Send us Fan Mail

This week on IPWatchdog Unleashed, our host and the founder of IPWatchdog, Gene Quinn, speaks with former USPTO Director, Andrei Iancu. The conversation begins with Iancu’s path from engineering at Hughes Aircraft to intellectual property law, including his early years at the IP boutique Lyon & Lyon and his later experience as a leading patent litigator and law firm managing partner at Irell & Manella. From there, Quinn and Iancu examine the cyclical nature of IP practice, the migration of patent litigation into large general practice firms, and the growing commoditization of patent litigation work. 

The discussion then turns to the structural imbalance facing patent owners in today’s enforcement environment. Quinn and Iancu address Section 101 motions to dismiss, PTAB challenges, routine litigation stays, Federal Circuit scrutiny, and the practical erosion of injunctive relief after a patent owner has already run the litigation gauntlet and proved infringement. Iancu explains that defendants now have many more pathways to victory than patent owners, who must prevail repeatedly across multiple forums and legal standards before securing meaningful relief. The result, they suggest, is a system that often no longer operates like a patent is an exclusive property right as was contemplated by the Constitution.

The conversation ultimately broadens into a first-principles discussion about what the U.S. patent system should look like in the 21st century. Iancu argues that the current framework, rooted in 18th-century statutory realities, is struggling to accommodate software, artificial intelligence, data, biotechnology, and other information-driven innovations. Quinn and Iancu explore whether a one-size-fits-all patent system still makes sense, whether sui generis rights may be necessary for emerging technologies, and how any future innovation framework must balance two core objectives: incentivizing investment in risky innovation while ensuring meaningful public disclosure.

Visit us online at IPWatchdog.com.

You can also visit our channels at YouTube, LinkedIn, X, Instagram and Facebook.