La La Land's most gruesome murder. A young woman is found cut in half on the side of the road and the media has an absolute field day with it. The fam susses out what's fact and fiction when it comes to the infamous, unsolved case of Elizabeth Short's murder. 

Carly Simon released a number 1 hit single that has plagued listeners since 1972. Who is so vain that they could elicit such a classic, scathing song? Rockstars, Hollywood Elite and even one of our hosts joins the list of suspects. The fam dances to a musical mystery. 

This one's a hometown mystery for Mae Elaine. Authorities found a disembodied torso in Sandwich, MA and then a similar case happened again decades later one town over. Neither victim could ever be identified but there's a good chance Whitey Bulger was involved. The fam loses their heads on this chilling case. 

Did Jesus come to Earth in a spaceship? Were alien astronauts roaming around ancient Italy? Was 1803 Japan the landing spot for an otherworldly woman? That's what these masterpieces throughout history would have you believe! The fam explores the final creative frontier in this artsy mystery. 

This is a dark one, folks. So we drank a lot of wine and talked about witches a whole bunch. Did witches do this? The government and a NJ based sci-fi magazine certainly don't want you to think so. The fam gets bewitched by this murder mystery. 

A serial killer who loves jazz and targets Italian grocers in New Orleans sounds like a game of extreme Mad Libs. But. It's real. And it happened during the last pandemic in 1918. The fam gets infected by this century old mystery. 

Possibly the most famous serial killer of all time and we taunt him relentlessly. Do we crack the case? No. But did we have fun? Probably too much. The fam decodes the zodiac in this one. 

This time it really was aliens! Or at least that's what former Area 51-adjacent engineer, Bob Lazar, has to say. He claims to have done experiments on UFOs in the 80s, a time known for being reasonable and not at all over the top. The fam rockets into this extraterrestrial mystery. 

The swinging 60's in Great Britain who wouldn't want to be a part of it? Most people actually. But especially the Gibbons twins who for decades refused to speak to anyone else even though they each believed the other was a demonic threat. 

The early 2000's were a weird time for everyone but especially this pacific northwestern family and their friends that received near-constant harassment via flip phone. Only problem is the calls came from their own phones even when they were off. Big Scream vibes on this one, fam.