What happens when your dream home becomes a nightmare? The Broaddus learned the hard way in 2014 when their New Jersey abode came with increasingly creepy letters from a stalker known only as "The Watcher". The experience was so intrusive and chilling that they never even fully moved into the house. Was The Watcher a local prankster, a ghoulish remnant of residents' past or something even more sinister? The fam moves in next door to this suburban mystery. 

Vincent van Gogh is known the world over as the quintessential tortured artist. An extraordinarily talented man whose frequents bouts with mental illness drove him to take his own life. Or so the story goes. The fam paints the picture behind the prominent belief that there was foul play involved in the death of Van Gogh. 

Who was history's most famous serial killer? 19th Century police officers had it narrowed down to just about every single person in England. We discuss some the of the more intriguing suspects and end up with exactly zero answers. 

The closest thing America has to a royal family and of course they're cursed. For over a century this clan has had mysterious death after death with no common thread other than their last name. From lesser known lobotomies to the infamous JFK assassination, there have been many a frightful fate for the Kennedys. The fam goes deep into this ancestral mystery. 

A highly advanced society made up of tall, beautiful people that became so morally bankrupt the gods sunk the whole place. Or so the tale goes. Underwater utopia or Plato's imagination run amok? The fam goes deep into the depths of this aquatic mystery. 

Legendary pilot Amelia Earhart vanished during a fateful and daring flight around the globe in June 1937. The whole world was watching and yet nothing conclusive has ever been found. She was a pioneer, author and possibly a government agent? The fam buckles in for America's most famous disappearance. 

Little kids are scary enough but add in the possibility that their older siblings were reincarnated in them? Yikes. A pair of twins seemingly remembers minute details of past lives just as their father predicted. The fam weighs in on what happens after we die.

Fan request! This case has everything: an unidentified body, a beachfront Australian backdrop, spy drama, and worldwide attention. Every clue makes you ask 10 more questions. The fam heads down under for this classic Aussie mystery. 

The United States' Apollo 11 was the first crewed mission to land on the Moon, on July 20th, 1969. Or was it? I mean it definitely was but why do so many people think it's a mystery? The fam rockets into this spacey mystery. 

In 2004, an all-american girl and star athlete disappears on the road to NH without a trace. Every time you tug a little thread you end up with a whole new sweater. Why was this college student seemingly on the run? Did she meet with someone? Who hasn't stolen a credit card? The fam vanishes into this famous mystery.