Art Criticism, Political Engagement, and the Role of Discontent with Elwyn Palmerton

In this incisive and far-ranging episode of What’s My Thesis?, host Javier Proenza welcomes artist and writer Elwyn Palmerton for a wide-reaching dialogue that explores the intersections of contemporary art, cultural criticism, and local political activism. From Palmerton’s formative years navigating the vibrant New York art scene of the late 1990s to his incisive voice as an art    critic today, the conversation offers a candid and layered portrait of an individual devoted to truth-telling in an increasingly performative cultural landscape.

Key Themes:

The Making of a Critic: Palmerton recounts his early exposure to the New York gallery circuit while attending NYU, and the pivotal role that grad school writing assignments—especially on the Whitney Biennial—played in forging his critical voice.

Criticism as Craft and Confrontation: Informed by his deep engagement with art history and frequent gallery visits, Palmerton discusses the value of clear, form-driven analysis versus vague, concept-heavy narratives. He challenges the art world’s aversion to negativity and praises figures like Sean Tatol for maintaining intellectual rigor in the space.

Art and the Sociopolitical Landscape: The episode delves into Palmerton’s campaign work for progressive city council candidates in Los Angeles, the structural power of real estate and police unions, and the possibilities of social housing as a viable alternative to market-driven development. His experience canvassing neighborhoods offers a grassroots lens into civic life often overlooked in mainstream coverage.

Digital Disillusionment: The conversation expands into algorithmic culture, censorship, and the numbing effects of digital discourse. Both host and guest reflect on how platforms skew public perception and dilute the impact of genuine political or artistic critique.

The Importance of Historical Consciousness: Palmerton advocates for more historically-informed criticism, citing influences ranging from Adam Curtis documentaries to post-1945 American painting as essential in contextualizing today’s cultural output.

Quotes to Remember:

“Criticism is about unpacking the experience—describing the thing that moved you, and understanding why.”

“Social media teaches us to perform like, not think critically. But criticism is how we grow.”

Where to Follow Elwyn Palmerton:

About the Podcast: