The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Big Mac and Craig Carton react to the breaking news that Aaron Boone will return to manage the New York Yankees for the final year of his contract. They analyze the fan base's frustration and the reported internal friction caused by Aaron Judge’s public comments about the team’s lack of production. The discussion also features a debate regarding the Jets' tanking strategies and the Giants' uncertainty at quarterback.

(00:01:00) Aaron Boone Returns

(00:04:15) Yankee Media Reporting

(00:07:40) Judge's Official Comments

(00:10:12) Jets Tanking Debate

(00:14:55) Paul's New Relationship

The Carton Show criticizes Polymarket for hosting wagers on a sexual assault trial involving the Cornell Seven. The conversation shifts to the New York Knicks season opener, highlighting roster expectations and potential concerns regarding Karl-Anthony Towns.

(00:01:12) Polymarket Betting Controversy

(00:08:10) Game Of The Week

(00:08:43) Knicks Season Preview

(00:12:14) Karl-Anthony Towns Concerns

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle express outrage over the Philadelphia Eagles' handling of Jalen Hurts' health following reports of a blood clot. They also debate the safety of playing NFL games in Paris amidst civil unrest and discuss a potential quarterback transition from Jameis Winston to J.J. McCarthy.

(00:01:00) Birthday Cake Banter

(00:02:57) NFL Paris Safety

(00:06:13) Hurts Health Controversy

(00:14:36) Winston McCarthy Debate

(00:18:37) Sunday Football Vent

Stephen A. Smith joins Craig to discuss the Philadelphia Eagles' medical handling of Jalen Hurts and his recent health scare. He also reflects on his lifelong New York Knicks fandom and evaluates Jalen Brunson's impact on the franchise's championship success. They swap stories about their early radio days in Philadelphia and debate an upcoming interview with Bill Maher.

(00:01:00) Stephen A. Smith Joins

(00:02:28) Eagles Medical Handling Concerns

(00:07:09) NFL In France Discussion

(00:10:41) Knicks Fandom And Championship

(00:18:29) Bill Maher Interview Banter

Craig and C-Mac break down the Jets' frustrating loss to the Patriots, specifically questioning the coaching decisions and late-game execution. They also handle a strange Zach Bryan ticket giveaway and discuss if a high-profile college coach like Kurt Cignetti could be the answer for 2025.

(00:01:04) Zach Bryan Ticket Giveaway

(00:05:16) Jets Coaching Decisions Breakdown

(00:12:00) New York Jets Future Debate

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the bizarre kickoff confusion involving the New York Jets' coaching staff and the team's offensive woes under Frank Reich. They also analyze the betting lines for the upcoming week, highlighting a massive point spread for the New York Giants against the Houston Texans.

(00:01:09) Jets Coaching and Kickoff Confusion

(00:05:10) Caller Danny Critiques Offense

(00:10:11) Giants vs. Texans Spread

Craig Carton and Big Mac break down the offensive ineptitude of the Jets and Giants while comparing their coaching struggles to successful NFL schemes. During the Carton Show, they argue that local players have not yet earned the right to attend the Knicks' championship ring ceremony given their disappointing season performances.

(00:01:08) New York Football Recap

(00:02:46) Jets Coaching Woes

(00:05:37) Knicks Ring Night Rant

(00:09:45) Caller On Talent Gaps

Craig Carton and Big Mac evaluate the New York Giants' quarterback situation, discussing if JJ McCarthy should replace Jameis Winston. They also analyze the Philadelphia Eagles' organizational struggles and hear from Jets fans frustrated with offensive coordinator Frank Reich.

(00:01:15) Giants and Jets Update

(00:01:40) Winston vs McCarthy Debate

(00:03:40) Eagles Season Collapse

(00:06:21) Jets Offensive Frustrations

(00:12:38) Giants Running Back Issues

Craig and C-Mac vent their frustrations regarding the Jets’ embarrassing loss to the Patriots, specifically targeting the play-calling of Frank Reich and Aaron Glenn. They also dive into the New York Giants' backfield issues and the confusing lack of touches for Cam Skattebo.

(00:01:06) Jets Coaching Failures

(00:05:33) Frank Reich Playcalling

(00:09:16) Giants Performance Issues

(00:10:14) Skattebo Benchgate Controversy