October 28, 2024

CIP 150: Time's Up Series - The High Cost of Staying in Canada Illegally

33 minutes

Episode 150: Time's Up Series - The High Cost of Staying in Canada Illegally

In this episode of the Canadian Immigration Podcast, Mark Holthe and immigration lawyer Alicia Backman-Beharry continue their Time’s Up series by delving into the significant risks and long-term consequences of staying in Canada without legal status. As temporary resident options narrow, many individuals face tough decisions about whether to stay or leave. Mark and Alicia discuss the legal, financial, and emotional realities for those who overstay, and offer strategic advice on why compliance with immigration laws is critical for safeguarding future opportunities.

The hosts also address myths surrounding the possibility of amnesty and provide practical options for restoring status. They outline when it’s time to explore restoration, when applying for temporary resident permits (TRPs) makes sense, and why leaving Canada voluntarily may sometimes be the smartest move. Tune in to learn how recent policy changes, economic pressures, and the upcoming federal election are reshaping the immigration landscape in Canada—and what you can do to stay ahead.

Topics Covered:

1. The Legal Landscape of Immigration Status

Overview of Canada’s immigration rules under Regulation 183 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR).

What happens when your work permit, study permit, or visitor visa expires.

The importance of tracking multiple expiry dates, including biometrics and passport validity.

Inadmissibility under Section 41: Why overstaying your permit leads to legal penalties.

2. The Immediate and Long-Term Consequences of Staying Without Status

Loss of health care, SIN, and driver’s license: How being out of status cuts off essential services.

Employment risks: Unstable jobs, exploitation, and under-the-table wages.

Psychological toll: Living with the fear of deportation.

International travel risks: Information sharing between countries and how overstays impact future visa applications abroad.

3. Debunking Myths: Will Canada Offer Amnesty?

Why amnesties and public policy measures like the 18-month post-grad permit extension are unlikely in the current political and economic environment.

Impact of labour shortages, housing constraints, and political pressures on future immigration policy.

The reality of immigration caps on temporary residents, international students, and LMIA-based permits.

4. Why Leaving Canada Voluntarily May Be the Right Move

Strategic benefits of returning home before your status expires:

Maintain a clean immigration record to reapply in the future.

Gain foreign work experience to increase Express Entry CRS points.

Position yourself for future opportunities through intra-company transfers or new pathways.

Scenario planning: What happens if you leave voluntarily versus waiting for removal proceedings.

How voluntary compliance makes it easier to return to Canada legally later on.

5. Employers to Avoid and Hidden Costs of Staying Illegal

Risks of working without status:

Unfair wages and lack of employment protections.

Legal penalties for employers hiring undocumented workers.

The danger of marriages of convenience:

How immigration officers detect fraudulent marriages.

The consequences of using a relationship solely for immigration status.

6. Preparing for Future Episodes in the Time’s Up Series

Upcoming episodes will dive deeper into:

Restoring status and when it’s your best option.

Temporary Resident Permits (TRPs): When and how to apply.

Humanitarian and Compassionate (H&C) applications: When extraordinary circumstances warrant this path.

Refugee claims: Why this option isn’t suitable for everyone.

An analysis of political party platforms and their potential impact on immigration policy ahead of the next election.

Key Takeaways:

Act Early: Don’t wait until your status expires—start exploring your options well in advance.

Compliance is Critical: Staying illegally can have long-term consequences for your ability to return to Canada or apply elsewhere.

Don’t Rely on Amnesty: Policy changes are unpredictable, and there is no guarantee of future extensions or public policies.

Leaving May Be a Strategic Move: Voluntarily returning to your home country can keep your immigration options open for the future.

Resources Mentioned:

Holthe Immigration Law: Book a consultation for personalized legal advice.

Canadian Immigration Institute YouTube Channel: Join Mark’s live Q&A sessions and stay up to date on immigration changes.

DIY Immigration Courses: Explore practical courses at the Canadian Immigration Institute for:

Express Entry Accelerator: Get step-by-step guidance for Express Entry applications.

Temporary Resident Visa Course: Learn how to navigate visitor visa applications.

Upcoming courses: Spousal Sponsorship, Citizenship, and Study Permits.

Disclaimer:

This podcast provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. For personalized guidance, please book a consultation with an immigration lawyer at Holthe Immigration Law.

Listen to This Episode On:

Spotify

iTunes

Holthe Immigration Podcast Website

Connect with Us:

YouTube: Canadian Immigration Institute

Facebook: Canadian Immigration Podcast

LinkedIn: Mark Holthe

...more

View all episodes

By Mark Holthe

4.7

2424 ratings