This one's a competition, folks! Mae presents a list of urban legends pulled off the internet and Max and Ben guess whether they're fake or still kind of not real but based on some truth. Cursed parks, secret experiments, widowed witches - there's a little bit of everything in here. The fam tells tall tales from around town.

He's been missing for over a month, the whole world's looking for him, and there are updates every hour on the hour. The search for him inside of a massive Florida nature reserve, however, is like looking for a needle in a haystack it might not even be in. Laundrie remains the only person of interest in the case of girlfriend Gabby Petito's murder. 

In 1982, someone put cyanide into Tylenol capsules throughout the Chicago area forever changing the way we consume over the counter medicine. Who did it? 40 years later and it's still unknown. The fam pops into this painful mystery. 

In celebration of Mae picking a wedding venue, we're covering the mysterious and tragic death of a Canadian newlywed in 1947. What happens when a couple brings their "best friend" on the honeymoon? Arson, drownings, affairs and everything in between. The fam gets hitched to an infamous bridal mystery. 

Possibly the biggest existential question of all time and science is split down the middle. Is this the base reality or are we just next gen Sims? The fam goes deep into the matrix. 

In this bonus episode, Mark Normand joins the pod to discuss an unsolved mystery from his past. His trailblazing drag queen superhero of a nanny was murdered without a trace. He and his parents help the team piece together what could have happened to him. 

In the first widely reported alien abduction, Barney and Betty Hill claimed to have been snatched up by a UFO in September, 1961. Their story shaped just about every extraterrestrial cliche in the books - flying saucer, little grey men, and of course, probing. But did it actually happen? The fam beams up into the og E.T. 

In one of the most infamous mysterious deaths of all time, college student Elisa Lam disappeared in her hotel. Only that hotel was basically cursed. And then she was found somewhere she almost certainly couldn't have gotten into alone. The fam checks into the ill fated Cecil Hotel.

They are both legendary heavyweights in the monster arena. But of the two, which one is more likely to actually exist? The fam breaks down stories from history, actual scientific studies, and modern day interviews with "real" vamps. 

A ship with no one aboard. Navigational equipment missing but food fully stocked. An entire family and crew never to be heard from again. The fam sets sail to find out what exactly happened to the famous Mary Celeste brigantine.