In a somber tribute to 9/11, BT and Sal discuss how sports are meant to be an escape but the current state of both the Mets and Yankees has become a new source of frustration. They dissect the Mets' shocking inconsistency, pondering whether they're better off with quirky personalities like Jesse Winker and Grimace than with a numbers-obsessed star like Juan Soto. Meanwhile, Sal expresses concern over the Yankees' bullpen and Volpe's injury, while the hosts disagree on whether the Yankees can still win their division. The conversation shifts to the Jets, with Wayne Chrebet discussing his 9/11 memories and the team's new culture under Aaron Glenn, before diving into NFL power rankings and venting from fans.

Sal and BT begin their show by reflecting on the somber anniversary of 9/11, highlighting the unity that emerged in New York and the rest of the country in the aftermath. They then pivot to the current state of New York sports, lamenting that while sports are meant to be an escape, the recent inconsistent and frustrating play of both the Mets and Yankees has made them anything but. The hosts discuss the Mets' puzzling lack of fun and inconsistency despite their talent, and the Yankees' ongoing struggles and sloppy play, questioning whether either team has the fortitude to succeed and make a deep postseason run.

Sal and BT's discussion was a fiery mix of athlete attitudes and team culture. They tore into Juan Soto's selfish play, arguing that his actions—like stealing a meaningless base while the Mets were down big—prove he cares more about his individual stats than team wins. Shifting gears to a more somber tone, they honored 9/11 with former Jet Wayne Chrebet, who shared his raw memories of the attacks and spoke about the new, accountable culture of the current Jets team. The segment closed with a critical look at Giants coach Brian Daboll, whose recent, uncharacteristic charm in a press conference was seen as a desperate public relations move born out of a lack of on-field success.

n a wild segment, BT and Sal explored a peculiar solution to the Mets' miserable season: bringing back Grimace to change the team's "vibe." Sal, half-jokingly, even suggested getting Grimace on the horn for an interview, convinced that the mascot's return would bring back the good energy from last season's winning streak. The discussion took a fiery turn when a caller, Mike from Old Bridge, lit into the hosts. Mike called Sal a "bum" and a "jinx," vehemently disagreeing with his ideas and accusing the duo of being a joke. The segment, which also included a discussion of NFL power rankings, underscored the frustration and absurdity surrounding the current state of both the Mets and Yankees.

On today's show, BT and Sal got into a fiery debate over the Yankees' bullpen struggles, with Sal pushing back on BT's faith in reliever Fernando Cruz after his recent meltdown. The discussion then took a surprising turn when they reacted to the breaking news that Anthony Volpe has been playing with a shoulder injury and recently received a cortisone shot, a revelation that may explain his defensive struggles. Wrapping up the show, they shared their "Call of the Day" clip featuring an interview with former Jets wide receiver Wayne Chrebet.

Sal and BT's "Call of the Day" centered on a quote from Mets outfielder Brandon Nimmo, where he claimed other teams were "hoping we don't make the playoffs" because they don't want to see the Mets in October. The hosts took Nimmo to task for what they saw as a delusional and dangerous mindset, arguing that it shows the team is not taking their current struggles seriously. Sal and BT said the quote revealed a "fatalistic" attitude where the team believes they can just "turn it on" when the playoffs arrive, a belief that is not supported by their recent poor play. They argued that this lack of urgency is the very reason the Mets are in danger of missing the playoffs in the first place.

BT and Sal reacted to the news that Anthony Volpe received a cortisone shot for a lingering shoulder injury, a bombshell revelation that may explain his season-long struggles. Sal noted that Volpe's offensive numbers have dropped significantly since he originally hurt his non-throwing shoulder in May, but stopped short of calling it a full excuse for his poor performance. He questioned why the Yankees and Aaron Boone have consistently downplayed the injury, and he and BT debated whether it's a legitimate reason for Volpe's slump or just another convenient excuse for the team's struggles.

BT and Sal dive into their first NFL power rankings of the regular season, a tradition that promises controversy and debate. After a wild opening week, the duo reveals their top five teams, with surprising additions and notable exclusions. BT's fiery take on the Bills and Sal's defense of the Ravens despite their loss sets the stage for a classic BT & Sal showdown, as they analyze the early results and try to separate the contenders from the pretenders heading into Week 2.

After a caller launched into a furious tirade against Sal's opinions on the Mets, BT and Sal embraced the role of on-air verbal punching bags. They stated that if a listener needs to vent and direct their anger at them to feel better, they are more than willing to take the abuse. This segment solidified their position as a platform for fan frustration, showing that they are not afraid to face fiery callers head-on, no matter how personal the insults get. They made it clear that they are there to serve the listeners, even if it means absorbing the full force of their rage.

Brian Daboll's recent press conference marked a noticeable shift in his public demeanor, as he was uncharacteristically open and "chatty" with the media. BT and Sal discussed this change, viewing it as a necessary course correction for a coach who has lost his "equity" with the fanbase after a series of frustrating losses. They argued that his previous Belichick-like, terse approach was no longer sustainable given the team's poor performance. While they see this new, more cooperative tone as a positive first step, they both agree that it's meaningless without a corresponding improvement on the field.