February 04, 2026

478: Beyond Requirements: Why Every Coach Needs Mentoring with Carly Anderson, MCC

51 minutes

Mentoring is a topic many coaches misunderstand, as they approach it reluctantly as another requirement in their credentialing process. In truth, mentoring is an opportunity, a gift, and a chance to sharpen our skills, break free from old habits, and continue our evolution as coaches. Mentoring is a valuable, transformational process that helps us identify our blind spots and expand our capacity. In this episode, you’ll hear insights about coaching presence in the mentoring process, along with how to approach your coaching growth with humility and curiosity. Join us to learn more!

Carly Anderson is a Master Certified Coach who has been continuously active as an ICF assessor for MCC, PCC, and ACC since 2005. She has carried this heavy load as an assessor, giving back to our profession and helping numerous coaches advance in the field. She has personally mentored over 200 coaches who have earned their MCC credential.

Show Highlights:

Carly’s perspective on 20 years as an ICF assessor, which she calls “the greatest joy of my life.”
The value of mentor coaching
Key takeaways from Carly’s mentor coaching role
Being present in mentoring without judgment
Using “practices” to stay focused in mentoring: something tactile to hold, breathing exercises, hot yoga, chiropractic, massage, etc.
The benefits of both group and individual mentoring
Differences between mentor coaching and supervised coaching
Helping coaches develop their own style
The value of listening to your own coaching recordings to help you be the best you can be
Carly’s tips for getting the most out of your recordings and using reflection without judgment
The #1 takeaway from today’s episode for being the most present as a mentor coach

Resources:

Connect with Carly Anderson: Website

Connect with Meg

Get Meg’s FREE download, Finding Your Perfect Match: A Coach's Self-Reflection Guide.

Explore the STaR Coach Show Mentor Program. New dates have been added for 2026!

Explore past episodes and other resources at www.STaRcoachshow.com.

Explore the STaR Coach Community and see what’s available there for you!

Visit the STaR Coach Show YouTube Channel! Subscribe today! Join our live show taping on the 3rd Thursday of every month at 1 pm CT.

Mentioned in this episode:

Join Mentoring Program!

If you’re a coach who wants to grow—not just check a box—this is for you.

I’m enrolling coaches now for my Spring Mentoring Program. Some are here for credentialing hours. Others are here because they want to become the coach their clients rave about.

Inside the program, we work on your actual coaching.

You’ll hear yourself differently.

Learn from other coaches.

Develop more presence.

And ask questions that create real transformation.

If you’re ready to deepen your skills and your impact, I’d love to support you.

Learn more at starcoachshow.com/mentor

I’d love to work with you.

Enroll More Clients: Clarity Sprint

Do you love coaching, but when it comes to enrolling clients, writing your bio, or posting online, you freeze? Or fall into “coach speak” that doesn’t actually connect?

That’s not a you problem. It’s a messaging problem—and it’s costing you clients.

Join me for my free, live five-day experience: Enroll More Clients: Clarity Sprint. From March 16–20 at 9 a.m. Central, I’ll help you get crystal clear on your ideal client, refine your message so it actually resonates, and create a confidence statement that makes booking a call the obvious next step.

No fluff, just clarity, you can use immediately.

Grab your free spot at:

https://starcoachshow.com/5day

Enroll More Clients: Clarity Sprint

...more

View all episodes

By Meg Rentschler

132132 ratings