The Interpreter Foundation Podcast

Asymmetry in Chiasms, With a Note About Deuteronomy 8 and Alma 36


Listen Later

Abstract: Some students of the Book of Mormon have claimed that chapter 36 of the book of Alma is structured as a chiasm. Some of the proposals depart from perfect symmetry, presenting elements of the suggested chiasm seemingly out of sequence. This has often been pointed to as a weakness in the proposed chiasm or as a problem arising from translation or editorial work, or even as evidence that no real chiasm exists over the text of the chapter. Perhaps, however, asymmetry may be a deliberate feature of ancient chiasmus. Understanding the presence and role of occasional asymmetry or skews, as they are called, may help us better appreciate the rhetorical tools employed in crafting chiastic texts anciently. In particular, we can see that the structure of Alma 36 may well be a beautifully crafted chiasmus featuring what may be an intentional skew similar to those that scholars have identified elsewhere in scripture. One such other chiastic text with a skew in it appears to be Deuteronomy 8. Indeed, one skew proposed in Alma 36, together with conceptual and other structural characteristics of the text, including the proposed chiasm of the text, perhaps suggests that some of the message and structure of Deuteronomy 8 may have served as a model for part of the message and structure of Alma 36.

h3 {margin-bottom: 0.5em !important;} td.right {text-align: right !important;} .ul {text-decoration: underline;} .dul {text-decoration: underline double;}
.chiasm1, .chiasm2, .chiasm3, .chiasm4, .chiasm5, .chiasm6, .chiasm7, .chiasm8, .chiasm9, .chiasm10, .chiasm11, .chiasm12, .chiasm13, .chiasm14, .chiasm15, .chiasm16, .chiasm17, .tiny-chiasm1, .tiny-chiasm2, .tiny-chiasm3, .tiny-chiasm4, .tiny-chiasm5, .tiny-chiasm6, .tiny-chiasm7, .tiny-chiasm8, .tiny-chiasm9, .tiny-chiasm10, .tiny-chiasm11, .tiny-chiasm12, .tiny-chiasm13, .tiny-chiasm14, .tiny-chiasm15, .tiny-chiasm16, .tiny-chiasm17, .tiny-chiasm18, .tiny-chiasm19, .tiny-chiasm20, .tiny-chiasm21, .tiny-chiasm22, .tiny-chiasm23, .tiny-chiasm24, .tiny-chiasm25, .tiny-chiasm26, .tiny-chiasm27, .tiny-chiasm28, .tinytiny-chiasm1, .tinytiny-chiasm2, .tinytiny-chiasm3, .tinytiny-chiasm4, .tinytiny-chiasm5, .tinytiny-chiasm6, .tinytiny-chiasm7, .tinytiny-chiasm8, .tinytiny-chiasm9, .tinytiny-chiasm10, .tinytiny-chiasm11, .tinytiny-chiasm12, .tinytiny-chiasm13, .tinytiny-chiasm14, .tinytiny-chiasm15, .tinytiny-chiasm16, .tinytiny-chiasm17, .tinytiny-chiasm18, .tinytiny-chiasm19, .tinytiny-chiasm20, .tinytiny-chiasm21, .tinytiny-chiasm22, .tinytiny-chiasm23, .tinytiny-chiasm24, .tinytiny-chiasm25, .tinytiny-chiasm26, .tinytiny-chiasm27, .tinytiny-chiasm28, .tinytiny-chiasm29, .table-chiasm1, .table-chiasm2, .table-chiasm3, .table-chiasm4 {text-indent: -1.5em !important; text-align: left !important;}
.chiasm1 {margin-left: 5em;} .chiasm2 {margin-left: 6.5em;} .chiasm3 {margin-left: 8em;} .chiasm4 {margin-left: 9.5em;} .chiasm5 {margin-left: 11em;} .chiasm6 {margin-left: 12.5em;} .chiasm7 {margin-left: 14em;} .chiasm8 {margin-left: 15.5em;} .chiasm9 {margin-left: 17em;} .chiasm10 {margin-left: 18.5em;} .chiasm11 {margin-left: 20em;} .chiasm12 {margin-left: 21.5em;} .chiasm13 {margin-left: 23em;} .chiasm14 {margin-left: 24.5em;} .chiasm15 {margin-left: 26em;} .chiasm16 {margin-left: 27.5em;} .chiasm17 {margin-left: 29em;}
.tiny-chiasm1 {margin-left: 5em;} .tiny-chiasm2 {margin-left: 6em;} .tiny-chiasm3 {margin-left: 7em;} .tiny-chiasm4 {margin-left: 8em;} .tiny-chiasm5 {margin-left: 9em;} .tiny-chiasm6 {margin-left: 10em;} .tiny-chiasm7 {margin-left: 11em;} .tiny-chiasm8 {margin-left: 12em;} .tiny-chiasm9 {margin-left: 13em;} .tiny-chiasm10 {margin-left: 14em;} .tiny-chiasm11 {margin-left: 15em;} .tiny-chiasm12 {margin-left: 16em;} .tiny-chiasm13 {margin-left: 17em;} .tiny-chiasm14 {margin-left: 18em;} .tiny-chiasm15 {margin-left: 19em;} .tiny-chiasm16 {margin-left: 20em;} .tiny-chiasm17 {margin-left: 21em;} .tiny-chiasm18 {margin-left: 22em;} .
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Interpreter Foundation PodcastBy The Interpreter Foundation Podcast

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

32 ratings


More shows like The Interpreter Foundation Podcast

View all
Mormon Discussions Podcasts – Full Lineup by Bill Reel

Mormon Discussions Podcasts – Full Lineup

635 Listeners

Maxwell Institute Podcast by Maxwell Institute Podcast

Maxwell Institute Podcast

812 Listeners

Scripture Central by Scripture Central

Scripture Central

985 Listeners

Talking Scripture by Mike Day & Bryce Dunford

Talking Scripture

1,790 Listeners

Y Religion by BYU Religious Education

Y Religion

1,816 Listeners

Church News by Church News

Church News

935 Listeners

Unshaken Saints by Jared Halverson

Unshaken Saints

2,621 Listeners

followHIM by Hank Smith & John Bytheway

followHIM

10,663 Listeners

Standard of Truth by Dr. Gerrit Dirkmaat

Standard of Truth

985 Listeners

Come Follow Up by BYUradio

Come Follow Up

88 Listeners

The Scriptures Are Real by Kerry Muhlestein

The Scriptures Are Real

511 Listeners

Come Back Podcast by Ashly Stone

Come Back Podcast

1,563 Listeners

Church History Matters by Scripture Central

Church History Matters

2,101 Listeners

Temples and Covenants by BYU Speeches

Temples and Covenants

190 Listeners