In this episode, we're back in the present, managing season three's finale fallout. Mike bitches about waiting a year and a half for this excellent episode. Matt is happy that (most) everyone is happy for Kara. Pat doesn't understand why everyone's ready to sex up Gaius Baltar.

Join us as we flash back to a simpler time, when Helena Cain was Admiral, Pegasus wasn't ka-sploded, and Lt. Kendra Shaw was learning to become a razor. Matt contrasts Cain and Adama's post-apocalypse rallying cries. Mike savors the First Hybrid's portents of season four. Pat explains why Razor's extended version is worth watching.

The trial of Gaius Baltar. Four of the Final Five revealed. And, as if that weren't enough, Kara's back. Pat pokes holes in Romo Lampkin's defense. Matt is swept up in the possibilities the Final Five present. Mike is ready for all this to happen again.

Guest host Joe Drew joins us for the introduction of Romo Frakkin' Lampkin. Mike prematurely trademarks Drunk Adama Decisions. Pat doesn't believe anything Lampkin says. Matt can't understand why Lee won't talk to his wife.

"Her ship's in pieces. No chute. We lost her." Mike argues that Kara needed to be in the cockpit. Pat knows Starbuck would do anything to avoid her issues. Matt wonders how the season finale is going to top this episode.

With the Cylons nowhere in sight, the fleet's workers demand better conditions and a fairer society. Pat's willing to barter for Baltar's tell-all. Matt understands why workers' rights might've taken a backseat 'til now. Mike would've put Cally against the wall.

What does it mean to realize your most significant decision might've been wrong? That's the question at the heart of A Day in the Life. Pat attempts to convince us Cally has merit. Matt buys Adama getting mired in the past. Mike understands that love is a battlefield.

How far can the fleet tolerate the Sagittarions' "backward" beliefs? How far can the Sagittarions tolerate the fleet's prejudice? Matt goes hard for Detective Sherlock Helomes. Pat takes issue with the episode's monster-of-the-week structure. Mike finds it completely plausible that the fleet would retain its prejudices.

Wouldn't it be nice to get away, Gaius? Too bad everybody in the fleet knows your name. Guest host Anna joins us to examine Baltar's mental state and finally put this Lee Adama drama to bed.

Look, behind you! It's a Cavil! Where'd he come from?! Who knows? Mike examines the politics of sending your wife to rescue your mistress. Pat is shocked to find Caprica Six once again snapping necks. Matt worries that Battlestar might be bad now.