
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Nothing brings the world together like analyzing famous people's terrible decisions. Add in a dash of Halloween and some pop culture references from hell, and ooo baby you've got yourself a problematic stew. What were these celebrities thinking when they chose their costumes? How did no one in their lives maybe raise a lil flag? Is this how society ends, because of a sexy lion? Tune in and find out if We Were Had!
Please support the show and our hosts!
We Were Had Podcast
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
The big question of this episode is are we doing Son of Sam? And that does get settled. But also, did serial killer David Berkowitz work alone during his murder spree? Using a .44 Special caliber Bulldog revolver, he killed six people and wounded seven others by July 1977, terrorizing New Yorkers and gaining worldwide notoriety. Berkowitz eluded the biggest police manhunt in the city's history while leaving letters that mocked the police and promised further crimes, which were highly publicized by the press. He confessed to all of them, and initially claimed to have been obeying the orders of a demon manifested in the form of a dog belonging to his neighbor "Sam". Was a satanic cult involved? Are they still around? Why didn't the police investigate the neighbors? Tune in and find out if We Were Had!
Please support the show and our hosts!
We Were Had Podcast
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
From Twitter memes to parental warnings, we're frequently reminded that there might be something murderous in our chocolate bars. And certainly do not take a loose apple from someone on all hallow's eve because that is chock full of razor blades. But why do people think Halloween candy might be poisoned? Much of the urban legends can be tied back to this horrific murder case from 1974. Tune in to hear how society was had.
We Were Had is a podcast of Murder, Mystery, and the Unnatural! Your hosts, Comedians Mae Planert, Max Spinelli, and Ben Kirschenbaum dive in each week to bring you the facts.
Please support the show and our hosts!
We Were Had Podcast
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
Let's take a trip to what some consider the evilest place on earth, Dudleytown, CT. This small abandoned village nestled between mountains is creepy and off putting even before you learn about all the cursed stuff that happened there. Legend says that an ancestral Dudley made a shady play for the throne of England in the 16th century and everything went downhill from there. It would appear the curse that was put upon the Dudley family followed them to the New World, because Dudleytown was beleaguered by accidental deaths, insanity, demonic activity and more before being completely deserted. Was the curse real, could it have been an extremely unfortunate string of bad luck, or was Dudleytown merely resting on a nexus of evil? Tune in and find out if We Were Had! We Were Had is a podcast of Murder, Mystery, and the Unnatural!
Your hosts, Comedians Mae Planert, Max Spinelli, and Ben Kirschenbaum dive in each week to bring you the facts.
Please support the show and our hosts!
We Were Had Podcast
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
This week on the pod, Ben's got five creepy lil cryptids just in time to kick off spooky szn in NYC. These monsters come from all over the world with origins as diverse as they are unbelievable. We've got an evil Native spirit known as a Wendigo (shout out Supernatural), the Chinese Big Foot known as Yeren, a carnivorous South American tree called the Ya-Te-Veo, an adorable winged German bunny called a Wolpertinger, and of course the classic lil Mexican bloodsucker, the Chupacabra. Are they real? Tune in and find out if We Were Had!
We Were Had is a podcast of Murder, Mystery, and the Unnatural! Your hosts, Comedians Mae Planert, Max Spinelli, and Ben Kirschenbaum dive in each week to bring you the facts.
Please support the show and our hosts!
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
Terri Lee Hoffman was an American religious cult leader known for the unexplained deaths of some of her followers, including two husbands, shortly after they had willed their possessions to her. The devotees in her Dallas-based new religious movement, Conscious Development of Body, Mind and Soul, fought against the "black lords" on various planes of existence and protected themselves with powerful gems. Her rise to power was defined by a bunch of tall tales like her claims to possess literal superpowers without backing any of it up. Eventually, the feds got her on the old Al Capone charge. Were her followers just really unlucky after they took out life insurance policies naming her as the beneficiary? Tune in and find out if We Were Had!
We Were Had is a podcast of Murder, Mystery, and the Unnatural! Your hosts, Comedians Mae Planert, Max Spinelli, and Ben Kirschenbaum dive in each week to bring you the facts.
Please support the show and our hosts!
We Were Had Podcast
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
We're entering Clifton, New Jersey's infamous Gates of Hell and telling the tale. For real though, Producer Crazy Chris Metcalfe actually did go in but turned around and left almost immediately. The longtime urban legend posits that these now abandoned sewage tunnels are actually a pathway to hell itself. Nine layers of dark, ominous caverns have been home to all sorts of satanic rituals, ominous graffiti and countless stories to keep you up at night. Can you actually talk to satan himself in this quiet NJ town? Tune in and find out if We Were Had! Also, shoutout Weird NJ for making it back on the pod!
We Were Had is a podcast of Murder, Mystery, and the Unnatural! Your hosts, Comedians Mae Planert, Max Spinelli, and Ben Kirschenbaum dive in each week to bring you the facts.
Please support the show and our hosts!
We Were Had Podcast
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
You'd think being $2 billion over budget would be the most controversial bullet point in the story of a travel hub and yet the Denver International Airport has been plagued by conspiracy theories since its conception. Stories of hidden messages from the illuminati, underground tunnels & doomsday bunkers beneath the sprawling structure, and even apocalyptic predictions have followed DEN for years. The giant blue demon horse out front doesn't exactly help. The fact that they heavily wink at these stories makes one wonder, was all this creepy stuff part of a marketing ploy or is a sinister force hiding in plane sight? Tune in and find out if We Were Had!
We Were Had is a podcast of Murder, Mystery, and the Unnatural! Your hosts, Comedians Mae Planert, Max Spinelli, and Ben Kirschenbaum dive in each week to bring you the facts.
Please support the show and our hosts!
We Were Had Podcast
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
It's the question on everyone's mind: is Glee star Lea Michele illiterate? This is an actual conspiracy theory that's gained so much traction she's actually addressed it. Can she read? Has she just memorized a bunch of words? Is there a difference? Tune in and find out if We Were Had! We Were Had is a podcast of Murder, Mystery, and the Unnatural! Your hosts, Comedians Mae Planert, Max Spinelli, and Ben Kirschenbaum dive in each week to bring you the facts.
Please support the show and our hosts!
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
The Guidestones have been the subject of controversy since their erection in 1979 by an anonymous individual known only as R.C. Christian. Known to some as the American Stonehenge because of their striking resemblance to England’s famous monument, the Georgia Guidestones were a granite monument that served as a celestial clock of sorts, recording the passage of time through special features. Mysterious inscriptions on the monument seemed to speak to the conservation of humanity, but their exact intent was unclear. In July 2022, unknown assailants blew the thing up, which probably had something to do with congresspeople referring to it as The Ten Commandments of the Antichrist. Was it a helpful, innocent map for a bright future or did the mysterious benefactors have something more sinister in mind? Tune in and find out if We Were Had!
We Were Had is a podcast of Murder, Mystery, and the Unnatural! Your hosts, Comedians Mae Planert, Max Spinelli, and Ben Kirschenbaum dive in each week to bring you the facts.
Please support the show and our hosts!
We Were Had Podcast
Mae Planert
Max Spinelli
Ben Kirschenbaum
From the publisher's feed