One of the members of the Scary Storytellers makes a deal with the Tennamen's Coffee Corporation exchanging scary story tapes for a limitless supply of delicious Tennamen's coffee with bold flavor that's really good.

One of the members of the scary storytellers uses an old CB radio to communicate with his dead uncle across time and space so they can stop his murder.

To escape the chill of winter and get into the Christmas spirit, the members of the Scary Storytellers Society gather together indoors around the Yule log fire only to discover that an escaped mental patient is killing his way back home for the holidays, and he has enacted the Santa Clause giving him the powers of Old Saint Nick.

After one of the members of the Scary Storytellers loses half of his family in a horrible accident, he inherits a collection of Al Hitchcock films that inspire him to follow his dreams of being a filmmaker. He tells the guys the plot of his upcoming film, the story of Walter Pith...Perth a man who watches the world with eyes that pop out of his skull like the lady from Ripley's Believe It or Not!

The scary storytellers are abducted by extra terrestrials and taken aboard an alien space craft where they're subjected to bizarre experiments, disco parties and relentless probing.

Owens tells the scary storytellers about his college days when he was so desperate for a place of his own that he agreed to help an aspiring chef kill a vampire of the time sucking variety.

There's a growing schism dividing the Scary Storytellers Society after one of the members gets a questionable tattoo to honor his friend.

Guest storyteller, Tim Napolitan, tells the Scary Storytellers a story about a detective that involves cops, drug addicts and serial killers and The Super Mario Bros.

Owens tries to remember the awesome time he had partying with his new bros at their lake house near Savage Hill and uncovers the dark origin of the band Savage Garden in the process

Hibbs tells the story of a middle schooler, Colt Danielson, who enters a world of demon ninjas in his attempt to learn karate and gain self confidence.