While Aaron Judge may be a great player, he is not a great motivator. Plus the Jets start to make some tough decisions! Craig is feeling optimistic by the New York Jets for the first time in a long time. Plus, Alex Rodriguez will never be CC Sabathia. Margot Robbie proves that acting is not a job you can have a long lasting relationship with! Team Italy is stacking up their coaching staff, Hoff get's pranked again and hanging with Danny DeVito!

While Aaron Judge may be a great player, he is not a great motivator. Plus the Jets start to make some tough decisions!

Craig is feeling optimistic by the New York Jets for the first time in a long time. Plus, Alex Rodriguez will never be CC Sabathia.

Margot Robbie proves that acting is not a job you can have a long lasting relationship with!

Team Italy is stacking up their coaching staff, Hoff get's pranked again and hanging with Danny DeVito!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go wild on the air in this unforgettable segment of the Carton Show! From Knicks betting advice (“stay away tonight!”) to a jaw-dropping prank call claiming to be Angelina Jolie’s love child, you won’t believe what happens next. Plus, music history, Michael Jackson vs. Beatles catalog drama, and unbelievable fan stories. This is one WFAN segment you can’t miss!

The Carton Show goes OFF on March 3, 2026! Chris McMonigle & Craig Carton dive into Mets batting practice updates, Nolan McLean’s ear infection, and WBC pitcher drama. Plus, they debate Jorge Posada & Francisco Cervelli’s Team Italy roles, share hilarious Yankees fan stories, talk LeBron James controversy, and even reveal Big Mac’s high school sports secrets. Don’t miss the laughs, inside baseball takes, and wild sports gossip you won’t hear anywhere else!

You won’t believe what went down on the Carton Show today! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down Russell Wilson’s feud with Sean Payton, Aaron Judge’s playoff struggles, and the shocking JT Miller injury/party controversy. Plus, Jets draft trade talk, Mets & Yankees updates, and some hilarious behind-the-scenes radio stories you won’t hear anywhere else! Don’t miss this chaotic, no-holds-barred WFAN segment.

hris McMonigle & Craig Carton dive into the wildest pop culture and NFL takes on the March 3, 2026 Carton Show! From the mysterious wife of Aaron Rodgers to Shaq’s outrageous new candy, Hollywood scandals with Margot Robbie, and the latest on Kyler Murray’s potential Jets move you won’t believe what they unpacked on-air. Don’t miss the chaos, the laughs, and insider insights!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the heated debate: Should Alex Rodriguez have his number retired by the New York Yankees?