

Purple Daily - A Minnesota Vikings Podcast

1,435 Listeners

Bison Media Zone by Forum Communications Co.

Bison Media Zone

19 Listeners

News & Views with Joel Heitkamp by MWC

News & Views with Joel Heitkamp

39 Listeners

Dizzo's Den by Forum Communications Co.

Dizzo's Den

8 Listeners

Afternoons Live with Tyler Axness by MWC

Afternoons Live with Tyler Axness

8 Listeners

Dakota Spotlight: True Crime & Cold Case Investigations by True Story Media

Dakota Spotlight: True Crime & Cold Case Investigations

906 Listeners

Kolpack and Izzo Podcast by Forum Communications Co.

Kolpack and Izzo Podcast

24 Listeners

Agweek Podcast by Forum Communications Co.

Agweek Podcast

8 Listeners

Purple Insider - a Minnesota Vikings and NFL podcast by Matthew Coller, Bleav

Purple Insider - a Minnesota Vikings and NFL podcast

938 Listeners

Huskies Hockey Insider by Forum Communications Co.

Huskies Hockey Insider

1 Listeners

Midwest Murder by Jonah Lantto & Dawn Palumbo with the Good Talk Network

Midwest Murder

900 Listeners

The Daily Punch by Punchbowl News

The Daily Punch

716 Listeners

#SistersInLaw by Politicon

#SistersInLaw

10,531 Listeners

Post Bulletin Minute by Forum Communications Co.

Post Bulletin Minute

4 Listeners

Grand Forks Herald Minute by Forum Communications Co.

Grand Forks Herald Minute

5 Listeners

Health Fusion by Forum Communications Co.

Health Fusion

3 Listeners

The Vault by Forum Communications Co.

The Vault

78 Listeners

Brainerd Dispatch Minute by Forum Communications Co.

Brainerd Dispatch Minute

5 Listeners

WDAY Sports Minute by Forum Communications Co.

WDAY Sports Minute

1 Listeners

Mitchell Republic Minute by Forum Communications Co.

Mitchell Republic Minute

1 Listeners

The President's Daily Brief by The First TV

The President's Daily Brief

3,348 Listeners

The Chris Cuomo Project by Chris Cuomo

The Chris Cuomo Project

3,515 Listeners

Growing Together: A Gardening Podcast by Forum Communications Co.

Growing Together: A Gardening Podcast

2 Listeners

George Conway Explains It All (To Sarah Longwell) by The Bulwark

George Conway Explains It All (To Sarah Longwell)

3,512 Listeners

Capitol Punishment by MWC

Capitol Punishment

36 Listeners

Archive Dive with the Superior Telegram by Forum Communications Co.

Archive Dive with the Superior Telegram

7 Listeners

Matters of Soul Importance with Roxane Salonen by Roxane Salonen

Matters of Soul Importance with Roxane Salonen

9 Listeners

Northland Outdoors by Forum Communications Co.

Northland Outdoors

4 Listeners

She Overcomes: Becoming BOLD with Melanie Rudd by Melanie Iverson Rudd

She Overcomes: Becoming BOLD with Melanie Rudd

6 Listeners

Echo Press Minute by Forum Communications Co.

Echo Press Minute

0 Listeners

The Health Variant by Forum Communications Co.

The Health Variant

6 Listeners

The Other Side of the Table by Forum Communications Co

The Other Side of the Table

7 Listeners

Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov by Vox Media Podcast Network

Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov

1,344 Listeners