In Episode 433 of Airey Bros Radio, we go belly-to-belly with Nate Shearer, Head Wrestling Coach at Washington & Lee University, for a deep dive into what it really takes to build a championship-level Division III wrestling program while maintaining elite academic standards.Coach Shearer breaks down his 13-year journey leading the Generals, how W&L climbed from small rosters and forfeits to becoming a conference champion and national contender, and why the ODAC’s growth has made D3 wrestling in Virginia more competitive (and more fun) than ever.We also get into high-academic recruiting realities (early decision, fit-first recruiting, national pipeline), what W&L students actually study (business, engineering, health professions, CS), the culture shift that keeps athletes thriving, and the behind-the-scenes “CEO” side of running a program—travel, film, training, community, and consistency.Plus: Springsteen, the Stone Pony, coffee setups, saunas, vinyl, and the most dangerous guilty pleasure in America: ice cream.Follow Washington & Lee Wrestling:
- Website: generalsports.com
- Social: @generalswrestle (Instagram/X)
Support Airey Bros Radio (Value for Value):
BuyMeACoffee.com/aireybros
Timestamp / Show Notes
0:00 ABR mission: shining light on JUCO/NAIA/D2/D3 opportunities + recruiting conversations we wish we had
1:29 Intro: Nate Shearer, Head Coach at Washington & Lee Wrestling (Year 13)
3:16 2025–26 snapshot: season context + ODAC dual stretch ahead
3:52 Where recruits/parents should go: generalsports.com + @generalswrestle
4:18 Through-line: ODAC talk + shoutout to Coach Nate Yetzer (Roanoke)
5:05 Virginia D3 wrestling growth: from “only program” to a full conference
6:43 Has ODAC expansion changed recruiting? Why it’s helped, not hurt
8:32 Origin story: “I didn’t want to wrestle” — thrown into a tournament with zero prep
10:08 Mark Coleman connection + early chaos of learning wrestling the hard way
12:58 When coaching became the path: Ohio Northern → mentorship → wrestling finally becomes “fun”
16:09 First coaching years: volunteering, teaching, GA role, building a youth club from scratch
19:09 Coaching philosophy: building athletes up, not tearing them down
23:54 Year 1 vs Year 13 at W&L: tiny roster, forfeits, growing in “small chunks”
24:58 Turning point: first national qualifier (2016) + expectations shift
25:27 Admissions reality: low acceptance rate + recruiting the right academic fit
26:37 Culture + community: families/alumni, packed home invite, “it’s not hard to be here”
29:19 High-academic recruiting pace: Early Decision deadline + why the “funnel” moves fast
31:25 Best wrestling state debate: NJ guys pounding the drum… but the data loves Connecticut
33:24 What majors recruits choose: business, health professions, engineering, CS + sciences
35:29 Facilities + Lexington vibe + being next door to VMI (two closest wrestling campuses)
37:17 2025–26 season report: best rankings in program history, injuries, staying steady
39:29 Date to circle: Friday, Feb 6 @ Roanoke (potentially stacked ranked lineup)
40:22 Brisket at matches? Not yet—“need a clone” (but recruiting camp meals are real)
41:15 Historic flex: 1936 wrestling championships hosted at W&L + gym built in the early 1900s
44:06 “Head coach as CEO”: what he actually manages (training, travel, film, recruiting)
45:04 Resources matter: why W&L is positioned differently (support systems, fewer corners cut)
48:33 Department success + top programs across campus + the “full package” student-athlete experience
52:03 Coffee talk: Americano life, pour over hacks, road-map coffee shout
54:32 Daily ritual: basement sauna + outdoor shower (recovery > cold tubs)
56:45 What he’s listening to: Steven Wilson Jr. + vinyl collecting
58:01 Flea market circuit upbringing: baseball cards, memorabilia, Ohio hustle
1:00:36 Cleveland baseball + Major League quotes + stadium nostalgia
1:01:14 Prize vinyl: Springsteen — Nebraska
1:03:13 Airey Bros Stone Pony classics: Warped Tour, Deftones, Pennywise, Sublime, Blink, 311
1:05:16 Springsteen deep cut: “Atlantic City” + NJ States mindset story
1:07:46 Guilty pleasure: ice cream (Reese’s/peanut butter + Butterfinger ice cream bars)
1:09:33 Wrap-up + where to follow W&L + what’s next on ABR