One day in 1999, a man named Bill Bannerman and the five members of a soon-to-be-VERY-famous pop punk outfit sat in a basement room with a dogeared copy of a little book called "Abby the Bad Sport." What they discovered in that tome would be the stuff of legend. Listen in as your favorite podcast boys recreate that heady conversation, delving into Abby’s rotten attitude, Shannon Kilbourne’s confusing extracurricular activities, Jackie Rodowsky’s travels through the universe, and Claudia Kishi’s most daring outfit yet. And to make matters even more fascinating this week, Tanner loses a battle with peanut butter, and Jack learns how to do a knock-knock joke, so there’s plenty of good stuff to balance out Abby’s shoddy behavior.

Music credits:

“The Energetic Rock,” by InflectionPoint

“Eternity,” by Whitesand

“Chopstick Slapstick,” by OurMusicBox

“Slash,” by Arc North

Thanks as always to original Baby Boy Scott Lamb for the intro music, and to Superbrat for the outro music.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices