Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes Present

Regina Rowe-Hicks’ was discovered inside of her submerged car under suspicious circumstances back in 2001. But, with no DNA evidence and no witnesses, the case went cold for over 20 years…

It was only when her husband, Paul, was charged with arson years later and a determined podcaster did more digging into Regina’s death that things started to line up.

What made Paul’s arson charge the most bizarre thing Emily has ever witnessed?! How did police finally connect the dots to make an arrest for the murder? What does Paul and Regina’s son have to say about this crime? 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Denise Huskins was abducted in the middle of the night from her boyfriend’s house. The police first believed her boyfriend murdered her then when they received a voice recording of Denise alive they were convinced she was copying the movie “Gone Girl”. In a bizarre twist Denise was released 48 hours later and upon her return she realized that the police and media didn’t believe she was actually abducted and were not actually looking for her captor. 

Denise Huskins joins Jenn to talk about her horrifying experience and what she endured trying to convince the world that she was indeed kidnapped. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

70-year-old former revered spiritual leader Daniel Savala pleaded guilty Thursday for a “pattern of sexual exploitation involving multiple victims over time.” A number of his victims crowded the courtroom yesterday to give victim impact statements. Savala is accused of grooming and abusing boys and young men beginning in the 1990s, using scripture to convince his victims to undress, saying “nudity is unity.” What’s even more disturbing about this story, church pastors continued to send children to Savala’s home for guidance even after he was convicted for child sex abuse in 2012.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

There is no known motive for why 52-year-old married father of two, Matthew Mitchell, would shoot and kill his wife and children this week, and then turn the gun on himself. The Mitchells were prominent Houston restaurateurs who spent the last several years building their business, appearing in magazines and on local tv together. Just 10 days before her death, Thy Mitchell posted a now eerie video with her husband, smiling and joking about growing old together. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Nearly 7 years after Jeffrey Epstein’s death, a federal judge has just released a purported suicide note written by Epstein. The New York Times filed a request for the note after hearing Epstein’s former cellmate describe its existence and reading veiled references to it in the DOJ’s released Epstein files.  The DOJ claimed it didn’t even know the note existed until now.  

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

53-year-old special forces sergeant Craig Berry is on the run in Tennessee and considered armed and dangerous. Berry is accused of beating, strangling and shooting his wife last week before taking off into a vastly wooded area armed with extra ammunition.  Berry’s wife survived and now authorities are warning the community to lock their doors and stay vigilant as Berry is trained to survive in difficult terrain, but may grow desperate to avoid capture.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

FBI Director Kash Patel is accusing the Pima County Sheriff’s Department of mishandling the Nancy Guthrie investigation. Patel maintains the FBI was shut out of the first four days of the investigation despite the fact it sent hundreds of agents to the area, and offered to analyze DNA evidence at their labs in Quantico. Sheriff Chris Nanos disputed Patel’s claims in a statement, saying his department began working with the FBI without delay. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Olympic dressage competitor Michael Barisone shot his student, Lauren Kanarek, in 2019 after a year of tension and alleged harassment. Though Lauren was the victim, do Emily and Shane believe she’s entirely innocent? 

Was Michael’s “temporary insanity” case valid, considering he still looked mentally unstable two years after the shooting?! 

Plus, what did they think about the Netflix documentary on this case? Do others agree that Lauren isn’t the most likable?!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

A quiet night. A locked door. And a stranger is already inside. She thought she was safe. She wasn’t.
In this episode, Director Traci Hays and star Tyler Perez talk about Kidnapped in Her Own Home: The Martha Carelli Story, a chilling story where a quiet life is shattered when a stranger takes control from inside of a home.

But what makes it even more disturbing? There’s no grand plan, no personal motive, just the terrifying randomness of how it all began.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Marsha Allen concocted a plan to poison her husband alongside her daughter, Ashley Jones, in 2022 using a root beer float and antifreeze…
When the victim, Harold Allen, was pronounced dead, authorities didn’t suspect any foul play. It was only when Marsha’s home was burglarized 9 months later that the truth finally came out.
Why did Marsha and Ashley do it? How many times did they try to poison him before they were successful? Was this Ashley’s first murder?!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.