The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

They discuss the intense emotions and sky-high ticket prices surrounding tonight's championship banner ceremony at Madison Square Garden. A strict guest policy is proposed, arguing that current non-winning stars like Aaron Judge and Francisco Lindor should stay home to keep the night reserved for true New York champions.

(00:01:06) Knicks Banner Night Emotions

(00:04:32) Guest List and Exclusions

(00:09:05) Historic New York Championships

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Giants' decision to release Najee Harris following his public comments about the team's backfield rotation. They debate John Harbaugh's strict coaching style and look forward to the championship banner ceremony for the New York Knicks at Madison Square Garden.

(00:01:00) Tuesday Show Introduction

(00:02:25) Najee Harris Release Analysis

(00:08:06) Giants Quarterback Controversy

(00:12:02) Knicks Championship Celebration

The Carton Show discusses the news of Aaron Boone returning to manage the New York Yankees for the 2025 season. They also analyze the coaching frustrations for the New York Jets and the medical emergency involving Jalen Hurts. Stephen A. Smith joins the conversation to weigh in on the New York Knicks and NFL safety.

(00:01:50) New York Football Struggles

(00:05:32) Jets Play Calling Criticism

(00:09:41) Giants Quarterback Dilemma

(00:13:12) Jalen Hurts Health Emergency

(00:15:51) Stephen A. Smith Interview

(00:24:16) PolyMarket Betting Controversy

(00:36:33) Bill Maher Discussion

(00:49:05) Aaron Boone Manager Decision

Craig and Big Mac analyze the frustrating performances of both New York football teams following recent losses. They criticize the Jets' coaching decisions under Aaron Glenn and Frank Reich while debating the future of the Giants' quarterback position between Jameis Winston and JJ McCarthy.

(00:01:20) Jets And Giants Meltdown

(00:04:36) Jets Coaching Under Fire

(00:09:10) Giants QB Debate Begins

(00:12:42) Harbaugh And Skattebo Drama

(00:17:35) Winston Versus McCarthy Decision

(00:22:05) No Jets At Garden

(00:25:55) NFC East Division Recap

Craig and C-Mac discuss the ongoing coaching failures of the Jets and the betting outlook for New York football. They examine the Giants' underdog status against the Texans and debate the ability of the team to compete without a consistent rushing attack.

(00:01:25) Jets Coaching Confusion

(00:05:15) Offensive Strategy Failures

(00:08:40) Jets Dolphins Betting

(00:12:00) Giants Texans Point Spread

(00:17:25) Knicks Opening Night Hype

(00:20:45) Giants Saints Defensive Struggles

(00:24:45) Harbaugh Rushing Rotation Concerns

Craig Carton and Big Mac speak with Stephen A. Smith about the Philadelphia Eagles' questionable handling of Jalen Hurts' medical emergency and the risks of playing NFL games in Paris. They also discuss the New York Knicks' championship victory and Jalen Brunson's pivotal leadership role. The conversation then transitions to analyzing the New York Giants' depth chart at running back and quarterback.

(00:02:12) Stephen A. Smith Joins

(00:05:34) Jalen Hurts Medical Scare

(00:10:47) Aaron Rodgers Influence

(00:13:56) Knicks Championship Fandom

(00:18:02) Jalen Brunson Leadership

(00:22:21) Carton VS Stephen A.

(00:27:20) Giants Running Back Woes

(00:31:27) Giants Quarterback Decision

(00:38:41) Jets And Dolphins Preview

Big Mac and Carton criticize the Philadelphia Eagles for their handling of Jalen Hurts' health following reports of a blood clot and extreme sleep deprivation. They also discuss the NFL's decision to play in Paris amidst civil unrest and voice frustration over the constant presence of the Manning brothers in commercials. The conversation concludes with news of Aaron Boone’s return to the Yankees and a preview of the Knicks’ home opener featuring Karl-Anthony Towns.

(00:02:57) NFL Security In Paris

(00:06:14) Jalen Hurts Medical Scandal

(00:12:44) Winston Versus McCarthy Debate

(00:17:30) Manning Commercial Fatigue

(00:23:44) Polymarket Betting Controversy

(00:31:20) Knicks Home Opener Preview

(00:13:05) Aaron Boone Yankees Return

(00:21:09) Giants Quarterback Concerns

(00:27:36) Producer Paul In Love

Chris McMonagle evaluates the New York Giants' struggling offense and the potential for a quarterback change between Jameis Winston and J. J. McCarthy. He also explores the collapse of the NFC East and questions whether the Yankees can find postseason success under Aaron Boone's continued leadership.

(00:01:00) Giants QB Debate

(00:04:25) Running Game Accountability

(00:09:24) NFC East Outlook

(00:13:51) Aaron Boone and Yankees

(00:21:34) New York Jets Future