BT and Sal exploded in disbelief and outrage over DJ LeMahieu's reported negative reaction to being benched, with BT emphatically stating DJ should "pack his bags and get lost" because he can't hit, field, or throw. They questioned his self-awareness, arguing he's "lucky to have a uniform" given his declining performance and that his perceived "hissy fit" contradicts any notion of him being a good clubhouse guy. Sal even suggested the Yankees might be placating Aaron Judge by keeping DJ around, while both hosts agreed the team should have moved on from LeMahieu years ago, lamenting the continuous "placating" despite his clear inability to contribute.

BT and Sal delve into the effectiveness of Clay Holmes as a starting pitcher for the Mets, with BT vehemently arguing that Holmes is a five-inning pitcher at best and pushing him further is reckless, especially given his past as a converted reliever and his career-high in innings pitched. Sal, while acknowledging the need for caution, points to Holmes's economical performance in his last outing and the impending return of other starters as factors that might alleviate the workload, but ultimately agrees that preserving Holmes for the postseason should be the priority, even if it means limiting his starts or innings.

BT and Sal open their show celebrating the New York Mets' recent offensive surge, particularly from their "Big Three" of Lindor, Soto, and Alonso, which is finally reflecting the formidable lineup they were designed to be at the season's start. They highlight the team's stabilized pitching rotation with the return of Senga and Manaea, fostering a new sense of hope and positivity around the club after a period of struggles. While acknowledging the need for potential further additions, especially a bullpen arm or a center fielder, the hosts emphasize that the top of the Mets' order is now clicking, making them a dangerous team built to contend for a World Series.

BT and Sal dive deep into the New York sports scene, dissecting the Yankees' ongoing struggles and whether they should "sell" at the deadline, while also celebrating the Mets' recent resurgence and aggressive trade deadline outlook. They also tackle the perplexing Knicks coaching staff changes, with Mike Brown's introduction and Rick Brunson's demotion stirring controversy. The duo also explores the fascinating, if radical, possibility of MLB realignment, including a "Premier League" system and the potential for a third New York team, igniting a passionate debate on the future of baseball.

BT and Sal dive headfirst into the New York Yankees' recent struggles, debating whether their current slump is a temporary blip in the new, unpredictable MLB landscape, or a symptom of deeper, long-standing organizational issues. While Sal advocates for the Yankees to "sell" off some dead weight and proactively address roster deficiencies by inserting younger talent like Dominguez and Rice, BT counters that overreacting to a few bad weeks in a volatile season is premature, especially given the Yankees' historical ability to bounce back and make deep playoff runs. They discuss the recent decision to move Jazz Chisholm Jr. back to second base as a long-overdue sign of progress, yet question the Yankees' overall philosophy of player acquisition and development, highlighting the ongoing frustrations of fans watching the same fundamental flaws persist year after year.

In their second hour, BT and Sal pivoted from Yankees talk to focus on the New York Mets, with a central theme revolving around the upcoming trade deadline. Inspired by a conversation with SNY's Andy Martino, Sal expressed renewed excitement for the Mets' potential aggression in acquiring talent, particularly a top bullpen arm and potentially more. They debated the "championship window" for the Mets, arguing that with Steve Cohen's willingness to spend and the core of the team, now is the time to go all-in. The discussion also touched on which prospects the Mets should be willing to part with, contrasting their approach to prospect hoarding with that of the Yankees.

BT and Sal engage in a lively and opinionated discussion about the current state of baseball, particularly focusing on the New York Yankees' recent struggles and the Mets' ongoing efforts. They delve into the Yankees' decision to move Jazz Chisholm back to second base, the team's pitching woes, and potential trade deadline moves, while also debating the impact of expanded postseasons and the possibility of MLB realignment and expansion. Sal often expresses frustration with the Yankees' "fundamental flaws," advocating for aggressive changes, while BT offers a more measured perspective, urging against overreacting to bad stretches in a long baseball season, all while maintaining a spirited back-and-forth about the New York baseball landscape.

BT and Sal delve into the New York Knicks' recent hiring of Mike Brown as head coach and the controversial demotion of assistant coach Rick Brunson, Jalen Brunson's father. Sal expresses strong disapproval of the demotion, arguing that it's a "stupid move" that risks upsetting star player Jalen Brunson and creating power struggles within the team, comparing it to a "Jets move" that will inevitably lead to further issues. He believes that if the Knicks intended to lessen Rick Brunson's role, they should have simply let him go entirely to avoid an "untenable" situation, despite the potential backlash from Jalen. BT, on the other hand, seems to initially think Sal would approve of Brown having more control over his staff, but Sal insists the demotion creates more problems than it solves, fearing it could ultimately lead to Jalen Brunson's dissatisfaction and a "domino effect" that derails the team's future.

In this "Call of the Day," Eddie from Long Island passionately argues that the struggling Yankees could significantly improve their winning record, particularly in extra innings, if they simply embraced small ball and bunted more often with runners on base. He emphasizes this as a fundamental Little League principle and expresses extreme frustration with the team's current approach. Brendan Tierney and Sal Licata then debate Eddie's point, bringing up hypothetical lineup changes and the merits of potential trade targets like Ryan McMahon and Nolan Arenado, ultimately circling back to the Yankees' perceived aversion to bunting and its impact on their offensive strategy.

BT and Sal are fired up discussing the latest Knicks news, with Rick Brunson's role reportedly being cut back under new head coach Mike Brown. While the organization claims this move grants Brown more control and addresses "distractions" or perceived conflicts of interest, Sal argues it's a dangerous demotion that could create an untenable situation for Rick, ultimately jeopardizing the relationship with star player Jalen Brunson. Given Jalen's close bond and loyalty to his father and his support for former coach Tom Thibodeau, the demotion is seen by some as a potential misstep that could upset the Knicks' franchise player and lead to further instability, despite Rick reportedly being "on board" with the change for now.