Kevin speaks with Gold Derby colleague Tony Ruiz about Clint Eastwood's bleak crime drama 'Mystic River,' the likely runner-up in the 2003 Oscar race that lost to 'The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King.'

0:00 - 1:27 - Introduction

1:28 - 32:14 - 'Mystic River' review 

32:15 - 46:15 - Why 'Mystic River' lost Best Picture

46:16 - 1:04:40 - Shoulda been a contender

1:04:41 - 1:13:52 - Did 'Mystic River' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Tony Ruiz on Twitter:

@goldderbytony

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Kevin chats with Next Best Picture founder Matt Neglia about Martin Scorsese's epic Howard Hughes biopic 'The Aviator,' the likely runner-up in the 2004 Oscar race that lost to 'Million Dollar Baby.'

0:00 - 1:13 - Introduction

1:14 - 35:18 - 'The Aviator' review 

35:19 - 54:40 - Why 'The Aviator' lost Best Picture

54:41 - 1:18:32 - Shoulda been a contender

1:18:33 - 1:24:36 - Did 'The Aviator' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Matt Neglia on Twitter:

@NextBestPicture

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Kevin brings in AwardsWatch founder Erik Anderson for a discussion of Ang Lee's gorgeous romantic drama 'Brokeback Mountain,' the likely runner-up in the 2005 Oscar race that lost to 'Crash.'

0:00 - 1:11 - Introduction

1:12 - 36:15 - 'Brokeback Mountain' review 

36:16 - 1:07:32 - Why 'Brokeback Mountain' lost Best Picture

1:07:33 - 1:25:40 - Shoulda been a contender

1:25:41 - 1:29:10 - Did 'Brokeback Mountain' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Erik Anderson on Twitter:

@awards_watch

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Kevin speaks with AwardsCircuit writer and Citizen Dame co-host Karen Peterson about Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Faris' quirky dramedy 'Little Miss Sunshine,' the likely runner-up in the 2006 Oscar race that lost to 'The Departed.'

0:00 - 1:07 - Introduction

1:08 - 30:32 - 'Little Miss Sunshine' review 

30:33 - 47:07 - Why 'Little Miss Sunshine' lost Best Picture

47:08 - 1:00:21 - Shoulda been a contender

1:00:22 - 1:04:44 - Did 'Little Miss Sunshine' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Karen Peterson on Twitter:

@KarenMPeterson

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Kevin speaks with Gold Derby colleague Zach Laws about Paul Thomas Anderson's ambitious tale 'There Will Be Blood,' the likely runner-up in the 2007 Oscar race that lost to 'No Country for Old Men.'

0:00 - 1:11 - Introduction

1:12 - 30:18 - 'There Will Be Blood' review 

30:19 - 47:26 - Why 'There Will Be Blood' lost Best Picture

47:27 - 1:11:00 - Shoulda been a contender

1:11:01 - 1:16:48 - Did 'There Will Be Blood' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Zach Laws on Twitter:

@zachlaws

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Kevin brings in Gold Derby colleague and The Awards Connection writer Andrew Carden to talk about David Fincher's poignant epic 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button,' the likely runner-up in the 2008 Oscar race that lost to 'Slumdog Millionaire.'

0:00 - 1:18 - Introduction

1:19 - 28:46 - 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' review 

28:47 - 40:00 - Why 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' lost Best Picture

40:01 - 52:34 - Shoulda been a contender

52:35 - 1:01:38 - Did 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Andrew Carden on Twitter:

@AwardsConnect

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Kevin is joined by Gold Derby colleague Cordell Martin to talk about James Cameron's 3D event film 'Avatar,' the likely runner-up in the 2009 Oscar race that lost to 'The Hurt Locker.'

0:00 - 3:14 - Introduction

3:15 - 26:22 - 'Avatar' review 

26:23 - 41:18 - Why 'Avatar' lost Best Picture

41:19 - 48:34 - Shoulda been a contender

48:35 - 58:58 - Did 'Avatar' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Cordell Martin on Twitter:

@cordiub

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Kevin brings in Gold Derby Senior Editor Rob Licuria to talk about David Fincher's thrilling Facebook origin story 'The Social Network,' the likely runner-up in the 2010 Oscar race that lost to 'The King's Speech.'

0:00 - 1:11 - Introduction

1:12 - 32:02 - 'The Social Network' review 

32:03 - 48:04 - Why 'The Social Network' lost Best Picture

48:05 - 56:43 - Shoulda been a contender

56:44 - 1:04:53 - Did 'The Social Network' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Rob Licuria on Twitter:

@robertlicuria

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Kevin Jacobsen welcomes FiveThirtyEight reporter and Not Her Again co-host Walt Hickey to talk about Martin Scorsese's 3D family film 'Hugo,' the likely runner-up in the 2011 Oscar race that lost to 'The Artist.'

0:00 - 1:05 - Introduction

1:06 - 24:59 - 'Hugo' review 

25:00 - 40:56 - Why 'Hugo' lost Best Picture

40:57 - 52:24 - Shoulda been a contender

52:25 - 1:01:04 - Did 'Hugo' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Walt Hickey on Twitter:

@WaltHickey

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Kevin Jacobsen welcomes Gold Derby colleague Tom O'Brien to talk about Ang Lee's 3D technical wonder 'Life of Pi,' the likely runner-up in the 2012 Oscar race that lost to 'Argo.'

0:00 - 0:55 - Introduction

0:56 - 21:35 - 'Life of Pi' review 

21:36 - 42:41 - Why 'Life of Pi' lost Best Picture

42:42 - 1:01:33 - Shoulda been a contender

1:01:34 - 1:09:11 - Did 'Life of Pi' deserve to win?

Go to FilmTrophies.com or email at [email protected] to vote for which film you think deserved to win Best Picture.

Follow Kevin Jacobsen on Twitter:

@Kevin_Jacobsen

Follow Tom O'Brien on Twitter and at his website:

@thomaseobrien and ExactChangeToday.com

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter:

@OscarRunnerUp

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich