BT and Sal bring in Hoff for a fiery edition of "Bald-Faced Lie, Bald-Faced Truth," tackling three controversial statements. First, Sal declares the Mets making the 2026 playoffs is a Bald-Faced Truth, driven by his faith in Steve Cohen and David Stearns to make major changes. Second, the trio debates if Darius Slayton will lead the Giants in receiving yards this season, with Sal betting it's a Bald-Faced Lie in favor of Wan'Dale Robinson. Finally, they heatedly discuss the Yankees-Red Sox Game 1 pitching matchup, with Sal ultimately siding with Max Fried having a better line than Garrett Crochet, arguing that Aaron Judge will touch up the Red Sox ace.

BT and Sal dove into the Yankees' Wild Card roster, expressing both excitement for postseason baseball and major concerns about the team's composition. Sal was flabbergasted by the inclusion of Paul Blackburn over Luis Gil, calling Blackburn's presence a sign that the Yankees are in "big trouble" if he has to pitch. The hosts debated whether the defense, the bullpen management, or the configuration of the everyday lineup (especially the Ben Rice/Austin Wells situation) poses the biggest threat to the team's World Series aspirations. Despite some skepticism, BT gave GM Brian Cashman credit for the trade deadline acquisitions, noting the team suddenly has a "grit" that was missing before.

BT and Sal engaged in a fiery debate over the disastrous 0-4 start for the New York Jets, with BT expressing serious reservations about head coach Aaron Glenn. Citing awful fundamentals, boneheaded mistakes like fielding a punt at the two-yard line, and a glaring lack of tackling, BT declared he can no longer "blindly" trust that Glenn is the right man for the job. He argued that Glenn's promises of a "different" team and improved discipline have been the exact opposite of what the team has shown on the field. While Sal urged patience for the first-year coach and blamed the chaotic New York environment, BT insisted that the team's visible lack of preparation and poor performance are a direct reflection of a coach who may be in over his head.

Sal and BT debated the true advantage in the Yankees-Red Sox best-of-three Wild Card Series, concluding that while the Yankees appear set up for success with their rotation, glaring issues could lead to an early exit. Sal is concerned about the Yankees' "flaws," specifically the shaky bullpen (trusting Bednar but not Williams or Weaver) and the inconsistent defense, singling out Volpe and Ben Rice's potential contributions. BT agreed that the high-stakes, short series magnifies these vulnerabilities, making it incredibly dangerous, even with a powerhouse like Aaron Judge in the lineup, who the hosts admit has historically underperformed in the postseason.

Sal and BT dove into the high-stakes Wild Card Series opener between the Yankees and Red Sox, centered around the formidable pitching matchup: Max Fried versus Garrett Crochet. Sal emphasized that this is a true test for the Yankees right out of the gate, unlike the previous year's "cakewalk." BT agreed it's the toughest matchup they could face but feels this deeper, more resilient Yankees team is finally equipped to fight. The conversation quickly shifted to the immense pressure on Aaron Judge to deliver in the postseason, especially against a "nasty lefty" like Crochet, while also questioning manager Aaron Boone's projected lineup decisions against the tough matchup.

The hosts are electric with anticipation for the Yankees' Wild Card Series against the rival Red Sox, viewing it as the team's ultimate early test and a chance for redemption. Sal and BT are thrilled by the high-stakes, palpable October hatred, even if they acknowledge the risk of a short series loss. They believe this current Yankees team is the most complete and capable of winning a World Series that Aaron Boone has had, but they must first overcome their most dangerous opponent right out of the gate—their bitter rivals from Boston. The debate quickly turns to the controversial Game 1 lineup set to face Boston's nasty lefty, Garrett Crochet.

The best reactions to the Giants' Week 4 win over the Chargers from Boomer & Gio, BT & Sal, and Evan & Tiki.

From 'NYYST' (subscribe here): The Yankees finished the regular season on an 8 game winning streak but it wasn’t enough to overtake Toronto at the top of the AL East. 

Christian and Sem are back to preview the Wild Card Series against Boston and deliver a few choice words for the team across town.

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Sal and BT furiously dissected the New York Mets' most embarrassing season ever, a historic collapse that saw the $400 million team miss the expanded postseason. The discussion was fueled by owner Steve Cohen's immediate public apology to fans and star Pete Alonso's post-game announcement that he will opt out, signaling a potential tear-down of the core, including possible trades for Francisco Lindor and Brandon Nimmo. This baseball disaster overshadowed the Giants' massive win over the Chargers and the exciting debut of rookie QB Jaxson Dart, with the celebratory mood immediately soured by the devastating news of Malik Nabers' season-ending ACL tear.

Sal and BT furiously dissected the Mets' "most embarrassing season" ever, a complete implosion despite a massive payroll and an expanded playoff field. The hosts agree this shocking collapse, characterized by a lack of character and clutch play, demands a "wrecking ball" approach to the roster. They also debated the fallout from Pete Alonso's immediate post-game declaration that he's opting out, with Sal defending the honesty of a player he feels the Mets management disrespected, while BT points out the core issue of a team that simply lacked the fight to resist its own downfall.