The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

The Carton Show examines the winless records of the Dolphins and Chargers, leading to a debate on whether Jim Harbaugh or Bill Belichick should coach the Jets. They break down the Giants' special teams situation and locker room dynamics after a narrow loss. Craig Carton also recounts a past physical altercation with another reporter during his time as an Eagles beat writer.

(00:01:07) Winless NFL Team Struggles

(00:02:56) Jets Head Coach Debate

(00:08:05) Giants Special Teams Analysis

(00:13:48) Giants Locker Room Insights

(00:17:24) Craig's Reporter Fight Story

Craig and Chris react to the bizarre ending of the Giants' game against the Commanders and the team's struggles in the kicking game. They also voice frustrations with the Fox broadcast team and analyze the Jets' defensive success against Deshaun Watson and the Browns.

(00:01:13) Giants vs Commanders Reaction

(00:04:26) Giants Strategy & OT Rules

(00:09:31) Jets Defensive Analysis

C-Mac evaluates the New York Giants' newfound resilience and their ability to remain competitive regardless of the opponent. They also discuss Jameis Winston's high-volume passing day and critique the New York Jets' offensive strategy during their win over the Cleveland Browns.

(00:01:00) Warwick Wildcats Mud Bowl

(00:05:30) Analyzing Jameis Winston's Performance

(00:09:15) Jets Beat Cleveland Browns

Carton and Big Mac react to a wild Sunday where the Giants moved into first place in the NFC East following a chaotic tie. They also praise the Jets' defensive performance in their victory over the Browns and discuss the emerging stardom of Malik Nabers.

(00:01:00) NY Football Recap

(00:02:07) Giants' Chaotic Tie

(00:05:15) NFC East Standings

(00:07:40) Malik Nabers' Impact

(00:11:00) Jets Defeat Browns

Craig and Big Mac break down the Dallas Cowboys' home loss and what it means for the New York Giants' chances in the NFC East. They are joined by Chris Kirschner to analyze a controversial report regarding Aaron Judge's commitment and the cultural issues within the Yankees organization.

(00:01:50) Weekend Sports Preview

(00:02:40) Cowboys Loss Analysis

(00:04:25) Giants Playoff Outlook

(00:15:37) Knicks Preseason Atmosphere

(00:18:44) Judge Leadership Rumors

(00:21:15) Chris Kirschner Interview

(00:23:54) Craig's Bizarre Advice

(00:29:40) NFL Rule Discussion

(00:32:49) Yankees Culture Debate

On the Carton Show, Craig and Big Mac discuss the New York Giants' opportunity to lead the division following a surprising Dallas Cowboys collapse. They evaluate the team's momentum under Brian Daboll and the high stakes for the New York Jets in their critical matchup against the Cleveland Browns. The conversation also highlights the electric atmosphere surrounding the New York Knicks' preseason return to Madison Square Garden.

(00:01:20) Giants Pursuit Of Division Lead

(00:05:15) Confidence In Giants Coaching

(00:08:35) Prescott's Locker Room Incident

(00:14:15) Knicks Preseason Energy Begins

(00:18:05) MLB Playoff Updates

(00:21:05) Jaxson Dart Injury Discussion

(00:27:10) Jets Desperation Against Browns

They react to a controversial report from Chris Kirshner suggesting Aaron Judge might be putting on an act regarding his disappointment over the Yankees' season. The discussion also covers the Giants' 3-0 home start and the perceived lack of mental toughness in the current New York sports landscape.

(00:01:25) Marcus King and Noah Kahan

(00:04:32) Dying In Your Dreams

(00:07:48) Giants Playoff Lock Statistics

(00:11:35) Evaluating The Giants Roster

(00:18:22) Kirshner On Aaron Judge

(00:22:40) Jeter Era Mental Toughness

(00:26:05) The Athletic Reporting Wars

(00:30:28) Firing Squad Execution Discussion