Sal and BT debate the best and worst possible Wild Card opponents for the Yankees, with an emphasis on the entertainment and competitive value of each matchup. While BT pushes for a spicy, rivalry-fueled series against the Red Sox, Sal raises concerns about their ace, Garrett Crochet, and the strength of their pitching. The hosts also touch on the potential of facing the Astros or Mariners and the importance of the Yankees securing home-field advantage. The conversation revolves around the question of what a "successful" season would be for the Yankees, given their current state, with both hosts agreeing that anything less than a World Series appearance would be a letdown.