On the 251st episode of Big Orange Couch: The 90s Nickelodeon Podcast, Andrew, Joey, Candice, and first-time guest, Katie, will discuss the fifth season episode of Are You Afraid of the Dark, "The Tale of a Door Unlocked." Also, Midnight Society intros, bios, trivia, ratings, stray observations, and name the episode. Plus, getting to know Katie, what is Sardo's deal, major disagreements, and so much more!